Abstract
We have analyzed the requirements for the multi sex combs (mxc) gene during development to gain further insight into the mechanisms and developmental processes that depend on the important trans-regulators forming the Polycomb group (PcG) in Drosophila melanogaster. mxc is allelic with the tumor suppressor locus lethal (1) malignant blood neoplasm (l(1)mbn). We show that the mxc product is dramatically needed in most tissues because its loss leads to cell death after a few divisions. mxc has also a strong maternal effect. We find that hypomorphic mxc mutations enhance other PcG gene mutant phenotypes and cause ectopic expression of homeotic genes, confirming that PcG products are cooperatively involved in repression of selector genes outside their normal expression domains. We also demonstrate that the mxc product is needed for imaginal head specification, through regulation of the ANT-C gene Deformed. Our analysis reveals that mxc is involved in the maternal control of early zygotic gap gene expression previously reported for some PcG genes and suggests that the mechanism of this early PcG function could be different from the PcG-mediated regulation of homeotic selector genes later in development. We discuss these data in view of the numerous functions of PcG genes during development.
THE strict control of the expression of the Hox and HOM genes, which specify identities along the antero-posterior body axis (Krumlauf 1994; Lawrence and Morata 1994), involves a mechanism that appears conserved between flies and vertebrates (Alkemaet al. 1997; Coreet al. 1997; reviews by Pirrotta 1997; Schumacher and Magnuson 1997). Silence maintenance requires the Polycomb group (PcG) genes that are negative trans-regulators of the homeotic genes, but they are also needed for control of other selector genes. In Drosophila, the group counts at least a dozen members that regulate HOM gene expression in embryos and larvae (Jürgens 1985; reviewed by Paro 1995; Pirrotta 1997). Expression of these targets is initially correct in PcG mutants, but later becomes ectopic, demonstrating that PcG products fix the repressed state of the genes that they regulate (Busturia and Morata 1988; McKeon and Brock 1991; Simonet al. 1992). The products of polyhomeotic (ph) and Polycomb (Pc) associate with other proteins in a multimeric complex (Frankeet al. 1992) that binds to about one hundred sites on polytene chromosomes (Zink and Paro 1989; De Camilliset al. 1992; Frankeet al. 1992). Proteins encoded by Posterior sex combs (Psc), Suppressor 2 of zeste (Su(z)2), Polycomb-like (Pcl), and Enhancer of zeste [E(z)] share many binding sites with PH and PC, including the two HOM gene clusters (Martin and Adler 1993; Rastelliet al. 1993; Lonieet al. 1994; Carrington and Jones 1996). These binding sites define a large set of potential targets for PcG-mediated regulation. extra sex comb (esc) products, which are only transiently present in the embryo, might regulate HOM gene expression by promoting the initial binding of the multimeric complexes to chromatin (Simonet al. 1995). PcG products are thought to organize the structure of their targets in such a way that the targets remain repressed throughout development, possibly by limiting the access of different transcription factors to these genes (Paro 1990; Schlossherret al. 1994; McCall and Bender 1996).
HOM gene regulation is not the only process that depends on PcG control because several amorphic PcG mutations have dramatic effects on cell viability or chromosome morphology. Embryonic development cannot proceed without maternal polyhomeotic product, and loss of maternal pleiohomeotic (pho) or zygotic ph leads to incomplete head involution associated with holes in the cuticle, likely due to massive epidermal apoptotic cell death (Breen and Duncan 1986; Dura et al. 1987, 1988; Abramset al. 1993; Girton and Jeon 1994). The E(z) product participates in some basic cellular process governing chromosome structure because loss of E(z) causes abnormal chromosome morphology and condensation (Gatti and Baker 1989; Phillips and Shearn 1990).
The Sex combs on midleg (Scm) protein shows sequence similarity with the product of lethal(3)malignant brain tumor (l(3)mbt), a Drosophila tumor suppressor gene that controls brain cell division and differentiation, suggesting a link between PcG proteins and the products controlling cell proliferation (Wismaret al. 1995; Bornemannet al. 1996). Furthermore, preliminary studies of the pleiotropic PcG gene multi sex combs (mxc) have demonstrated that mxc is allelic with lethal(1)malignant blood neoplasm (l(1)mbn), another tumor suppressor gene that controls hemocyte proliferation in larvae (Gateff 1978; Santamaria and Randsholt 1995). mxc is also needed in both males and females at all stages of germline development, where the most extreme defects caused by loss of mxc are similar to proliferation defects (Docquieret al. 1996). In so far as the wild-type mxc product controls HOM gene expression and hemocyte as well as germline proliferation in Drosophila, it provides a possible link between maintenance of cell identities and tumor suppression. A key question concerning mxc is how control of proliferation and of selector gene expression could be connected. To understand this better, we have extended our genetic studies of mxc to determine in which cells mxc product is crucially needed for cell identities, cell division, and cell survival, and which target genes might be responsible for (some of) the pleiotropic mutant mxc phenotypes.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Fly stocks and culture: Fly cultures were maintained on standard culture medium at 23° or 25°, unless otherwise stated in the text. Df(1)mxc1 is a small deletion obtained by excision of a P element inserted close to mxc (F. Forquignon, unpublished results). All other mxc deficiencies, duplications, and alleles used in the present study have been described by Santamaria and Randsholt (1995) or by Docquier et al. (1996). Their major characteristics are summarized in Table 1 (see also results section). All mxc strains are y1, and mxc larvae were recognized by their yellow mouth-hooks. PcG gene alleles tested in mxcM1/Y;PcG/+ transheterozygous males were the following: Additional sex combs, AsxXF23; extra sex combs, escr4; Enhancer of zeste, E(z)1, E(z)60 E(z)62, E(z)63, and E(z)70 (provided by R. Jones); Polycomb, Pc K; Polycomb-like, PclXM3; pleiohomeotic, phob; Posterior sex combs, Psc1 and PscO; Sex combs extra, Sce1; Sex combs on midleg, ScmD1; super sex combs, sxc1. The Gull allele of fat (Mahoneyet al. 1991) was provided by P. Bryant, the Deformed null allele Dfd16 by T. Kaufman, and the DfdD mutation (Chadwicket al. 1990) by W. McGinnis. lacZ enhancer traps or reporter genes were the following: cubitus interruptus-lacZ, ci-lacZ (Orenicet al. 1990); decapentaplegic-lacZ, dpp-lacZ (Blackmanet al. 1991); engrailed-lacZ, en-lacZ (Hamaet al. 1990); ftz-lacZ, FM7c p[(ry+)ftz:lacZ] where lacZ is expressed in the striped ftz pattern as early as the blastoderm; hedgehog-lacZ, hh-lacZ (Leeet al. 1992); patched-lacZ, ptc-lacZ (Lepageet al. 1995); spalt-lacZ provided by K. Basler (Nellenet al. 1996); Ultrabithorax, Ubx-lacZ (line 35UZ-3; Irvineet al. 1991); and wingless-lacZ CyO, wg-lacZ (Kassiset al. 1992). Line pbG1-lacZ, a gift from D. Cribbs, is expressed in the head primordia and in several other imaginal territories. The decapentaplegic alleles dppd6 and dppshv (from W. Gelbart and the Bloomington Stock Center) were described by St. Johnson et al. (1990). For description of PcG gene mutant phenotypes of all other stains and variants, see Lindsley and Zimm (1992).
