Cytoplasmic polyadenylation element binding (CPEB) proteins bind mRNAs to regulate their localization and translation. While the first CPEBs discovered were germline specific, subsequent studies indicate that CPEBs also function in many somatic tissues including the nervous system. Drosophila has two CPEB family members. One of these, orb, plays a key role in the establishment of polarity axes in the developing egg and early embryo, but has no known somatic functions or expression outside of the germline. Here we characterize the other Drosophila CPEB, orb2. Unlike orb, orb2 mRNA and protein are found throughout development in many different somatic tissues. While orb2 mRNA and protein of maternal origin are distributed uniformly in early embryos, this pattern changes as development proceeds and by midembryogenesis the highest levels are found in the CNS and PNS. In the embryonic CNS, Orb2 appears to be concentrated in cell bodies and mostly absent from the longitudinal and commissural axon tracts. In contrast, in the adult brain, the protein is seen in axonal and dendritic terminals. Lethal effects are observed for both RNAi knockdowns and orb2 mutant alleles while surviving adults display locomotion and behavioral defects. We also show that orb2 funtions in asymmetric division of stem cells and precursor cells during the development of the embryonic nervous system and mesoderm.
CYTOPLASMIC polyadenylation element binding (CPEB) family proteins bind to target sequences in the 3′-UTR of mRNAs and control their localization and translation. CPEB proteins function in many different biologocial contexts including oogenesis in Xenopus and Drosophila (Lantz et al. 1992, 1994; Christerson and McKearin 1994; Hake and Richter 1994), synaptic plasticity in the rat hippocampus (Wu et al. 1998), and long-term memory in Aplysia (Si et al. 2003, 2010). In Xenopus oocytes, CPEB regulates oocyte maturation. Prior to progesterone stimulation, it functions to repress target mRNAs in conjunction with proteins such as Maskin. After hormone stimulation, CPEB is phosphorylated, and the phosphorylated isoform recruits factors that stimulate poly(A) addition and translational activation of mRNAs that mediate the maturation process. In Drosophila, the CPEB protein Orb is required for oocyte determination and the establishment of the anterior–posterior and dorsal–ventral axes of the developing egg chamber. It functions by promoting the on-site translation of mRNAs that are localized in the developing oocyte, and like the Xenopus oocyte CPEB, its activity is regulated by phosphorylation.
Most animals have two or more CPEB genes. Completed genome sequences reveal that humans, mice, and Caenorhabditis elegans have four CPEB genes, but only two CPEBs in Drosophila. The homology between the CPEB proteins is limited to the C- terminal half of the protein, which has two RNA-recognition motif (RRM) domains and a zinc finger domain, while the N-terminal half is highly divergent. Phylogenetic trees indicate that the CPEB genes fall into two different subgroups (Luitjens et al. 2000; Mendez and Richter 2001; Huang et al. 2006). One subgroup includes Drosophila orb, mouse CPEB1, and the canonical Xenopus CPEB, while the other subgroup contains the second Drosophila CPEB gene, orb2, as well as mammalian CPEB2–4.
In the subgroup that contains orb and the Xenopus CPEB, most of the proteins are expressed in the germline and have important functions in this tissue, but are not essential for viability. This is the case with strong loss-of-function alleles of Drosophila orb (Christerson and McKearin 1994; Lantz et al. 1994) and the mouse knockout of cpeb1 (Tay and Richter 2001). In Drosophila, orb expression is only observed in the germline of larvae and adults and in pole cells of the early embryo. Strong loss-of-function alleles are adult viable, but female sterile. The mouse knockout for cpeb1 has no apparent defect on viability, but is both male and female sterile (Tay and Richter 2001). When cpeb1 mice are examined for nervous system defects, only minor deficiencies in learning and memory are observed (Alarcon et al. 2004; Berger-Sweeney et al. 2006). CPEB proteins from this subgroup are also found in other organisms such as clams and zebrafish, but only their function in female oogenesis has been studied to date (Bally-Cuif et al. 1998; Minshall et al. 1999; Walker et al. 1999).
The second subgroup of CPEBs is generally expressed more broadly and is often found in the nervous system as well as in the germline. For instance, CPEB2 in mice is abundantly expressed in male germ cells and the brain (Kurihara et al. 2003). CPEB3 and CPEB4 in mice are expressed in the brain and a number of other tissues (Theis et al. 2003). The two human genes that fall into this subgroup, CPEB3 and -4, were identified in a cDNA library from brain tissue (Kikuno et al. 2004). A human-specific polymorphism in CPEB3 has recently been associated with decreased episodic memory performance (Vogler et al. 2009). While the Drosophila Orb2 protein is a member of the second subgroup, little is known about its expression or functions. In the studies reported here we have examined the expression pattern of orb2 mRNA and protein during development and used RNAi and mutations to learn about its functions.
Materials and Methods
Generating the UAS–Orb2 double-stranded RNAi fly stocks
cDNA sequence (clone ATO4101 equivalent to the orb2B RNA species from Drosophila Genomic Research Center) was digested with BamHI and ClaI restriction enzymes and ligated into a UASi–GFPhp plasmid (a gift from Amin Ghabrial). This construct expresses a double-stranded hairpin RNA that inhibits expression of the targeted sequence by RNA-mediated interference. This sequence encodes amino acids 134–459 of the 75-kDa isoform of Orb2. The first 28 amino acids (134–161) are unique to the 75-kDa isoform, while the rest of the sequence is common to both forms of Orb2 protein. A BLAST search to the DNA sequence used in this construct reveals no significant similarity to any sequence except orb2. The plasmid was transformed into Drosophila embryos according to published methods. Two independent insertion lines were isolated and maintained: 137A (on X) and 39A (on 3).
Generating Orb2 monoclonal antibodies
DNA sequence corresponding to 1729–2499 bp (443–699 aa of the 75-kDa isoform of Orb2) of the clone ATO4101 was amplified by PCR and cloned into the pGEX–4T3 vector (Amersham) to generate a GST–Orb2 RRM fusion protein. The fusion protein was purified and injected into mice (Princeton Monoclonal Facility). Clones were screened for immunoreactivity to the purified RRM protein fragment by ELISA and verified by Western blotting to 0- to 24-hr embryo extract and the purified RRM protein fragment. Three positive hybridoma cell lines, 2D11, 4G8, and 7C3, were identified and saved.
