TABLE 1

Comparison between different simulation models in 1D with U = 0.05

sR/Ua MoranSDa MoranR/Ub WFSDb WFR/Uc Haigh
0.00010.9360.0090.9500.0060.960
0.00020.9170.0270.8970.0080.907
0.00040.8300.0220.8440.0120.854
0.00080.7510.0210.7440.0080.762
0.00160.6460.0180.6480.0200.658
0.00320.5150.0100.5070.0160.520
0.00640.3540.0140.3440.0080.366
0.01280.1910.0040.1870.0080.200
0.02560.0490.0010.0450.0010.050
  • a Moran model run with population size = 1000 for at least 500 clicks and at least 50,000 generations: average and standard deviation from five replicate runs.

  • b Wright–Fisher model run with N = 500 for at least 500 clicks and at least 50,000 generations: average and standard deviation from five replicate runs.

  • c Haigh model run with N = 500 for at least 5000 clicks and at least 500,000 generations: a single run with estimated standard error of at most 1.5%.