TABLE 2

Error rate in coassignments (ERCA) for 200 simulated data sets (n = 100, L = 10, J𝓁 = 10) with Kmax = 2

Genetic structure:Spatial structure:Inbreeding
FSTψ1, ϕ2)Nonspatial modelHMRF modelGENELAND
AllAllAll16.10.73.2
FST ≤ 0.08AllAll26.31.66.6
0.08 < FST ≤ 0.09AllAll7.60.61.4
0.09 < FST ≤ 0.1AllAll80.61.4
FST > 0.1AllAll8.30.21.1
Allψ ≤ 0.2All1.111.1
All0.2 < ψ ≤ 0.4All10.81.6
All0.4 < ψ ≤ 0.6All2.70.70.9
All0.6 < ψ ≤ 0.8All28.20.44.7
Allψ > 0.8All42.40.56.9
AllAll(<0.06, <0.06)17.20.30.7
AllAll(<0.06, >0.1) or (>0.1, <0.06)100.51.9
AllAll(>0.1, >0.1)12.311.5
FST ≤ 0.08ψ ≤ 0.4All2.72.12.8
FST ≤ 0.080.6 < ψ ≤ 1All41.80.99.4
FST > 0.1ψ ≤ 0.4All0.20.10.4
FST > 0.10.6 < ψ ≤ 1All23.70.32.4
  • The three models were initialized at Kmax = 2.