We used the standard Western blotting protocols for extraction of proteins and blotting procedures. Primary antibodies were used as follows: mouse anti-Orb2 2D11 (1:25), mouse anti-Orb2 4G8 (1:25), mouse anti-Snf 4G3 (1:2000), mouse anti-Orb 4H8 (1:60), mouse anti-Orb 6H4 (1:60), and mouse antiactin JLA20 (Developmental Studies Hybridoma Bank, 1:100).
In situ hybridization
Ovaries were dissected in cold PBS and then fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde for 20 min at room temperature. Samples were washed in PBST and then incubated in 50 mg/ml proteinase K for 4 min. The proteinase treatment was stopped with 2 mg/ml glycine, and the samples were refixed in 4% paraformaldehyde. Samples were washed and then hybridized overnight to an antisense probe or orb2. Samples were washed and then blocked in 1% BSA in PBST for 30 min and then incubated for 90 min with 1:5000 AP anti-DIG (Roche). Samples were washed and detection was carried out with nitro-blue tetrazolium chloride/5-bromo-4-chloro-3'-indolyphosphate (Roche) until color was readily visible. For embryos, a 0- to 24-hr embryo collection was treated for 2 min in bleach and then fixed for 20 min in 4% paraformaldehyde/heptane and dechorionated with methanol. Embryos were rehydrated into PBST and then treated with 10 mg/ml proteinase K for 2 min. All other steps are similar to the ovary protocol.
Whole mount staining
Ovary, embryo, and larvae staining was done essentially as described by Costa et al. (2005). Primary antibodies used were: mouse anti-Orb2 2D11 IgG1 and mouse anti-Orb2 4G8 IgG1 (undiluted), mouse anti-Orb 6H4 IgG2a (1:30), mouse anti-BP102 IgG2A (1:20), rabbit anti-Eve (1:2000; a gift from Manfried Frasch, University of Erlangen-Nuremberg), DNA was stained with Hoescht (1:2000). Secondary antibodies used were goat antimouse IgG1 Alexa 546, goat antimouse IgG2a Alexa 488, goat antirabbit Alexa 488 (Molecular Probes). For adult brains the procedure described in (Gazi et al. 2009) was followed. Briefly, adult brains were dissected in cold PBS and then treated for 15–17 min with 1 mg/ml collagenase type VII (Sigma). Samples were fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde for 1 hr at room temperature, washed, and then blocked in 1% normal goat serum for 3 hr at 4°. Primary antibody was added in 10% goat serum and incubated for 2 days at 4°. Mouse anti-Orb2 was used undiluted. Samples were washed 6 × 20 min in PBST and then blocked again in 10% goat serum for 1 hr at 4°. Fluorescent antibodies were added at 1:500 dilution and incubated for 2 days at 4°. Samples were washed in PBST as above and mounted in Vectashield mounting medium.
Analysis of orb2 and CG43113 transcripts
RNAs were extracted with RNAspin kit (cat. no. 25-0500-70). cDNA synthesis was performed with oligo-dT primers. RT products were PCR amplified and analyzed on a 2% agarose gel. For PCR primers we used the following: orb2 common exon among RA, RB, RC, and RD: CAACAGTGCCACCAGCAGTGC and GCGCAGACTAACTTCGTCGTT; RA primers: TTGTGTGTGATTGTGAGTGTCCGT and GCGCATCTCCGCCACCAGTT; RB: AATAAGCTTCGCCGTGTAGCAGGC and CGCCCGCACCAACACTTTCTACA; RC: ATCACAGTCGTTGCTGACGAG and CGCCCGCACCAACACTTTCTACA; RD: AGTAATAAGGGCATAAGG and CGCCCGCACCAACACTTTCTACA; Orb2-CG43113 hybrid: TGCAAGCCGGTGGTTTCTTCAATC and GATGGTTTGTGTGACCTTGCCCTT; and CG43113 only: ATGAGCAAAGCTCCGTTGAAAGCC and TATCCGGATTAACCGTGTTCCGCA.
Flies were knocked down to the bottom of a vial and the number of flies that climb 6 cm in 10 s were recorded.
Flies were vortexed for 10 sec and those that return to standing position in 10 sec/20 sec were counted.
Flies grown at room temperature were heat shocked at 37° and the number of flies that were still standing after a 10-min heat shock was recorded.
The orb2 gene structure and homology to CPEB
The orb2 gene is located in the cytogenetic interval 66E4 on the left arm of the third chromosome (Hoskins et al. 2000). According to FlyBase, the orb2 locus is predicted to produce two sets of transcripts and proteins (Figure 1A). One set of transcripts, the orb2 RNAs, RA, RB, RC, and RD encode the Orb2 CPEB protein. The other set of predicted transcripts are the orb2-CG43113 hybrid RNAs, RE, RF, and RG, which encode a composite protein of unknown function.
The orb2 transcripts, RB, RC, and RD, are expected to encode the same 75-kDa CPEB protein and differ only in their 5′-UTRs and/or 3′-UTRs (Figure 1A). The differences in the UTRs are due to the use of two different promoters (orb2-1 and orb2-2), slightly different transcription start sites, alternative splicing, and polyadenylation. The fourth orb2 transcript, RA, is expressed from a downstream promoter, orb2-3, that is close to the major orb2 exons and encodes a protein of 60 kDa. The 75-kDa and 60-kDa Orb2 CPEB proteins share a common C-terminal region of 542 amino acids, but have different sequences at the N terminus (see Figure 1). The larger isoform has 162 unique amino acids at its N terminus, while the smaller has only nine unique amino acids. While the sequence in the N-terminal half of Orb2 is poorly conserved, it resembles Orb in that it is characterized by many polyglutamine and polyglycine repeats and is rich in histidine and serine. The sequence in the C-terminal half of the Orb2 protein is highly conserved especially for proteins within the same CPEB subgroup, and it contains the two 90-amino-acid RRM domains and a zinc finger domain.
