Abstract
We report that Cas9/gRNA mediates efficient genetic modifications in Drosophila. Through targeting seven loci, we achieved a germline efficiency of up to 100%. Genes in both heterochromatin and euchromatin can be modified efficiently. Thus the Cas9/gRNA system is an attractive tool for rapid disruption of essentially any gene in Drosophila.
DROSOPHILA is considered as one of the best animal models due to its amenability to a wide repertoire of genetic tools including gene targeting by homologous recombination (Rong and Golic 2000; Gong and Golic 2003). However, the traditional gene-targeting method can be considered labor intensive if one’s goal is to simply generate knock-out mutations. Alternatively, designer nucleases (ZFN and TALEN) have been introduced into Drosophila to direct site-specific DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) in the coding region of a target gene (Carroll 2011; Liu et al. 2012). During nonhomologous end joining (NHEJ) repair of the DSBs, mutations at the cut site lead to disruption of the target gene. For both ZFN and TALEN, each chromosomal target site requires the construction of a pair of genes encoding the nuclease, which can be a significant investment if one’s goal is to knock out multiple genes. Recently, the type II prokaryotic CRISPR (clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats) system from bacteria has been introduced into several heterologous systems for the purpose of generating targeted mutations (Chang et al. 2013; Cong et al. 2013; Hwang et al. 2013; Mali et al. 2013; Shen et al. 2013; Wei et al. 2013). The CRISPR-associated nuclease Cas9 is guided to its target cut site by a small RNA molecule (gRNA), which shares a region of about 20-nt homology to its target DNA. Therefore, the same Cas9 protein can be directed to multiple chromosome sites depending solely on the sequence of the guide RNA. Here we targeted multiple genes with different gRNAs and achieved remarkable efficiency of targeted mutagenesis, including heterochromatic genes.
Results
Cas9 induced mutations at yellow
As a proof of principle for the functionality of the Cas9/gRNA system in Drosophila, we chose the yellow locus to conduct our first target mutagenesis. We designed gRNAs to target two different sites in the yellow coding region (y1-gRNA and y2-gRNA; Supporting Information, Figure S1). The gRNA along with in vitro transcribed Cas9 mRNA were injected into y+ w1118 embryos. The results from targeting yellow were summarized in Table 1.
For y1-gRNA, 80% of the injected F0 males showed somatic yellow mosaicism suggesting that Cas9/y1-gRNA induced yellow mutations in somatic cells (Figure S1C). We crossed F0 adults to y w flies to recover Cas9 induced yellow mutations in the germline. For y1-gRNA, between 30 and 67% of the F0 yield at least one yellow offspring; 7–13% of the fertile flies inherited the Cas9-cut chromosome appearing as yellow mutants. For y2-gRNA, 36% of the F0 were mosaic for yellow; 59–68% of them yield yellow offspring and 7–9% of the total progeny were yellow mutants. Sequencing identified small insertions and/or deletions (indels) at y1 or y2 in these individuals that bear signatures of nonhomologous end joining (NHEJ) repair (Figure S1D). Therefore, Cas9 can efficiently induce indel mutations at yellow in both the male and female germline.
Cas9 induced mutations at other euchromatic loci
To further demonstrate the functionality of the Cas9 system in Drosophila, we selected three additional euchromatic loci. Mutations of the ms(3)k81 locus cause male sterility (Fuyama 1986). No mutation has been characterized for either CG3708 or CG9652. Results for this series of targeted mutagenesis are reported in Table 2.
For ms(3)k81, we designed a gRNA that would result in Cas9 cutting at an RsaI restriction site. We reasoned that indels at this site would destroy the cut site and render a PCR fragment across this site resistant to RsaI digestion. Interestingly, all 17 F0 males were sterile. Some of the sterility must be an artifact from the micro-injection as 12 of the 20 females were also sterile. However, another possibility is that some of the male sterility could be due to simultaneous disruption of both ms(3)k81 copies on homologous chromosomes in the germinal nuclei, which are determined to develop into germ cells. We subjected these sterile males along with several randomly selected F0 female to PCR amplification followed by RsaI digestion (Figure S2A). While the PCR fragment from uninjected controls could be fully digested with RsaI, the PCR from F0 flies showed no sign of digestion, suggesting that in most, if not all, of the PCR fragments, the RsaI site had been mutated due to Cas9 cutting. Our proposition was supported when we assayed the mutation frequency in the female germline. Of all the 88 progeny randomly selected from 8 fertile F0 females, 87 were mutant for ms(3)k81 as assayed by RsaI digestion, DNA sequencing, and complementation with an existing ms(3)k81 mutation (Figure S3).