Cuticle preparations and phenotype ratings: Embryos were dechorionated with bleach and mounted in Hoyer's medium. Larval cuticles were also mounted in Hoyer's medium. Tissues with melanotic pseudotumors were dissected from second or third instar larvae. Adult phenotypes were rated in at least 20 adults (40 halves) for each genetic combination. Flies were collected 24 to 48 hr after emergence or dissected from pupal cases for combinations lethal as pharate adults and incubated in acetic acid:glycerol (4:1) at 65° overnight. Flies were then dissected, mounted in Hoyer's medium, and examined at ×40 magnification. Extra sex-comb teeth were counted on all three legs.
Embryos mutant for mxc22a-1 and mxcG48 represent one-fourth of progeny from y1 mxc 22a-1/FM7c and y1 mxc G48/FM7c females mated to mxc+ males. For antibody staining, y1 mxcG48 was balanced with FM7c p[(ry+)ftz:lacZ] and nonmutant embryos were recognized by the striped ftz-lacZ pattern. Rescue of nos phenotypes by mxc was tested with mxcG48, mxc22a-1, mxcmbn1, Df(1)lz10-70d, and Df(1)mxc1 at 25°. mxc/FM7hb7MnosL7/TM3 females were crossed to +/Y;TM3/nosL7 males. Batches of 2- to 3-day-old mxc/+;hb7MnosL7/nosL7 females were then crossed to mxc+ males. Segmentation was evaluated on resulting embryos. As a control in each experiment, sibling +/FM7;hb7MnosL7/nosL7 females were crossed to wild-type males and segmentation of progeny estimated. Similar crosses, using balanced stocks to recognize the different genotypes, served to construct mxcG48/+;Df(2)vgB/+;hb7MnosL7/nosL7 and mxcG48/+;hb7MnosL7/nosL7;phob/+ flies. Possible effects of Gull were tested in the progeny of crosses between y ac z mxc/FM7 females and +/Y;al Gull b pr/CyO males. Phenotypic interactions between dpp and mxc were evaluated among the progenies of dppd6/CyO females crossed with +/Dp(1Y)FF1″pd6/CyO males, or in y ac z mxcG43/FM7″pshv/dppshv and y ac z mxc G43/FM7″pd6/dppd6 flies. To evaluate phenotype enhancement by other PcG alleles, batches of mxcM1/FM7 females were crossed to balanced strains carrying autosomal PcG mutations. mxc M1/Y;PcG/+ males were identified by the absence of dominant balancer chromosome markers. Interactions between DfdD and mxc were observed in mxcM1/Y;DfdD/+, mxcG46/Y;Dfd D/+, and mxc G43/Y;DfdD/+ individuals from crosses between mxc/FM7 females and DfdD/DfdD males, and in mxcG43/Y;Dfd16/+ compared to mxcG43/Y;TM3/+ males.
Recombinant mitotic clones: Mitotic recombinant clones homozygous for mxc 22a-1 were induced by irradiating batches of y1 mxc 22a-1 f36a/+;mwh jv/+ larvae 24, 48, 72, and 96 hr before puparium formation (BPF) with 1000 rad (45 kV and 25 mA for 3 min 10 sec) and observing the resulting adult flies under a dissection microscope. Experimental clones were marked with y1 f36a and control clones with mwh jv.
X-gal staining of embryos and imaginal discs: Embryos were treated as described by Docquier et al. (1996). Imaginal discs were dissected in 1× PBS from staged larvae, fixed in 1× PBS, 3.7% formaldehyde for 5 min at room temperature, washed in 1× PBS, and stained as for embryos.
Antibody staining: Embryos were treated as described by MacDonald and Struhl (1986). Imaginal tissues were stained according to Lajeunesse and Shearn (1996). Primary antibodies were directed against proteins from Sex combs reduced (Scr) (provided by W. Gehring), from Deformed and labial (lab) (a gift from M. Scott), from Ultrabithorax (Ubx) (antibody FP3.38, provided by T. Braverman), and from Abdominal-B (Abd-B) (a gift from S. Celniker).
Acridine orange staining of imaginal discs: mxc mbn1/Y and mxc16a-1/Y third instar imaginal discs were dissected in Ringer's solution, incubated 5 min in 5 μg/ml acridine orange (AO), rinsed in Ringer's, and immediately observed under a fluorescence microscope.
Brain squashes: Larval brains were dissected in 0.7% NaCl, fixed for 30 sec each in 45 and 60% acetic acid. Tissues were stained for 1 min in a drop of orcein solution (2% orcein in 45% acetic acid) on a coverslip and then squashed between the coverslip and a clean slide and observed under the microscope. Brains were dissected from second instar y1 mxcG48/Y and from third instar y1 mxc 16a-1/Y larvae raised at 25°.
Characteristics of mxc alleles
RESULTS
Characteristics of mxc alleles: Some features of all mxc alleles used in this study (Table 1) have been described previously (Gateff and Mechler 1989; Santamaria and Randsholt 1995; Docquieret al. 1996). mxcG48 and mxc22a-1 are lethal during the second larval instar as hemizygotes or homozygotes but also in trans with each other or in trans with the deficiency Df(1)lz10-70d that uncovers the mxc locus. Furthermore, females that carry a given hypomorphic mxc allele in trans with either Df(1)lz10-70d, mxcG48, or mxc22a-1 exhibit similar phenotypes. mxcG48 and mxc22a-1 are thus both potential amorphic alleles. All mxc alleles are strictly recessive and can be totally rescued by Dp(1Y)FF1. Classification of hypomorphic alleles from mxcM1 to mxc16a-1 is based on their increasingly severe phenotypes, including fertility and germline development (Docquieret al. 1996), homeotic transformations (Santamaria and Randsholt 1995), abnormal immune responses (Gateff and Mechler 1989; Santamaria and Randsholt 1995; and see below), and lethality stage.
mxc− is lethal in larvae and in clones: The potential amorphic alleles, mxcG48 and mxc22a-1, were used to determine the mxc null phenotypes and lethality stage. Hemizygous y1 mxcG48 and y1 mxc22a-1 embryos hatch with normal cuticles. These animals exhibit no transformation of their anterior segments toward abdominal segment 8 (A8). As mxc is important for head specification (see below), we paid special attention to head structures but no difference from wild type was observed. y1 mxcG48/Y and y1 mxc22a-1/Y larvae are smaller than wild type and attain the second instar with about 24 hr delay. Most of them die several days later without going through a second molt. They exhibit gut-specific melanizations or pseudotumors (Sparrow 1978) that first affect the imaginal hindgut ring and later cover the posterior gut (Figure 6). All their major imaginal discs are smaller than wild type, but they contain anterior and posterior compartments, as revealed by lacZ expression in the posterior compartment imaginal disc cells of second instar y1 mxcG48/Y;en-lacZ/+ larvae (data not shown).
Loss of zygotic mxc at later stages of development was achieved by irradiating y1 mxc22a-1 f36a/+;mwh jv/+ larvae BPF. No y1 f36a clones were found on individuals irradiated earlier than 48 hr BPF; 0.2 clone per hemi-notum was observed between 24 and 48 hr BPF, and only 0.5 clone on the hemi-notums of flies irradiated between 0 and 24 hr BPF. All clones were tiny, formed at most by a few cells, because they never included more than a single y1 f36a bristle. Such clones would be too small to be seen in the wing blade. mxc22a-1 clones were never observed on the abdomen either. Similar results were observed with y1 mxcG48 f36a/+ adults that had been irradiated in larvae. Control mwh jv clones appeared on the wings of the irradiated y1 mxc22a-1 f36/+;mwh jv/+ flies with expected frequency and size (about 4.6 mwh jv clones per wing and 22 cells per clone for flies irradiated 24 to 48 hr BPF). These data show that loss of zygotic mxc causes cell-autonomous lethality and that mxco cells divide only a few times before dying.