The second set of predicted transcripts is the hybrid orb2-CG43113 RNAs, RE, RF, and RG (Figure 1). These RNAs are derived from the upstream orb2-1 and orb2-2 promoters, and share 5′-UTR sequences and sequences encoding the first 162 amino acids with the larger orb2 RNAs. The remainder of the 1221-amino-acid CG43113 protein, which is derived from exons located downstream of the Orb2 coding sequences, bares no resemblance to the Orb2 CPEB proteins. Database searches reveal that this part of the orb2-CG43113 gene is found in other flies. However, it is a completely independent transcription unit and does not include N-terminal protein coding sequences derived from the 75-kDa Orb2 isoform. In addition, as is in other Drosophila species, melanogaster has an independent transcription unit, CG5741, which expresses the CG43113-specific protein coding sequences. The CG5741 promoter is located downstream of the orb2 3′-UTR and polyadenylation signals, and it generates five distinct mRNAs (two of which are shown in Figure 1) that differ in their splicing patterns. These mRNAs are predicted to encode proteins ranging from 887 to 1093 amino acids and overlap all of the hybrid orb2-CG43113 sequences except for those derived from the orb2 N terminus.
Orb2 is expressed throughout development in both the soma and germline
orb2 gene activity:
We used RT–PCR with different primer combinations to examine the activity of the orb2 promoters during development. The predicted orb2 transcripts (RB, RC, and RD) derived from the two upstream orb2 promoters, orb2-1 and orb2-2, are detected in 2- to 4-hr, 9- to 12-hr, and 18- to 24-hr embryos, adult flies, heads, ovaries, and testes (Figure 1). In contrast, transcripts from the orb2-3 promoter, which generates the orb2-RA mRNA, are only observed in testes. We also found that transcripts containing the major orb2 (not shown) and CG5741 (CG43113) (Figure 1) specific protein coding exons are present in all stages and tissues examined. The relationship between orb2 and the hybrid orb2-CG43113/CG5741 genes will be considered further in a subsequent section, while we focus below on the products specific to the orb2 gene.
We used a combination of in situ hybridization (with orb2-specific probes), whole mount staining, and Western blots to examine orb2 expression during embryogenesis. We found that orb2 transcripts are deposited maternally and are distributed uniformly throughout the embryo until the extended germband stage (Figure 2 A–C). In contrast, orb mRNA is not detected in Northern blots by 2–4 hr and is seen only in the pole cells by RNA in situ (Lantz et al. 1992). Whole mount staining with Orb2 monoclonal antibodies shows that the protein is distributed rather uniformly throughout the precellular blastoderm embryo (Figure 2E). However, there appears to be an apical concentration of the protein, just above the nuclei as the blastoderm cellularizes. Consistent with a maternal deposition, a protein of the expected size (75 kDa) for the RB, RC, and RD transcripts is found in extracts from unfertilized eggs. A protein of the same size is found in precellular blastoderm embryos (0–1, 1–2, and 2–3 hr) and early gastrula embryos as well (3–4 hr, Figure 3A). The 60-kDa protein predicted for the RA transcript is not detected at these stages and is only found much later in development (see below). In contrast to Orb2, Orb is not seen in Western blots of unfertilized eggs or in 0- to 4-hr embryos (Figure 3A).
During germband extension, the orb2 message appears to turnover and there is a drop in the in situ hybridization signal in most regions of the embryo. Consistent with this decrease, the level of Orb2 protein also drops as can be seen in the Western blots of 0- to 4-hr and 4- to 8-hr embryo extracts (Figure 3B). Expression is upregulated in 8- to 16-hr embryos and there is an increase in the amount of Orb2 protein (Figure 3B). After germband retraction commences, the highest levels of orb2 mRNA are found in the developing CNS (Figure 2D) and PNS, and there are lower levels elsewhere in the embryo. While it seems likely that mRNA seen at earlier stages is largely of maternal origin, much of the message present in the CNS and PNS in mid-to-late embryogenesis is likely due to de novo transcription.
Like the mRNA, the highest levels of Orb2 protein are in germband retracted embryos in the CNS (Figure 2, H and J) and PNS (Figure 2K). Interestingly, the protein in the CNS is concentrated in the cell bodies, while it is largely excluded from the longitudinal and commissural axon tracts. This is evident from the fact that there is little overlap between Orb2 (Figure 2, H and J) and BP102 (Figure 2, G and I), which is a marker for the longitudinal connectives and commissural axon tracts in the CNS. We also found evidence for Orb2 expression in the cells derived from specific neuronal lineages. One such neuronal lineage is the Even-skipped (Eve)-positive neuroblast (NB)4-2 → ganglion mother cell (GMC)4-2a → RP2/sib lineage. In stage 11 embryos (Figure 4, A and B), Orb2 can be seen in Eve-positive GMC4-2a cells (see arrows; GMC4-2a is also known as GMC-1), while in stage 14–15 embryos (Figure 4, C and D) Orb2 is found in the Eve-positive RP2 cells (see arrows). Orb2 is also detected in the Eve-positive aCC/pCC neurons (see arrowhead).
Our antibody staining indicates that Orb2 is not restricted to the nervous system and lower levels of the protein can be detected in the ectoderm and mesoderm. For example, Figure 2, L–N shows that Orb2 is expressed in at least a subset of the Twist-positive mesodermal cells. Note that the GFP marker seems to accumulate in both nucleus and cytoplasm of these mesodermal cells, while Orb2 is restricted to the cytoplasm (Figure 2N).
Western blots (Figure 3C) indicate that the amount of orb2 is relatively low during the larval stage. The lowest levels are seen in the first and second instars, while the level begins to increase during the third instar (data not shown). To examine the distribution of Orb2 protein in the nervous system at this stage, we dissected the brain and ventral nerve cord. Figure 5, A–C shows the condensed/retracted nerve cord and two successive images of a lobe from the brain of a third instar larva. As was observed in the embryo, Orb2 is found primarily in the cell bodies of neurons. While labeling of cell bodies of different neurons is evident in each focal plane, Orb2 appears to be largely excluded from axonal projections. Also, Orb2 is expressed at high levels in only a subset of the neurons (see Figure 5, B and C). As in embryos it is largely restricted to cell bodies of neurons in the ventral nerve cord as well.