For CG3708, we designed a gRNA to direct Cas9 cutting at a BpmI site (Figure S2B). About 35% of the randomly selected progeny carried an indel at the BpmI site as assayed by both BpmI digestion of PCR fragments and DNA sequencing (Figure S4). For CG9652, we recovered two germline events with an indel out of 94 events sequenced (Figure S5). This frequency seemed rather low when compared to those from targeting the other loci. The underlying cause requires further investigations. In summary, we successfully targeted three different euchromatic loci using Cas9/gRNA. The germline frequency ranged from about 2% to essentially 100%.
Cas9 induced mutations at heterochromatic loci
The heterochromatic portion of the genome is generally considered inert. Yet it contains functional genes, some of which are essential for viability or fertility. We selected three different heterochromatic loci for targeted mutagenesis: the kl-3 fertility factor on the Y chromosome, the light, and RpL15 loci on autosomes.
For kl-3, all of the 29 F0 males were sterile, yet only 4 of 37 F0 females were sterile (Table 2), suggesting that in all of the F0 males, most if not all of the germ cells carried a nonfunctional kl-3 locus, possibly due to Cas9-induced indel mutations. To provide support for this proposition, we PCR amplified the Cas9 targeted region in kl-3 from individual F0 males. DNA sequencing revealed multiple peaks around the Cas9 cut site, consistent with the PCR products being a mixture carrying different indels of kl-3 (Figure S2D and Figure S7).
For the RpL15 locus, we observed something similar to that observed when targeting ms(3)k81, which might have been frequent alteration of both gene copies in addition to a possible off-target effects. Of the 800 embryos injected, none developed beyond the first-instar stage. This lethal phase matches that of existing RpL15 mutations (Schulze et al. 2001), suggesting that both RpL15 copies had been disrupted in the injected individuals. Consistently, PCR products of the Cas9-targeted region amplified from dying F0 larvae could not be digested with the NspI enzyme, although in wild-type DNA they could (Figure S2C). DNA sequencing of PCR products from F0 animals revealed the presence of indels (Figure S8).
For the light gene, DNA sequencing of 50 randomly selected F1 adults identified 9 indel events representing a frequency of 18% (Figure S6)
Discussion
As this article was being prepared, Gratz et al. (2013) reported the successful application of Cas9 to induce germline mutations in the yellow gene of Drosophila. In addition, they were able to use the yellow phenotype to recover deletions of yellow, along with an insertion of a 50bp attP attachment for phiC31. The frequencies reported by Gratz and colleagues were generally lower than the frequencies that we were able to achieve. One likely cause for this difference is the fact that both the mRNA for Cas9 and the gRNA were in vitro transcribed in our study so that a large amount can be injected into the embryos. Remarkably, we were able to achieve germline targeting of ms(3)k81 at essentially 100% efficiency. To avoid any negative effects of too high efficiency, one may consider injecting less of gRNAs and/or injecting only gRNAs into flies that stably express a low amount of Cas9 protein. The results from targeting kl-3 and RpL15 suggest that such efficiency is achievable even for heterochromatic loci. (See File S1, Table S1, Table S2, and Table S3.)
Acknowledgments
We thank Dr. Jingwei Xiong for providing the plasmid of pMD19-T gRNA scaffold vector, Wei Wei and Wenyuan Li for technical assistance in DNA sequencing and constructing the pSP6-2sNLS-spcas9 plasmid, and Dr. Hui Wang for providing the bacterium strain of S. pyogenes that contains the Cas9 gene. This work was supported by the grants from the National Natural Science Foundation of China, NSFC (31171278, 31271542). R.J. is supported by the grants from the 973 program (2009CB918702 and 2012CB825504) and the NSFC (31071087 and 31271573). Research in Y.S.R.’s laboratory is supported by the intramural program of National Cancer Institute.
Footnotes
Communicating editor: D. A. Barbash
- Received May 31, 2013.
- Accepted June 28, 2013.
- Copyright © 2013 by the Genetics Society of America