Maternal effects of mxc: The lethality stage and mitotic clone data for the strongest mxc alleles suggested that mxc product is either first required in larvae or, alternatively, that maternal mxc product allows normal development until the second larval instar. To test this, we examined the maternal effect on embryonic development of a viable hypomorphic mxc allele. Germline clones that are homozygous for amorphic or strong hypomorphic mxc alleles do not develop and most mutant mxc females lay no eggs (Docquieret al. 1996). Maternal mxc requirement was therefore evaluated in mxcM1 progeny because a few embryos from mxcM1/mxcM1 mothers show some development. mxcM1/mxc M1 females were crossed to wild type (Cross 1) or to mxcM1/Y males (Cross 2), to see whether the paternal mxc+ copy has an effect. The most-developed embryos from Cross 1 have posterior “filzkörper,” spiracles, and denticle belts, but head involution is seldom observed, dorsal closure is incomplete, and their segmentation is abnormal, especially on more anterior segments (Figure 1B). The segmentation defects include fusions and deletions of segments or of parts of segments. Occasional lateralized patches of denticle belts are also found, but we detected no homeotic transformations on the cuticles of these animals. The remaining Cross 1 embryos contain tiny pieces of necrotic tissue and have either no recognizable structures, or exhibit patches of differentiated cuticle with a few denticles and one posterior spiracle or “filz-körper” (Figure 1C). Statistical treatment of data from Cross 1 is difficult because <10% of the embryos develop. We assumed the first category to be mxcM1/+ embryos, because they made up 51% (35/68) of the largest batch that we examined. The others would thus be mxcM1/Y individuals. All progeny from Cross 2 are small with very severe phenotypes. These embryos were similar to the putative mxcM1/Y individuals from Cross 1 (Figure 1D). We conclude that maternal mxc is critically required for embryogenesis. A partial rescue of the maternal effect by paternal mxc+ is seen but cannot restore normal development.
Maternal effect of mxc. All embryos are anterior to the left. Cuticle preparations (A to D) are shown in a ventral view. X-gal stained embryos (E to H) are presented in a latero-ventral angle. (A) Cuticle of wild-type embryo. (B and C) Embryos from mxc M1/mxcM1 females crossed to wild-type males. (D) Embryo of mxc M1/mxcM1 mother crossed to a mxc M1/Y male. (E) hh-lacZ expression in a wild-type embryo at germband retraction. (F) Same in embryo from mxc M1/mxcM1 mother crossed to an hh-lacZ/hh-lacZ male. (G) Expression of dpp-lacZ in a wild-type embryo at germband retraction. (H) Same in embryo from a mxcM1/mxcM1 female crossed with a dpp-lacZ/dpp-lacZ male.
The structural defects of these embryos could be correlated with deregulation of genes controlling embryonic patterning. To see if this were the case, we examined mxcM1/mxcM1 progenies that carried lacZ reporter genes for the segment polarity genes en or hedgehog (hh), or for the dorso-ventral specifying gene decapentaplegic (dpp). In wild type, en-lacZ and hh-lacZ are expressed in a series of stripes corresponding to the posterior compartments of each segment (Figure 1E). en-lacZ/+ or hh-lacZ/+ embryos from mxcM1/mxcM1 mothers exhibit unevenly distributed stripes or parts of stripes (Figure 1F, and data not shown). The wild-type dpp-lacZ reporter gene marks head structures and, in each segment, a cluster of cells that are part of the imaginal disc or the histoblast primordium (Figure 1G). In mxcM1/mxcM1 progeny, head-specific dpp-lacZ staining is seldom seen, and the number of latero-ventral cell clusters is reduced (Figure 1H). In the embryos from mxcM1/mxcM1 mothers, the en-lacZ or hh-lacZ stripes do not appear larger than in wild type, and the dpp-lacZ reporter gene shows no sign of ectopic expression either. These results indicate that the drastic maternal effects of mxcM1 on embryonic development are likely not caused by deregulation of en, hh, or dpp.
Although maternal mxc+ product is sufficient to specify wild-type larval cuticle in amorphs, we tested whether homeotic gene expression was normal in mxcG48/Y embryos. Indeed, elimination of zygotic PcG products can sometimes have an effect on homeotic gene expression before the physiological modifications are detected on the embryos, or without causing adult structures to be homeotically transformed (Dura and Ingham 1988; N. B. Randsholt, unpublished result). Embryos from mxcG48/+ females were stained with antibodies directed against the proteins coded by Deformed, labial, Sex combs reduced, Ultrabithorax, and AbdominalB. All these products are normally expressed in mxcG48/Y embryos (not shown). Hence the maternal mxc+ component covers all needs for homeotic gene regulation during embryogenesis.
A mutant mxc product can partially rescue the maternal nos phenotype: The regionalization of the Drosophila embryo depends on the maternally supplied products of bicoid (bcd), hunchback (hb), and nanos (nos). NOS represses the translation of the maternal hb mRNA in the posterior embryonic region. This permits the expression of the zygotic gap genes knirps (kni) and giant (gt) that specify posterior identities. These genes would otherwise be repressed by HB (reviewed by St. Johnston 1993). Embryos from nos/nos mothers form no abdominal segments, but this phenotype can be rescued by a total lack of hb in the maternal germline. It can also be dominantly rescued by the mutation of maternally supplied regulator molecules that normally repress kni and gt in the zygote. Pelegri and Lehmann (1994) have shown that certain mutant products of the PcG genes E(z), Psc, and pho can partially rescue nos by such a maternal effect. To determine if mutation of mxc also affects this regulation, we examined the cuticles of embryos from mxc/+;hb7Mnos L7/nosL7 mothers that were heterozygous for different mxc mutations. We used this genetic background because a decrease in the amount of maternal hb product can partially rescue the nos phenotype in F1 embryos (Irishet al. 1989). Such embryos can differentiate a few abdominal denticle belts (Figure 2) and form an adequate background to evaluate increased rescue of nos.
Rescue of hb nos/nos progeny by mxc. (A) Embryo from hb7MnosL7/nosL7 female. (B–C) Rescue of embryos from mxcG48/+; hb7MnosL7/nosL7 females can be partial as in B or total, as shown in C (compare C to wild-type embryo in Figure 1A).
We compared the progenies of young hb7Mnos L7/nosL7 mothers heterozygous for five mxc variants to those of their FM7/+;hb7MnosL7/nosL7 sisters (Table 2). An average of 2.0% of the embryos from the FM7/+;hb7MnosL7/nos L7 females differentiate three or more abdominal segments, although as many as 5.8% of such embryos were seen in one control (Table 2). No rescue of the maternal nos phenotype was seen with deficiencies for mxc or with the mutant alleles mxc22a-1 and mxcmbn1. The progeny of mxcG48/+;hb7Mnos L7/nosL7 females show a strongly increased rescue, because 21.7% of the embryos differentiated three or more abdominal segments (Table 2 and Figure 2). It is interesting that mxcG48 and mxc22a-1 behave differently in this genetic context, showing that only mxc22a-1 is like the deficiency. By following the development of embryos from mxcG48/+;hb7MnosL7/nosL7 mothers, we showed that this combination also permits a more than 10-fold increase in the number of hatching first instar larvae, and in the rescue of adult progeny (Table 3). The adult escapers have abnormal tergites and are mostly fertile. Together these data show that a mutant maternal mxc product can affect gap gene regulation during early embryogenesis, whereas a decrease in maternal mxc+ product apparently has no such effect.