Orb2 levels increase substantially during the pupal stage and remain relatively high in adults (Figure 3C). To determine where Orb2 is expressed in adults, we probed Western blots of extracts from the heads, bodies, and gonads of males and females. For comparison, we also probed the same blots with Orb antibody. As shown in Figure 3C, the overall distribution of Orb2 differs substantially from that of Orb. There is little, if any, Orb in somatic tissues from the beginning of embryogenesis to the adult stage (Lantz et al. 1994) and as illustrated in this figure, it is not detected in the head or bodies of adult flies. In contrast, high levels of the 75-kDa Orb2 protein are present in the head and bodies of both sexes. There are also differences in the expression of the two CPEB proteins in the adult germline. Although both are found in male and female gonads, Orb2 is much more abundant in the testes than in the ovaries. Figure 3C shows that the 75-kDa Orb2 isoform is barely detected in the slightly overloaded sample from ovaries. In contrast, both the 75-kDa and 60-kDa Orb2 isoforms are readily observed in the greatly underloaded extract from testes. Note that while the 60-kDa RA Orb2 is present in testes, it is not found in extracts from heads or bodies of adult flies. This is consistent with our RT–PCR data, which indicates that the orb2-3 promoter is only active in testes.
Orb2 expression in the adult CNS:
Whole mount staining of dissected brains reveals that Orb2 is expressed throughout the brain. However, it is also greatly enriched in certain specialized structures. This is shown in serial confocal sections in Figure 5. There is a high level of Orb2 present in the ellipsoid body (Figure 5, D–L), which begins as a discrete posterior structure (Figure 5, D–H), then becomes a ring-like structure (Figure 5, I–L, shown also in Figure 5, P and Q as line drawings). Moreover, two Orb2-positive discrete structures above the ellipsoid body can also be observed (marked by arrowheads in Figure 5, D–I); both of these are not part of the ellipsoid body, but just above it (see Figure 5, D–I). There is also another Orb2-positive structure (indicated by an arrow in Figure 5, D and E), but visible only on the left side of the brain, suggesting that there might be asymmetry in the left–right Orb2 expression pattern in adult brains. It is possible that this novel structure is present only on the left side of the brain, as opposed to Orb2 expression being limited to only one of the two structures. Orb2 is also found in the Fan-shaped body (Figure 5, L–O, R, and S). The staining pattern suggests that Orb2 is localized to the synaptic terminals in a fashion similar to the localization of Synaptotagmin (see Gazi et al. 2009). These structures are part of the central complex within the central brain area and are believed to function as higher order processing sites for locomotion control (Strauss 2002). These structures are rich in axonal and dendritic terminals and have efferents from the protocerebral bridge. In this context it is interesting to note that the intracellular distribution of Orb2 in neurons of adult brains differs from that seen at earlier stages. Whereas most of the protein localized in the cell bodies of neurons at earlier stages, in the adult brain, the protein appears to be localized to synaptic terminals.
Orb2 accumulation in ovaries:
Since the expression of orb mRNA and protein in developing egg chambers has been extensively characterized, it was of interest to compare it with that of orb2. orb mRNA and protein are first detected in the newly formed 16-cell cysts in the germarium where both are concentrated primarily in the presumptive oocyte. Between stages 1 and 7, orb mRNA and protein are concentrated in the region near the posterior pole of the oocyte. After the onset of vitellogenesis, orb mRNA is concentrated along the anterior margin of the oocyte, while Orb protein is localized around the entire oocyte cortex (Figure 6G). A very different expression pattern is observed for orb2. There is little orb2 mRNA in either the germarium or in early previtellogenic stage chambers (Figure 6, A and B). Midway through oogenesis, the level of orb2 mRNA begins to increase and it then remains high through at least stage 10; however, orb2 differs from orb in that the message is largely restricted to the nurse cells (Figure 6, B and C). The distribution of Orb2 protein also differs from that of Orb. While Orb is restricted to the germline, Orb2 is present in both germ cells and follicle cells (Figure 6D). In the germline nurse cells, it is most heavily concentrated in a ring around the nuclei (see arrows in Figure 6F) and in the cytoplasm of nurse cells close to the oocyte (see arrowhead in Figure 6F). Even though there is little orb2 mRNA in the oocyte, Orb2 protein is present and its localization pattern resembles that seen for Orb. In previtellogenic chambers, it forms a cap posterior to the oocyte nucleus (Figure 6D). At later stages, most of the Orb2 protein appears to be localized along the cortex of the oocyte just like Orb (compare Figure 6, F and G).
Orb2 RNAi causes lethality
We used two different approaches to learn more about the biological functions of the orb2 gene. In the first, we generated a double-stranded RNA specific to a region of the orb2 mRNAs common to the 60-kDa and 75-kDa Orb2 isoforms, which does not contain the conserved CPEB RRM domains (see Materials and Methods). We used the Gal4-UAS system to express the orb2 dsRNA in a tissue-specific manner (Brand and Perrimon 1993). Flies carrying two independent UAS-orb2RNAi inserts were crossed to different Gal4 lines to drive expression in distinct tissue-specific patterns. Since high levels of orb2 mRNA and protein are present in the CNS and PNS, we reasoned that expression of orb2 dsRNA using nervous system Gal4 drivers might have deleterious effects. However, there were no obvious effects on viability using the elav-GAL4 driver, which drives expression mostly in postmitotic neurons (Berger et al. 2007). While this could mean that orb2 has no essential function in the fly nervous system, it is also possible that the amount of dsRNA produced by the elav driver is not sufficient and/or the timing of its production is not appropriate to compromise a vital orb2 function in the nervous system. This possibility is supported by the fact that lethal effects are observed for many other nervous system drivers. Altogether we tested 12 other Gal4 drivers that have been reported to be expressed in the CNS and/or PNS of embryos and/or larva and found that all had lethal effects when combined with UAS-orb2-RNAi transgenes (Ward et al. 2002). As shown inSupporting Information,Table S1, the severity of the lethal effects varied depending upon the driver and the UAS-orb2-RNAi insert. Further supporting the idea that orb2 has a vital function during the development of the nervous system, we found that expression of orb2 RNAi using a scabrous Gal4 driver also had lethal effects (not shown). scabrous is activated earlier in development than elav. It initially comes on in the late blastoderm stage in the neuroectoderm and is further upregulated in neuroblasts after they delaminate from neuroectoderm; however, it is not active in postmitotic neurons (Mlodzik et al. 1990).
Piggybac insertions in the orb2 locus disrupt expression of orb2 gene products
In the second approach, we characterized a collection of five piggybac transposons and one P-element transposon inserted within or near the orb2/CG43113/CG5741 transcription units. The piggybac transposon orb21769 is inserted upstream of the orb2-1 promoter, while the piggybac transposon orb21556 and the P-element orb21793 are inserted in the first (or second) exon for the orb2-1 promoter. These three insertions should only affect transcripts expressed from the orb2-1 promoter. The piggybac transposons orb21925 and orb26090 are located in the first intron downstream of the orb2-2 promoter and could potentially affect transcripts from both this promoter and the orb2-1 promoter. The final piggybac insertion, orb24965, is located in a large intron downstream of the orb2 protein coding sequences, but upstream of the protein coding sequences unique to CG43113/CG5741. This transposon would not be expected to have any effect on the expression of the various orb2 or CG5741 mRNAs, but could disrupt expression of the hybrid orb2-CG43113 transcripts originating from the orb2-1 and orb2-2 promoters. We used RT–PCR, Western blots, and whole mount antibody staining to examine the effects of these transposons on the expression of orb2 and CG43113/CG5741 gene products in adults.
With respect to the different orb2 and hybrid orb2-CG43113 transcripts, we used semiquantitative analysis and found that the piggybac 1769 insertion, which is upstream of the orb2-1 promoter, had no apparent effect on any of the orb2 or the hybrid orb2-CG43113 RNAs (Figure 1) and the levels of the different RNAs were approximately equivalent to that in wild type (data not shown). Similarly, the orb24965 transposon, which is inserted downstream of the orb2 mRNA coding sequences, did not affect any of the orb2 mRNAs. However, expression of the hybrid orb2-CG43113 mRNAs originating from the orb2 promoters upstream of the insertion was substantially reduced in 4965 compared to the control (1769 in the experiment shown in Figure 1). Significantly, when we used RT–PCR primers complementary to sequences located entirely within the CG5741 protein-coding region, we found that the level of the CG5741 RNAs in 4965 is close to that in the 1769 (or wild type) control. Moreover, a similar pattern is seen for some of the other transposon insertions: they have reduced levels of the hybrid orb2-CG43113 RNAs generated by the orb2 promoters, but nevertheless have substantial amounts of the CG5741 specific RNAs. These results suggest that sequences critical for CG5741 promoter activity are located downstream of the 4965 transposon insertion and that this promoter is fully active in the 4965 allele and in all of the other transposon insertions. It would also appear that a substantial fraction of the CG5741/CG43113 transcripts are derived from the CG5741 promoter rather than from the upstream orb2 promoters.
When we used a primer set specific for the 75-kDa orb2 protein-coding sequence, only two transposons, 6090 and 1925, showed a significant reduction in the levels of orb2 mRNA. Both mutants also showed reduced amounts of the orb2 RB, RC, and RD transcripts when primer sets specific for these RNAs were used (Figure 1). The insertions in 1556 and 1793 are upstream of the RC orb2-2 promoter, and the levels of RC transcripts in both these alleles were similar to the control. On the other hand, both had reduced levels of the orb2 RD and RB transcripts (Figure 1). As expected, we found that none of the transposon insertions had any effect on the expression of either the 60-kDa Orb2 RA protein or the orb2 RA mRNA (data not shown). Consistent with our RT–PCR experiments, only two, 6090 and 1925, had major effects on the expression of the 75-kDa protein. As shown in the Western blot of adult heads in Figure 7A, the levels of the 75-kDa protein are markedly reduced in both mutants. By contrast, there is no obvious change in the expression of this protein in the remaining transposon alleles. We also examined the expression of Orb2 in whole mounts of orb21925 and orb6090 embryos. As shown in Figure 7C, the expression of Orb2 in the embryonic CNS, PNS, and in other tissues of homozygous orb21925 embryos is reduced compared to wild type. Similar results were obtained for orb26090.
Two of the piggybac insertions cause lethality
Since the RNAi knockdowns of orb2 had lethal effects, we tested whether any of the piggybac or P-element insertions also had lethal effects. As shown in Figure 7B, 1769, 1556, 1793, and 4965 flies are fully viable. In the case of 1769, this is not surprising since this allele expresses wild-type levels of orb2 RNA and protein. While there are reductions in the levels of several orb2 transcripts in 1556 and 1793, the reductions are either not sufficient to cause lethality or are not in tissues in which orb2 activity is needed for full viability. Similarly, the disruptions in the expression of the hybrid orb2-CG43113 transcripts in 4965 showed no adverse effects on viability.
On other hand, lethal effects are observed for both 6090 and 1925. These results are consistent with studies of a null allele of orb2 (orb2Δ) generated by homologous recombination and described by Keleman et al. (2007). For 6090, only about one-third of the homozygous flies survive to adulthood, while about two-thirds of the 1925 homozygotes survive. While some mutant animals die during embryogenesis, most appear to die during the pupal stage. Arguing against potential background effects, we found that when 6090 flies are trans to Df(3L)ED4421, which uncovers the orb2 gene, only ∼10% (n = 351) of the expected number of the trans-heterozygous flies survived to adulthood. Similar results were obtained for 1925. We also found that the lethality of 1925 and 6090 can be reverted by precise excision of the piggybac transposons. Finally, we found that the orb26090 allele showed a reduction in life span (seeFigure S1).
orb2 functions in asymmetric cell division in the CNS
Since Orb2 appears to specifically accumulate in the cell bodies but not in their axons during embryogenesis, we wondered whether it has any role in the specification of these neurons. To explore this question, we examined the specification of RP2 neurons, a well-studied neuronal lineage (reviewed in Bhat 1999; Gaziova and Bhat 2007), under conditions where orb2 activity is compromised. During embryogenesis, each neuroblast (NB) undergoes a series of asymmetric divisions generating a self-renewing NB and a daughter GMC. Each GMC divides, producing two daughter cells, which typically differentiate into two different neurons. The Eve-positive RP2 neuron arises from the NB4-2 → GMC4-2a lineage (Bhat and Schedl 1994; Buescher et al. 1998; Skeath and Doe 1998; Wai et al. 1999). In wild-type embryos, GMC4-2a (also known as GMC-1) divides asymmetrically, producing two daughter neurons: RP2 and sib. The sib cell is smaller in size compared to RP2. While Eve is expressed in both daughter cells initially, it eventually disappears from the sib (Frasch et al. 1987; Patel et al. 1989; Fujioka et al. 2003). In wild-type stage 14 embryos, a single RP2 neuron is observed in each hemisegment (arrows in Figure 8A). However, if the asymmetric division of a GMC4-2a is disrupted, two cells with the same identity (RP2 or sib) can be formed, which can be determined by the Eve-staining pattern (Bhat and Schedl 1994; Bhat et al. 1995; Buescher et al. 1998; Wai et al. 1999).