Several PcG genes appear to participate with mxc in gap gene regulation, but the mechanism involved is not entirely clear. The effects of PcG mutations on homeotic gene regulation are synergistically enhanced in transheterozygotes that carry hypomorphic and especially amorphic mutations of two PcG genes (Jürgens 1985; Moazed and O'Farrell 1992), indicating that all these products are involved in a common regulatory process. If early gap gene regulation by PcG products functions in a similar manner, then greater rescue of nos phenotypes should be obtained from hb7Mnos L7/nosL7 mothers that also carry two PcG mutations. To test this, we examined progenies of mxcG48/+;Df(2)vgB/+;hb7MnosL7/nosL7 mothers and mxcG48/+;hb7MnosL7/nosL7;phob/+ flies. Df(2)vgB is a deletion of the Posterior sex combs/Suppressor of zeste 2 complex (Psc/Su(z)2-C) and phob was described as an amorphic EMS-induced pleiohomeotic mutation by Girton and Jeon (1994). One copy of Df(2)vgB in hb7MnosL7/nosL7 mothers partially rescues the maternal nos phenotype (data not shown; Pelegri and Lehmann 1994). We found that at least 50% of the embryos from hb7MnosL7/nosL7;phob/+ mothers differentiate more than three abdominal segments. The rescue due to Df(2)vgB or phob was not significantly increased by adding one copy of mxcG48 in the mother (data not shown). These data confirm that early gap gene regulation is somehow dependent on certain maternal PcG products. But the lack of enhanced effect in a PcG double mutant background suggests that the nature, or the parameters, of this regulation differ from those pertaining to PcG-mediated repression of homeotic genes later in development.
Interactions between nos and mxc
Rescue of hb7MnosL7/nosL7 progeny by maternal mxcG48
mxc product is critically required in imaginal tissues: The needs for mxc during larval development were determined in the hypomorphic mutants mxc16a-1, mxcmbn1, and mxcG43 (see Table 1). mxcmbn1/Y and mxc16a-1/Y larvae were raised at 25° and 19°, because most mxc phenotypes are thermosensitive and more penetrant at 25°. At 19°, mxcmbn1/Y larvae reach normal size with a slight delay. They are smaller and develop slowly at 25°. All mxc16a-1/Y larvae develop in this way. mxcmbn1/Y or mxc16a-1/Y larvae remain at the wandering stage for up to 7 days without forming pupae. They have reduced imaginal discs and brains. The eye-antennal, leg, and wing discs appear more deformed than the haltere and genital discs. At 25°, the prothoracic leg discs of most mxc16a-1/Y larvae develop as a fused mass of tissue (Figure 3). Coalescence of the peripodial membranes of the prothoracic leg discs takes place in wild-type individuals during early pupariation (Demerec 1950), whereas the disc fusions in mxc16a-1/Y larvae also affect the primordial leg tissue. The mxc leg disc phenotype thus reveals a developmental abnormality specific to the larval stages because the prothoracic leg disc primordia are specified on either side of the embryo (review by Cohen 1993) and are only brought in close contact in the larva (Auerbach 1936).
The finer structure of the reduced mxc imaginal discs in late third instar larvae was determined using a wingless-lacZ (wg) reporter gene that labels specific territories in all major discs (Cousoet al. 1993) (Figure 3). wg-lacZ expression in discs from wandering mxc/Y larvae resembles wg-lacZ expression in wild-type discs from younger larvae (Figure 3). Null mutations of the PcG gene E(z), which also induce a small disc and brain phenotype, exhibit abnormal mitotic figures in the brain tissue and proliferation defects (Shearnet al. 1978; Gatti and Baker 1989; Phillips and Shearn 1990). To see if the mxc mutant phenotype was associated with similar defects, we examined mitotic chromosomes from mxc larval brains. Brain squashes from second instar mxcG48/Y or from third instar mxc16a-1/Y larvae exhibit mitotic figures and metaphase chromosome morphology without striking anomalies (not shown). Gull, an allele of the tumor suppressor gene fat (Mahoneyet al. 1991), can dominantly rescue the leg phenotype of four jointed (fj), which is associated with proliferation defects in the leg discs (Villano and Katz 1995). As defective proliferation might be responsible for the mxc phenotypes, we tried to rescue mxc mutants with Gull. Most mxcG48/Y;Gull/+ larvae die before or during the second instar and mxcG43/Y;Gull/+ pharate adults are no less transformed than their mxcG43/Y siblings (data not shown), indicating that Gull has no effect on mxc phenotypes. Therefore, the disc phenotypes of mxc larvae are likely not associated with abnormal chromosome morphology or with proliferation defects. Because the fused leg discs of mxc16a-1/Y larvae suggest an abnormal development during several cell divisions, we concluded that more than a simple arrest of imaginal development during the third instar must take place in these animals.
Strong mxc hypomorphs induce imaginal cell death: The mxc small disc phenotype could reflect abnormal patterning. This would be possible because (1) engrailed is an embryonic and imaginal target of several PcG genes (Busturia and Morata 1988; Moazed and O'Farrell 1992; N. B. Randsholt, unpublished results), and (2) correct pattern specification in the discs depends on en expression in posterior compartment cells, which activates the hedgehog signaling pathway and leads to organization of the future limb (Tabataet al. 1995; Zeccaet al. 1995). We examined the expression patterns of en, hh, and of the hh pathway genes patched (ptc), cubitus interruptus (ci), and dpp in mxcmbn1/Y and mxc16a-1/Y discs, using lacZ reporter genes or enhancer traps. en, hh, ptc, and ci expressions are similar to those of early third instar wild-type discs (data not shown), indicating that the hh pathway is not affected in the reduced mxc mutant discs.
We found, on the other hand, that expression of decapentaplegic is modified in mxc mutants. dpp-lacZ expression expands into both compartments in the genital discs, in the antennal, haltere, leg, and wing discs (Figure 4). The transforming growth factor β (TGFβ) homologue DPP acts as an appendage organizer in the imaginal discs where it diffuses from the antero-posterior compartment border and creates a gradient that governs patterning (Lecuitet al. 1996; Nellenet al. 1996; reviewed by Lawrence and Struhl 1996). During normal disc patterning, DPP induces a stripe of spalt expression in the imaginal discs, in a concentration-dependent manner. Using a spalt-lacZ reporter gene in mxc16a-1/Y larvae, we showed that DPP produced by mxc mutants induces a wider spalt-lacZ domain than in wild type, indicating that the downstream targets of dpp can still react to the concentration of DPP in an mxc mutant (Figure 4, G and H).
Imaginal disc phenotypes of strong mxc hypomorphs. Leg and wing discs are represented posterior to the right and dorsal up. Eye-antennal discs are shown ventral to the right. All mxc16a-1/Y larvae were raised at 19°. (A) Prothoracic leg discs from a pbG1-lacZ late third instar larva where lacZ is expressed in the imaginal leg discs. (B) Fused prothoracic leg discs from a mature mxc16a-1/Y larva. (C to H) wg-lacZ expression in imaginal discs. (C) Wild-type wing disc from a mature larva. (D) From a mid-third instar larva. (E) wg-lacZ expression in wing disc from a mature mxc16a-1/Y larva. (F) Expression pattern in eye-antennal discs from wild-type late third instar. (G) From wild-type mid-third instar. (H) From mature mxc16a-1/Y larvae.