As shown in Figure 8, A–D, in 11% of the orb21925 and 25% of the orb26090 embryos (Figure 9A), we observed RP2 neuron specification defects. In most instances (∼70%) the RP2 neurons are duplicated and there are two equal sized Eve-positive cells per hemisegment (arrows in Figure 8, B and C). However, we also observed hemisegments that lacked Eve-positive RP2 neurons (arrowhead in Figure 8B), an indication that such hemisegments had either no RP2 lineage formed or that the GMC divided into two sib cells. These findings argue that orb2 is required for the proper elaboration of this lineage. Consistent with this conclusion, RP2 specification defects were also observed when orb2 activity is knocked down by RNAi in the nervous system using Gal4 drivers such as cb43, scabrous (Figure 9A), and cb36.
orb2 may have a general role in asymmetric cell division
Many of the genes implicated in the asymmetric NB4 → GMC-1 → RP2/sib cell division pathway are known to function in the asymmetric division of other lineages (Ruiz Gomez and Bate 1997; Carmena et al. 1998; Paululat et al. 1999; Tio et al. 2001). To test whether orb2 also has a more general role in asymmetric cell division, we examined cell division patterns in the mesoderm. In each hemisegment there are two Eve-expressing mesodermal lineages that undergo asymmetric divisions. In one of these lineages, the P2 cell divides asymmetrically to generate the founder of the Eve-positive pericardial cells (FEPCs) and FEPC sib cells. The FEPC daughter then divides symmetrically to form a pair of Eve-positive pericardial cells (EPCs) in each hemisegment (arrow in Figure 8D). In the other lineage, the P15 cell divides asymmetrically to produce the Eve-positive DA1 muscle founder cell FDA1 and the FDA1 sib cell. The FDA1 daughter then generates the multinucleate DA1 muscle (arrowhead in Figure 8D).
As was observed for the RP2 lineage, orb2 is required for asymmetric cell division in the P2 → EPC and P15 → DA1 lineages. In both orb21925 and orb26090 mutant embryos, we observe abnormalities in these two lineages. Figure 8E shows a hemisegment in which the P2 cell divided symmetrically to produce an extra Eve-positive EPC cell (arrow), while Figure 8F shows a hemisegment in which the P2 or FEPC asymmetric division was abnormal and no Eve-positive EPC cell was produced (arrow). Extra and missing Eve-positive cells are also seen in the P15 → DA1 lineage. Figure 8G (arrowhead) shows a hemisegment in which P15 divided symmetrically to produce two DA1 muscles, while Figure 8H shows a hemisegment in which the DA1 muscle is absent (arrowhead).
Alignment of the mitotic spindle is disrupted in orb2 mutants
Mastushita-Saki et al. (2010) have shown that one of the mRNAs associated with Orb2 in the adult CNS encodes Drosophila atypical protein kinase C (aPKC). Since this kinase is known to play a central role in asymmetric cell division, we wondered whether there were any effects on aPKC in orb2 mutant neuroblasts. In nondividing wild-type neuroblasts, aPKC is distributed around the cortex of the cell (Figure 10A, cell with arrowhead), while in neuroblasts about to undergo asymmetric division (Figure 10A, arrow) it concentrates on the apical side of the cell. Orb2 is also in a cortical ring in nondividing neuroblasts (Figure 10A, arrowhead). However, the Orb2 ring does not appear to overlap with aPKC (Figure 10A, left). Instead, it is localized in a slightly more interior region of the cell. In dividing neuroblasts, Orb2 differs from aPKC in that it disappears from the cortex and becomes largely unlocalized (Figure 10A, arrow). When wild-type neuroblasts divide, the mitotic spindle (arrowhead in Figure 10B) is oriented along the apical–basal axis. After division, the apical daughter cell that inherits the cap of aPKC (arrow in Figure 10B) retains neuroblast identity, while the basal daughter becomes a GMC. In orb2 mutants, aPKC can be detected in nondividing neuroblasts; however, it seems to be somewhat less tightly linked to the cortex than in wild type. In dividing mutant neuroblasts, the mitotic spindle orientation is often randomized with respect to the apical–basal axis (arrowhead in Figure 10C). Interestingly, in these neuroblasts, the apical cap of aPKC is also missing. These findings further support the conclusion that orb2 plays a role in asymmetric cell division and suggest that it may function by promoting the localized accumulation of aPKC.
Behavioral deficiencies in orb2 adults
In the adult CNS, high levels of Orb2 are found in the ellipsoid and fan shaped bodies. As these structures have been implicated in sensing distance, orientation, and walking, we tested different orb2 alleles in behavioral assays that measure locomotion and activity of adult flies. These assays were recovery from vortexing (bang assay) and recovery from knockdown (climbing assay). We also tested recovery from heat shock. As shown in Figure 9, B and C, the three orb2 mutants, 1769, 1793, and 1556, that had no apparent effects on Orb2 protein expression in adult brains recover from vortexing and knockdown as rapidly as wild type. This is also true for an orb2 mutant, orb2delQ, lacking the N-terminal glutamine-rich region, which has previously been implicated in learning and memory (Keleman et al. 2007). The 4965 allele, which disrupts the orb2 promoter-dependent CG43113 mRNAs, but not the orb2 mRNAs, also resembles wild type. In contrast, 6090, and to a lesser extent 1925, take longer than wild type to recover from vortexing. Even more pronounced defects are evident in the knockdown experiment. Finally, we also found that 6090, but not 1925, recovers more slowly from heat shock than wild type (Figure 9D).
Sequence organization of Orb2 and the neighboring CG43113 transcription units
The sequence organization and coding properties of the orb2 transcription unit is quite complex. There are at least three orb2 promoters and they generate two quite different sets of mRNAs. One set of mRNAs, the orb2 mRNAs, encode the CPEB protein Orb2, while the other set of mRNAs, the hybrid orb2-CG43113 mRNAs, encode a conserved protein of unknown function (Figure 1).