Because of the ectopic expression of dpp-lacZ in mxc mutant discs, we analyzed genetic interactions between the two genes by looking at the phenotypes of double mutant flies for mxc and for the dpp mutations dppd6 and dppshv. dppd6 is a recessive semiviable disk-specific allele that induces pattern abnormalities of the head, thorax, and appendages, and dppshv is a recessive viable short-vein allele that only causes venation defects (St. Johnstonet al. 1990). The Dp(1:Y)FF1 chromosome that carries an extra mxc+ copy has no effect on the homozygous phenotypes of dppd6 and dppshv (data not shown). Phenotypes induced by mutation either of dpp or of mxc were rated in mxcG43 dppd6 and mxcG43 dppshv double mutants raised at 19° (Table 4). Loss of the distal-most leg structures, the claws, is seen in both mxc and dpp mutants and becomes fully penetrant in mxcG43/Y;dppd6/+ flies (Table 4). Another common mxc and dpp phenotype, small eyes, is also increased in mxcG43/Y;dppd6/dppd6 adults. dppd6-specific phenotypes are all enhanced in these animals, including small wings, loss of distal-most tarsi, and duplication of the remaining ones (Figure 4, I–K, Table 4). mxcG43-specific phenotypes, on the other hand, appear unaffected by dppd6. More ectopic sex-comb teeth are seen on some legs of the double mutant flies, but they are likely due to the dppd6-induced duplications of ventral structures (Heldet al. 1994). The mxcG43/Y;dppshv/dppshv adults show mxcG43/Y leg phenotypes with similar penetrance and expressivity as mxcG43/Y single mutants. These animals also exhibit increased venation defects, reduced eyes, and maxillary palps. Both of the latter phenotypes are observed in stronger dppshv mutants (St. Johnstonet al. 1990) and indicate again that mutation of mxc increases dpp mutant phenotypes. Some tarsi and antennae of these flies show fusions and duplications that are never seen in dppshv flies (Segal and Gelbart 1985; St. Johnstonet al. 1990). Such phenotypes recall those induced by dppd6 in the antennae and legs, but whereas dppd6 always affects the distal-most appendage structures in the strongest way, the mxcG43/Y;dppshv/dppshv abnormalities sometimes first affect other structures along the proximo-distal axis of the antennae or the leg (Figure 4, L–N). Our data show that mutation of mxc increases dpp expression in the discs, but it also enhances the loss of dpp in discs, according to the adult phenotypes of mxc dpp double mutants. This apparent contradiction suggests that both genes are implicated in a common phenomenon.
DPP plays several roles in Drosophila. One such role was reported by Brooks et al. (1993), who established that dpp is ectopically expressed in discs during regeneration following extensive cell death, in a broad domain similar to the pattern we observed in the mxc mutants. To see whether cell death was occurring in mxc mutants we stained mxcmbn1/Y and mxc16a-1/Y imaginal discs with AO. This revealed that apoptosis occurs in all territories of mxc imaginal primordia, demonstrating that mxc is required by most imaginal cells and that alteration of mxc in strong hypomorphs causes imaginal cell death (Figure 5). Cell death, followed by regeneration in hypomorphic mxc discs, could thus explain the broadening of the dpp-lacZ expression domain. Furthermore, prothoracic leg discs have been reported to fuse during regeneration after massive cell death induced during the first larval instars (Postlethwait and Schneiderman 1973). Together, these data indicate that cells are dying in the discs of strong hypomorphic mxc mutants, possibly as early as during the first larval instar. As dpp mutants have also been reported to induce cell death in imaginal discs (Bryant 1988), we conclude that the enhancement of dpp phenotypes by mxc could be attributed to the joint effect of two different patterns either of reduced viability or of cell death in the discs.
Interactions between mxc and dpp. The wild-type expression domain of dpp-lacZ in the (A) wing disc, (C) leg disc, and (E) genital disc is broader in (B) wing, (D) leg, and (F) genital discs from mature mxc16a-1/Y;dpp-lacZ/+ larva raised at 19°. The expression domain of (G) spalt-lacZ is also wider in (H) mature mxc16a-1/Y;spalt-lacZ/+ larva. (I) Wild-type prothoracic male leg showing sex comb on basitarsus, segmented tarsus, and claws. (J) dppd6/dppd6 males have duplicated sex combs and lack distal-most structures. (K) Prothoracic leg from mxcG43/Y;dppd6/dppd6 male. (L) dpp shv/dppshv males lack claws (arrow). (M) mxcG43/Y;dpp shv/dppshv males have modified sex combs and fusions of intermediate tarsal segments (arrow). (N) mxcG43/Y;dppshv/dpp shv males exhibit reduced eyes and duplications that can affect the first (S1) and third (S3) antennal segments. *, prothoracic ectopic sex-comb teeth.
Alteration of mxc induces abnormal immune responses: All mxc mutant larvae and some adults exhibit melanotic pseudotumors with variable penetrance and expressivity, from rare mxcM1/Y larvae raised at 25° under crowded conditions to almost all L3 mxcmbn1 or mxc16a-1 and L2 mxc22a-1 or mxcG48 larvae. Melanotic spots in mxc22a-1/Y and mxcG48/Y larvae touch the hindgut imaginal ring and the hindgut, whereas gut and fat body tissue can be melanized in other mutants (Figure 6). Imaginal discs or central nervous system structures are not melanized in mxc mutants. Because melanized pseudotumors result from an aberrant immune response (AIR) (Watsonet al. 1991) of the individual toward parts of its own body where lamellocytes—specialized hemocytes—encapsulate tissue perceived as “alien” and are melanized afterwards (Sparrow 1978), the pseudotumors of mxc mutants indicate that recognition capacities or membrane properties have been changed either in the hemocytes in charge of the defense response, in the cells that are encapsulated by the lamellocytes, or in both, and this in viable as well as in lethal mxc mutants.
Standard homeotic transformations of mxc mutants are enhanced by PcG mutations: A number of the homeotic phenotypes of mxc mutant flies are induced by many PcG mutations, whereas other modifications are specific to mxc (Santamaria and Randsholt 1995). Among the latter phenotypes are the ectopic sex-comb teeth that develop on tarsal segment 2 of the prothoracic legs of mxc hypomorphs. This transformation is also induced by particular alleles of some PcG genes (Jones and Gelbart 1990) and by all viable alleles of the cramped gene (crm). It could reveal a change in proximo-distal identities along the prothoracic leg (Santamaria 1993; Yamamotoet al. 1997). The first abdominal segment (A1) of mxc mutant males is consistently smaller than wild type (Figure 7). This modification is similar to a weak bithoraxoid (bxd) phenotype (Castelli-Gairet al. 1992). Furthermore, a tuft of bristles sometimes replaces ommatidia in the antero-ventral eye region of mxc mutants (Santamaria and Randsholt 1995), mimicking the phenotype of the gain-of-function Deformed allele DfdD (Chadwicket al. 1990). We wondered to which extent all these phenotypes depended on joint regulation of the corresponding targets byPcG products. Because phenotypes that are due to deregulation of common PcG targets, such as the homeotic genes, are synergistically enhanced in transheterozygous mutant flies, we scored homeotic transformations in adult males that were hemizygous for a viable mxc allele and carried one copy of a PcG mutation on the autosomes (mxc/Y;PcG/+ flies). Because mxcG46 is lethal in trans with several autosomal PcG mutations, we used the mxcM1 allele that on its own induces weak homeoticphenotypes in males (Santamaria and Randsholt 1995).
Interactions between mxc and dpp
Cell death in mxc16a-1/Y imaginal discs. (A) Wild-type wing disc. (B) mxc16a-1/Y wing disc from mature larvae grown at 25° and stained with acridine orange, revealing cell death scattered throughout the disc.
All mxcM1/Y;PcG/+ animals are viable or die as pharate adults. No significant interaction is detected in mxcM1/Y in trans with one mutant copy of escr4, Sce1, or with E(z)63 (Table 5). Some enhanced transformations are observed for sxc1, AsxXF2, phob, and PclXM3. Strong synergistic interactions were observed in flies carrying one copy of the antimorphic allele E(z)60, of ScmD1, Psc1, or Pck. We found that standard PcG phenotypes of antennae, legs, wings, or abdomen, due to gain of function of Antp, Scr, Ubx, abdA, and AbdB, are synergistically enhanced in mxcM1/Y;PcG/+ flies (Table 5). The enhanced leg phenotype involves an increased number of sex-comb teeth on the basitarsus of posterior legs, and the differentiation of prothoracic-specific bristles on the tibias of the second and third legs of mxcM1/Y;PcG/+ flies (data not shown; Hannah-Alava 1958). Antennae into leg transformations in mxcM1/Y;Psc1/+ flies feature reduced aristae and swollen second and third antennal segment with coxa or tibia-specific bristles (not shown) (Postlethwait and Schneiderman 1971). Maxillary palps are also reduced in these flies (not shown).
mxc mutants exhibit AIR phenotypes. (A) Gut from a second instar mxc22a-1/Y larva, showing melanization of the imaginal hindgut ring. (B) Third instar mxc mbn1/Y larvae. (C) mxcmbnSO/mxc22a-1 pharate adults, showing melanotic spots due to an abnormal immune response.
Small tergites and Ubx deregulation in mxc mutants. Cuticle from (A), wild-type male; and (B), mxc M1/Y;ScmD1/+ male, showing a bxd-like phenotype. (C) Expression of the Ubx-lacZ reporter gene from line 35UZ-3 in wild-type wing discs and (D) haltere discs from late third instar larvae. (E) Same in wing disc from mature mxc mbn1/Y larva raised at 19°.
These data indicate that several homeotic genes require the mxc product together with other PcG gene proteins to maintain their wild-type expression pattern during development. We checked whether mxc+ is needed for regulation of Ubx expression in imaginal discs, using the P[35UZ] transposon that functions as an Ubx-lacZ reporter gene (Irvineet al. 1991). In line 35UZ-3, lacZ is expressed following a wild-type Ubx-like epidermal pattern in the posterior compartments of the metathoracic imaginal discs (Irvineet al. 1991). β-Galactosidase staining of discs from mxcmbn1/Y;35UZ-3/+ larvae reveals ectopic expression in the wing discs and in many other imaginal structures (Figure 7 and data not shown). This result confirms the need for mxc+ product for negative control of the Ubx promoter.
Among the phenotypes that appeared specific to mxc, only the bxd-like A1 modification was increased in trans by the PcG mutations that we tested (Table 5). In extreme cases, the tergites form tiny plates that hardly join along the midline, as in mxcM1/Y;ScmD1/+ males (Figure 7). The proximo-distal leg transformations were not significantly increased in any of these mxcM1/Y; PcG/+ flies. Three E(z) alleles, E(z)1, E(z)62, and E(z)70, that on their own can induce ectopic sex-comb teeth on the second tarsal segment of prothoracic male legs (Jones and Gelbart 1990) were also tested in combination with mxcM1/Y. None of them enhanced this transformation (data not shown). The DfdD-like eye transformation was not enhanced by PcG mutations either. These data suggest that mxc has a particular role in proximo-distal identity determination and in head specification.
mxc product is needed for adult head specification and regulates Deformed: The need for wild-type mxc in head specification is illustrated by the eye phenotype of viable mxc mutants and by the head phenotype of mxc22a-6/mxcmbnSO females. These animals die as pharate adults and exhibit extremely reduced eyes and head structures (Figure 8). Differentiated eye structures, such as ommatidia and bristles, are present on the rudimentary heads. Antennal segments 1 and 2 appear normal, whereas antennal segment 3, the arista, and maxillary palps are reduced. Head structures derived from the labial and clypeo-labial discs, such as the proboscis, labrum, and clypeus appear normal (not shown), indicating that the need for mxc product is particularly strong in eye-antennal disc derivatives.
We looked for genetic interactions between mxc and Dfd because the identities of the maxillary palps and the head capsule that are affected in mxc mutants are specified by Dfd. The DfdD-like transformation of mxcG43/Y flies depends on Dfd+ dosage because mxcG43/Y;Dfd16/+ flies do not show this phenotype, whereas their mxcG43/Y;TM2/+ siblings do. Furthermore, the gain-of-function allele DfdD enhances the phenotype of mxc mutant males. A single DfdD copy in trans with mxcM1/Y, mxcG46/Y, or mxcG43/Y induces head phenotypes that are more severe than those of DfdD homozygotes (Figure 8). These flies have no aristae, and the eye-disc-derived maxillary palps and eyes are extremely reduced even in mxcM1/Y;DfdD/+ males, despite the fact that mxcM1/Y flies have normal eyes. The defects observed in mxc/Y;Dfd D/+ flies are similar to those of hsp70-Dfd-58 flies that have been exposed to ectopic DFD in all disc territories during larval development (Chadwicket al. 1990), suggesting that ectopic DFD could be responsible for the mxc eye phenotypes.
Wild-type DFD is present in antennal disc cells, in the peripodial membrane and in the lateral anterior disc territories that specify maxillary palps and rostral membrane, whereas ectopic DFD expression and disc reductions are observed in DfdD eye discs (Chadwicket al. 1990). Both mxc16a-1/Y and mxcmbn1/Y third instar imaginal discs stained with anti-DFD antibody exhibit weak ectopic staining. In the small mxcmbn1 eye discs ectopic DFD expression is seen in a number of cells, including the cells which will form the eye territory where tufts of bristles replace ommatidia in mxc mutants (Figure 8). A high level of ectopic DFD is detected in the eye discs of mxcG43/Y;DfdD/+ larvae, associated with a dramatic reduction in the eye primordia that give rise to the compound eye (Figure 8), explaining the almost total absence of ommatidia in mxcG43/Y;DfdD/+ adults. From these genetic and expression data, we conclude that mxc product is required to maintain expression of Dfd in the eye antennal disc, identifying Dfd as one of the mxc targets which is responsible for the effect of mxc mutations on head specification.