Three orb2 mRNAs, RB, RC, and RD, are expressed from the orb2-1 and orb2-2 promoters and encode the same 75-kDa Orb2 isoform. The fourth mRNA, RA, is expressed from the orb2-3 promoter and encodes a smaller 60-kDa protein. These two Orb2 isoforms share a common 542-amino-acid C-terminal region, which includes the two CPEB RRM domains and the zinc finger, but have unique N termini of 162 and 9 amino acids, respectively. The other set of transcripts is the hybrid orb2-CG43113 mRNAs. They are generated by the orb2-1 and orb2-2 promoters and share several 5′ exons with the orb2 RB, RC, and RD mRNAs. These 5′ exons include the translation start signal and the “unique” 162-amino-acid N terminus of the 75-kDa Orb2 isoform. However, instead of being spliced to the downstream sequences encoding Orb2, the CG43113 mRNAs are spliced to a conserved 1059-amino-acid open reading frame, which is located ∼7 kb beyond the end of orb2. This downstream open reading frame is also part of an independent transcription unit, CG5741, which has its own promoter and generates five different mRNAs. These mRNAs encode variants of the same conserved open reading frame depending on their splicing pattern and the location of the AUG codon.
An important issue is the relationship between orb2, orb2-CG43113, and CG5741. In most other fly species orb2 and CG5741 (CG43113) appear to be distinct genes. For example, the pseudoobscura CG43113 gene, GA19098, is also located downstream (12 kb) of the orb2 (GA1909) open reading frame and like CG5741, it is predicted to have its own promoter. Our data would suggest that in spite of the fact that some of the CG571/CG43113 transcripts are derived from orb2 promoters, the orb2 and CG5741 genes are probably distinct in melanogaster as well. In particular, we found that a piggybac insertion, orb4965, located downstream of the orb2 open reading frame interrupts CG43113 transcripts emanating from the two orb2 promoters, and greatly reduces the level of the hybrid orb2-CG43113 mRNAs. However, there were no obvious reductions in the level of mRNA specific for the CG5741/CG43113 protein coding sequences. We also found that insertions in the upstream orb2 introns, which disrupt transcripts from the orb2-1 and orb2-2 promoters, reduce the levels of orb2 and orb2-CG43113 hybrid mRNAs but do not alter the level of mRNAs specific for the CG5741/CG43113 protein coding sequences.
Orb2 expression pattern is different from that of Orb during development
Drosophila has two CPEB genes, orb and orb2. While the expression of orb is restricted to the germline and its only essential functions are in the female ovary where it plays a key role in the development of the egg, orb2 is expressed not only in the germline, but also in a wide range of somatic tissues in the embryo, larvae, and adult. While orb and orb2 mRNAs and proteins are deposited in the developing egg during oogenesis, their fate in embryos is quite different. With the exception of the orb gene products that are incorporated into the germline pole cells, all maternal orb mRNAs and proteins turnover by the midblastula transition. In contrast, maternally derived orb2 mRNA is translated in precellular blastoderm embryos, and high levels of the 75-kDa Orb2 protein are distributed throughout the early precellular and cellular blastoderm embryo. After the onset of gastrulation, there is a general reduction in the levels of orb2 message and protein, which likely reflects the turnover of the maternal gene products in the absence of significant de novo synthesis. However, once the embryonic CNS and PNS begin to differentiate, orb mRNA and the 75-kDa Orb2 protein isoform are expressed at high levels in these tissues. The Orb2 protein in the embryonic CNS is found predominantly in the cell bodies and is largely excluded from axon tracts. Orb2 protein is also detected in other differentiating tissues like the mesoderm, though the levels are lower than in the CNS or PNS.
High levels of Orb2 persist in the nervous system during the larval stages, and as in the embryos, the protein is predominantly localized in cell bodies, and not in axons or dendrites. Interestingly, in the adult brain, Orb2 is found mostly in axon/dendritic terminals. As orb2 has been implicated in learning and memory (Keleman et al. 2007; Si et al. 2010), this apparent shift in distribution in the adult CNS could reflect a change in the functional role of the Orb2 protein. Orb2 is also found in adult gonads. Recently, the smaller Drosophila Orb2 60-kDa isofom was shown to assemble into large aggregates in response to synaptic stimulation when ectopically expressed in Aplysia sensory neurons (Si et al. 2010). Once formed, these large aggregates were proposed to have self-perpetuating properties that would contribute to long-term facilitation. It was argued that the special prion-like properties of the N-terminal domain in the 60-kDa isoform was responsible for multimerization in response to synaptic stimulation. In contrast, when the larger Drosophila Orb2 75-kDa isoform was ectopically expressed in Aplysia neurons it was unable to form these self-propagating bodies either with or without stimulation (Si et al. 2010). As this study seemed to directly implicate the Orb2 60-kDa isoform in long-term facilitation, it was of interest to examine its distribution in different fly tissues. Strikingly, there is little if any of the 60-kDa isoform in Westerns of adult heads, even when overloaded, and only the larger Orb2 75-kDa isoform seems to be expressed in this tissue. In contrast, both isoforms are found in testes, though even in this tissue the 60-kDa isoform is less abundant than the 75-kDa isoform. Thus, it seems quite unlikely that the Orb2 60-kDa isoform plays a central role in nervous system function in adult Drosophila. If the assembly of Orb2 into prion-like aggregates is critical for synaptic stimulation-dependent long-term facilitation, then the experiments of Si et al. (2010) would imply that there must be special ancillary factors in the fly CNS, but not in Aplysia sensory neurons, that are able to promote the assembly of the 75-kDa isoform into prion-like aggregates upon synaptic stimulation. Since all of the smaller isoforms are included in the larger isoform except for nine amino acids at the very N terminus, one could imagine that Orb2 75 kDa should also be capable of forming prion-like aggregates under certain condition(s).
Function of Orb2 during development
Though orb2 function has been implicated in learning and memory (Keleman et al. 2007; Mastushita-Saki et al. 2010), what other functions it might have, if any, during the Drosophila life cycle are largely unknown. In our work, we have attempted to identify some of these other activities using RNAi knockdowns and transposon insertion mutations. This task has been complicated by the fact that the orb2 locus generates mRNAs encoding not only the Orb2 CPEB protein(s) but also a hybrid Orb2-CG43113 protein.