Phenotypes of mxcM1/Y;PcG/+ adults
DISCUSSION
mxc functions as a PcG gene during development: mxc functions as a Polycomb group gene according to three basic characteristics: (1) mxc phenotypes affect many segments of the adult body and mimic those of gain-of-function mutations in the ANT-C and BX-C genes; (2) these phenotypes are synergistically enhanced by mutations of other PcG genes; and (3) they are associated with ectopic expression of homeotic target genes in imaginal discs. The functions of trxG and PcG genes are often described as antagonistic, although Lajeunesse and Shearn (1996) have shown that E(z) mutants have features of either group. In this context, it is noteworthy that the bxd-like loss-of-function phenotype of mxc hypomorphic males is enhanced by several PcG mutations, suggesting that more PcG genes than E(z) may be needed for HOM gene activation.
mxc has, like many PcG genes, a strong maternal effect that cannot be entirely rescued by the father (Breen and Duncan 1986; Duraet al. 1988). The defects of the cuticle of the few escapers from mxcM1/mxcM1 mothers are likely due to the strong need for mxc product during oocyte formation (Docquieret al. 1996), because eggs from mxcM1/mxc M1 females are abnormal, most of them are small, and they collapse rapidly after oviposition. Misdistributed maternal determinants in oocytes from the mxcM1/mxcM1 mothers could explain the large cuticle holes and abnormal segmentation of their progeny. These embryos do not show the posterior transformations of other lethal PcG mutants (Breen and Duncan 1986; Duraet al. 1987; Phillips and Shearn 1990), but mxc product may still regulate HOM genes in embryos if the paternal allele provides sufficient mxc+ product, like the wild-type paternal allele of Sce (Breen and Duncan 1986). Alternatively, mxc might regulate HOM gene expression only during the larval stages, which would place mxc in a category of its own.
Deformed is a target of mxc regulation: Dfd is an mxc target since the DfdD-like eye phenotype of mxc mutants depends on Dfd+ dosage, because the DfdD/+ phenotype is enhanced by mxc and because DFD is ectopically expressed in mxc eye discs. The ANT-C gene labial also specifies posterior and lateral head capsule (Diederichet al. 1991), but we saw no ectopic label in the eye primordia of mxc mutant discs stained with anti-LABIAL antibody (data not shown), indicating that labial is not responsible for this mxc phenotype. The regulation of Dfd is likely specific to mxc. Indeed, no other PcG mutation exhibits DfdD-like phenotypes, hypomorphic polyhomeotic alleles have no effect on the eyes of DfdD/+ flies (data not shown), and this phenotype is not enhanced in mxc/Y;PcG/+ mutants. Homeotic gene expression is maintained within its normal domain during development through negative trans-regulation by the PcG and positive regulation by trxG genes. Gellon et al. (1997) recently showed that trxG products control Dfd expression, and mxc product might play the opposite role in control of Dfd.
Head specification and Deformed regulation require mxc+. (A) Head of mxc mbnSO/mxc22a-1 pharate adult. (B) Head of DfdD/+ male, showing ectopic antero-ventral bristles (arrow). (C) Similar phenotype in mxcG43/Y fly. (D) Head of mxcG43/Y;DFdD/+ male. (E to I) Eye-antennal discs from mature third instar larvae stained with anti-DFD antibody. All discs are shown ventral to the right. (E) DFD expression in wild type and (F) in DfdD/+ discs. (G) Dfd expression in mxc mbn1/Y at 19°. Arrowheads indicate ectopic DFD expression. (H and I) mxcG43/Y DfdD/+ larvae have reduced eye discs.
An interesting point concerning the head phenotype of mxcG43/Y;DfdD/+ males is the replacement of the compound eye by naked cuticle, as well as the disappearance of the corresponding eye disc territories. Other PcG gene mutants exhibit phenotypes where structures are apparently lost, such as the loss of the humerus in ph mutants (Duraet al. 1985), and the partial loss of the sixth segment in PcG mutant males. The latter phenotype is likely a partial transformation of A6 toward A7, which bears no tergites in D. melanogaster males (Santamaria and Garcia-Bellido 1972). Such phenotypes could be interpreted as homeotic transformations toward structures that are intrinsically defined by lesser proliferation rates.
Gap gene regulation by mxc and Polycomb group genes: Pelegri and Lehmann (1994) proposed that certain PcG genes are required for the maintenance of the expression domains of knirps and giant, through a mechanism similar to the regulation of HOM genes. If PcG regulation of the gap genes and of HOM genes later in development involved a similar mechanism, then loss-of-function mutations should have a strong effect on rescue, and the embryos from hb nos/nos mothers that have two PcG mutations in their genetic background should permit increased rescue of the nos phenotype.
Three E(z)son (suppressor of nanos) alleles or a hypomorphic pho allele partially rescue the phenotypes of hb nos/nos progeny by a maternal effect; deficiencies covering E(z) or the Psc/Su(z)2 complex also allow some maternal rescue of hb nos/nos progeny, yet the strongest effect is observed with the gain-of-function E(z)son alleles (Pelegri and Lehmann 1994). We found that the EMS-induced allele mxcG48 rescues the hb nos/nos progeny phenotype, whereas a deficiency of mxc does not. We also observed, like Pelegri and Lehmann (1994), some rescue with the Psc/Su(z)2 complex deletion Df(2)vgB, but in contrast to their data for a deletion of pho, we found strong rescue (consistently >50%) with an EMS-induced pleiohomeotic allele phob described as amorphic (Girton and Jeon 1994). This suggests that phob and mxcG48 are probably not amorphic alleles, and that maternal rescue of hb nos/nos progeny by a PcG gene is most efficient with a non-null mutation.
We looked at the segmentation of embryos from transheterozygous mothers. Although quantification of the nos rescue is difficult because it depends on many parameters (temperature, medium, age of the females), we found that rescue is not increased in progeny from such females. This was obvious for embryos from mxcG48/+;hb nos/nos;phob/+ flies, compared to those from hb nos/nos;phob/+ females. Yet the mxc and pho genes interact in HOM gene regulation because the transformations of mxcM1/Y;phob/+ males are much stronger than those of mxcM1/Y males.
Because neither a reduction of wild-type PcG product nor two PcG mutations in trans in the hb nos/nos mothers increases nos rescue, our data strongly suggest that, whatever the mechanism of gap gene regulation by these PcG mutations may be, it does not function like the PcG-mediated maintenance of HOM gene expression in embryos and in imaginal discs. The strong rescue provided by several non-null EMS-induced mutations, which may produce mutant proteins, leads us to propose that modified PcG proteins are poisoning a normal process. How this process depends on wild-type regulation by PcG products has yet to be established.
Loss of mxc is cell lethal: Cell death is a common feature of many mxc mutations: in the embryos from mxcM1/mxc M1 mothers, in the small imaginal discs of strong hypomorphs, and in clones of mxc null cells. Cell death is also observed in association with loss of other PcG products, in amorphic ph embryos (Duraet al. 1987; Abramset al. 1993), in embryos from pho− germline clones (Breen and Duncan 1986), and in pho− pharate adults (Girton and Jeon 1994). In E(z) null mutants, the small imaginal discs are associated with a low mitotic index, mitotic chromosome breakage, and polyploidy (Gatti and Baker 1989; Phillips and Shearn 1990), whereas Anti-E(z) antibody binds strongly to 40 discrete sites on polytene chromosomes and weakly all along the chromosome arms, showing that E(z) is required for maintenance of the overall chromosome structure (Carrington and Jones 1996). By contrast, none of our data suggested that the overall chromosome structure depends on wild-type mxc product.
The small discs, the fused discs, and the AO staining of mxc larvae all show that mxc cells start to die when the maternally supplied mxc+ is used up. The random AO staining throughout the disc indicates that all cells are affected (Figure 6). This could provide an explanation for the increased dpp-like phenotypes of mxcG43 dpp double mutants. Indeed, the phenotypes of flies that are homozygous for dpp disk-specific alleles are due to massive apoptotic cell death in the central disc regions during the third larval instar (Bryant 1988). If an mxc mutation adds a second pattern of subviability or of cell death to this, then many more cells will likely die, especially around the center of the discs where cell death is already occurring, causing increased dpp-like mutant phenotypes. The dppshv mutation, on the other hand, modifies a cis-regulatory region required by different dpp transcripts (St. Johnstonet al. 1990), which could affect all disc territories. In a growing mxc;dppshv imaginal disc, this general dpp defect, associated with the reduced viability of all the cells, could induce clusters of cells to die anywhere in the disc in a stochastic manner, explaining the fusions of nondistal-most tarsal segments in mxc;dppshv double mutants.
We observed an enlargement of dpp-lacZ expression in discs from strong mxc hypomorphs, but dpp expression is only increased within and next to its normal domain, although cells are dying everywhere in the discs. Brooks et al. (1993) have shown that a dpp-lacZ reporter gene reacts in this way to randomly induced cell death followed by regeneration during imaginal development. Recent data concerning positional information systems in imaginal discs from Drosophila point to the existence of a nonautonomous regulation system of positional information throughout the growing discs (Milanet al. 1997; Weigmannet al. 1997). In mxc discs, where cells are dying everywhere, an increased amount of DPP may be required to stimulate cell divisions to replace the cells that have died, but this induction still takes place within the framework of the nonautonomous overall patterning mechanism, which could exert control on dpp expression and maintain it, more or less, within its normal domain at the A/P compartment border.
Requirement and perdurance of mxc product: The diversity of mxc mutant phenotypes indicates that mxc is required in most tissues of the animal. A particular need for mxc is nevertheless detected in rapidly dividing cells: the germline, the larval hemocytes (Gateff 1978; Gateff and Mechler 1989), and imaginal tissues. Heteroallelic mxc females that die as pharate adults (Docquieret al. 1996; data not shown) have defective tergites, showing again a need for mxc in the histoblast nest cells that are mitotically very active in pupae (reviewed by Fristrom and Fristrom 1993).
Survival of the amorphic mxc mutants until the mid-second, early third larval instar is likely possible because of the perdurance of the maternal mxc+ product, whereas mxc null cells in imaginal discs die after a few divisions, suggesting that the amount of mxc product in imaginal cells is not as large as the maternal component. Taken together, our data indicate that mxc is not only needed but also expressed during most stages of development, like most other PcG genes (Paro and Zink 1992; Martin and Adler 1993; De Camillis and Brock 1994; Lonieet al. 1994; Carrington and Jones 1996).
Links between cell death, malignant blood neoplasms, and homeosis in mxc mutants: The very pleiotropic nature of the mxc mutant phenotypes could suggest a role in some basic cellular function, but pleiotropy should be the rule for PcG proteins, some of which bind a hundred targets on polytene chromosomes. Certain PcG proteins might also play a double role, like E(z) that maintains the overall chromosome structure and silences specific targets (Gatti and Baker 1989; Carrington and Jones 1996). The AIR phenotypes may also indicate that mxc cells are deficient in some general function or that cell death occurs in most mxc mutants, because the overgrown lymph glands and AIR phenotypes of most mxc larvae (Gateff 1978; N. Remillieux, personal communication) could be caused by a defense reaction to eliminate dead cells. Indeed, dpp-lacZ larvae that are treated with X rays that kill about 30% of their cells show similar AIR responses, associated with a broader expression of dpp-lacZ in discs (M.-A. Michellod, personal communication). Still, hemocytes from mxcmbn larvae differ in their fine structure from wild-type plasmatocytes (Shrestha and Gateff 1982), and cell death alone cannot explain their invasive character when they are transplanted into wild-type hosts (Gateff and Mechler 1989).
Cell death in the larva followed by regeneration could also explain some phenotypes of adult mxc mutants, because homeotic transformations can occur in response to localized ablations of tissue during insect development (Ouweneel 1976). We nevertheless believe that the strong interactions between mxc and DfdD or between mxc and other Pc-G mutants is not due to cell death alone, because irradiated DfdD/+ and ScmD1/+ animals do not show equally enhanced phenotypes (data not shown). Bristle patterns evoking proximo-distal homeotic transformations along the leg are seen in flies that have been irradiated as larvae; Girton and Jeon (1994) interpreted this phenotype in pho mutants as induced by cell death. This phenotype is likely outside the range of regulation by previously described PcG genes because it is not enhanced by other PcG mutations in mxcM1/Y;PcG/+ males. The cramped (crm) locus is a PcG member that consistently induces such proximo-distal transformations on all six legs, along with standard PcG transformations of the legs due to deregulation of Scr; crm mutations also induce sterility in both males and females (Yamamotoet al. 1997). crm may thus, together with mxc, control processes or genes required for proximo-distal identities along the leg and for germline development. Interestingly, crm interacts strongly with the mus209 locus (Yamamotoet al. 1997), which also causes proximo-distal transformations and sterility (Hendersonet al. 1994). mus209 encodes the Proliferating Cell Nuclear Antigen (PCNA), revealing a possible link between a subgroup of PcG genes and regulation of DNA replication.
Altogether, our data show that cell death is seen in several mxc mutants, but they also strongly suggest that cell death does not explain everything, and that the pleiotropic phenotypes of mxc provide a means to unravel trans-regulatory mechanisms that control, at the same time, the maintenance of cellular identity during development as well as cell proliferation and cell survival. In this context the tumor suppressor function of mxc is particularly interesting. Indeed, genetic alterations of basic cellular processes such as cell-cell communication, signal transduction, regulation of gene expression, cytoskeletal organization, and regulation of the cell cycle may result in cell death or in uncontrolled growth (Watsonet al. 1994). A tumor suppressor gene may maintain the identity of cells determined to form particular tissues or organs, like mxc controls HOM gene expression. Induction of uncontrolled growth and deregulation of Hox genes are linked in mammals, where Hox products can induce leukemia (reviews by Stuartet al. 1995; Boncinelli 1997). In Drosophila, modification of HOM gene expression causes homeosis, sometimes associated with increased proliferation but not with uncontrolled tumorous growth (Casareset al. 1996), possibly because the identity of each segment is specified by a combination of HOM products. Loss or gain of one HOM gene will likely lead to a new combination that is found elsewhere in wild type, and cells expressing this combination follow the corresponding developmental pathway and give rise to homeotic transformations. On the other hand, because each cellular identity apparently corresponds to a given proliferation rate, loss or ambiguity of identity due to deregulation of several selector genes in a single cell, such as mxc mutations apparently induces, could lead to loss of proliferation control. Identification of mxc partners and targets, as well as of the molecular nature of the mxc product, may help throw light on the genes and mechanisms involved in this process.
Acknowledgments
We thank K. Basler, P. Bryant, D. Cribbs, W. Gelbart, R. Jones, T. Kaufman, W. McGinnis, and the Bloomington Stock Center for sending us strains and T. Braverman, S. Celniker, W. Gehring, and M. Scott for providing us with antibodies. We are grateful to R. Karess and to B. Limbourg Bouchon for technical advice, to M.-A. Michellod and N. Remillieux for sharing results before publication, to our other colleagues at the Centre de Génétique Moléculaire for helpful discussions, and to D. Cribbs for critical reading of the manuscript. O.S. was financed by the Ministère de la Recherche et de l'Enseignement Supérieur, the Association de la Recherche contre le Cancer and the Ligue Nationale contre le Cancer. Part of this work was financed by an Association de la Recherche contre le Cancer grant to P.S.
Footnotes
-
Communicating editor: T. Schüpbach
- Received December 29, 1997.
- Accepted April 6, 1998.
- Copyright © 1998 by the Genetics Society of America