While not entirely definitive, the properties of the orb2 transposon insertions argue that the observed phenotypes are due to an effect on orb2 gene activity and not on the activity of either the hybrid orb2-CG43113 or the CG5741 gene. First, with the exception of 1769, which is inserted upstream of the orb2-1 promoter, all of the transposon insertions reduce expression of the hybrid orb2-CG43113 mRNAs. However, only two of these, 1925 and 6090, have obvious phenotypic effects. While 6090 has little of the hybrid orb2-CG43113 mRNA, the amount of hybrid mRNA in 1925 is close to that seen in the three other transposon insertions (1556, 1793, and 4965) that have no phenotype. Second, 4965 differs from the other orb2 transposons in that it is downstream of the orb2 coding sequences. It has no effect on orb2 mRNAs, but does reduce expression of the hybrid mRNAs. However, it has none of the phenotypes evident in the 1925, 6090, or orb2 RNAi animals. Third, while all but one of the transposon insertions reduce expression of the hybrid orb2-CG43113 mRNAs, the total level of the CG5741 (CG43113) transcripts appears to be unaffected in all of the mutants. This is likely due to the fact that the bulk of the CG5741/CG43113 transcripts are derived from the CG5741 promoter and not the orb2 promoters. Since the level of the hybrid orb2-CG43113 mRNAs can be reduced without any phenotypic effects, this would argue that CG5741 may be able to substitute, perhaps even fully, for whatever function the hybrid orb2-CG43113 protein might have. The suggestion that the 1925 and 6090 phenotypes are attributable to orb2 rather than the hybrid orb2-CG43113 gene product is supported by the fact that they are also observed in orb2 RNAi experiments. Less than 10% of the ∼1 kb double-stranded RNA expressed by orb2 RNAi vector is from the common region and thus the orb2 RNAi would be expected to have a much greater effect on orb2 than on the hybrid mRNAs.
We found that both the orb2 RNAi knockdowns and the 1925 and 6090 piggybac insertions reduce viability. As might be expected from the high levels of orb2 mRNA and protein in the CNS/PNS, Gal4 drivers that were expressed in the nervous system generally reduced viability. Also consistent with important functions in the nervous system, surviving 1925 and 6090 adults exhibit behavioral defects in assays that measure fly locomotion and activity. One of the piggybac mutants was also found to have a reduced life span. Moreover, the studies of Mastushita-Saki et al. (2010) on potential targets for orb2 regulation showed that mRNAs encoding factors involved in neuronal growth and synapse formation are associated with Orb2 in the adult brain.
One of the important nervous system functions appears to be in asymmetric cell division. In the embryonic CNS, Orb2 protein can be detected in the cell bodies of specific neurons such as the Eve-positive RP2 and aCC/pCC neurons. However, it appears to be needed prior to the formation of these neurons as we found that the proper elaboration of the NB4-2 → GMC4-2a → RP2/sib lineage depends upon orb2 activity. There are defects in the specification of the RP2 and sib cells in two different orb2 piggybac alleles, and also in orb2 RNAi knockdowns. The most common phenotype is the duplication of RP2. This duplication appears to be due to the loss of asymmetric division of the parent GMC to generate two RP2s. Since we also observe hemisegments with no Eve-positive RP2 cells, either the parent GMC generates two sibs (or some other neurons) or the defect occurs at even earlier stages. The effects of orb2 mutations on asymmetric cell division are not limited to the embryonic CNS, since a similar fate transformation is seen in two asymmetrically dividing mesodermal lineages that give rise to the Eve-positive pericardial EPCs and to the DA1 muscle.
The genes that have been implicated in asymmetric cell division fall into two general categories, those responsible for the asymmetry and those responsible for specifying the fate of the daughter cells. In the former category are genes like inscuteable, bazooka, and atypical protein kinase C (Schaefer and Knoblich 2001; Bhalerao et al. 2005; Gaziova and Bhat 2007). Mutations in these genes disrupt the process of asymmetric cell division and give rise to two identical cells. In the latter category are genes like numb, the transcription factor prospero, and various components of the Notch signaling pathway. Cells mutant in these genes still divide asymmetrically; however, though the daughter cells are unequal, they still assume the same fate. It seems likely that orb2 falls into the former category as the duplicated RP2 cells are equal in size. This is also observed for mutations in inscuteable, but not for mutations in the Notch pathway, where the two daughter cells are still unequal in size (Buescher et al. 1998; Wai et al. 1999).
Our analysis of neuroblast cell division in orb2 mutants points to roles in localizing aPKC and orienting the mitotic spindle. In wild-type nondividing neuroblasts, aPKC is localized around the cortex. Orb2 is also concentrated around the cortex, but localized just inside the cortical layer that contains aPKC. When neuroblasts divide asymmetrically, aPKC relocalizes to the apical cortex, and during mitosis, the spindle is oriented along the apical–basal axis. At this point, Orb2 is distributed uniformly in the cytoplasm. In orb2 mutants, aPKC is cortical in nondividing neuroblasts but appears to be somewhat more diffusely localized than in wild type. During cell division, aPKC does not concentrate at the apical cortex and the spindles are not properly aligned relative to the apical–basal axis. Since Orb2 is known to bind to apkc mRNA (Mastushita-Saki et al. 2010), a plausible mechanism is that orb2 helps promote the apical accumulation of aPKC by activating the localized translation of apkc mRNA.
While these findings point to a role in polarizing the cell during asymmetric cell division, the two orb2 mutants (and RNAi knockdowns) we have examined differ from mutations in genes like apkc and inscuteable in that only a relatively small percentage of the mutant embryos exhibit defects in the RP2 lineage. This could be due to the fact that we have not fully eliminated orb2 activity. Alternatively, orb2 might have only an ancillary role in generating asymmetry. Further studies will be required to determine how orb2 fits into the asymmetry pathway and why the phenotypic effects of orb2 mutations are relatively modest.
We thank members of the Schedl laboratory and Bhat laboratory for discussion and advice on this project. We acknowledge J. Goodhouse for help with confocal microscopy and Gordon Grey for fly food. We also acknowledge three undergraduates for their contributions to this work: Cindy Hodakoski, Mahala Burn, and Blessing Agunwamba. This work was supported by a grant from National Institutes of Health (NIH) (GM056937) and, subsequently, by grants from NIH (GM043432) to P.S. and (GM080538) to K.B.
Supporting information is available online at http://www.genetics.org/content/suppl/2011/09/07/genetics.110.123646.DC1.
Please verify all supporting information links in the article.
Please check use of italics throughout article. NOTE: Journal style includes gene names and alleles set in italics.
Please check the FlyBase links throughout. A list of entities linked in this article is available at http://textpresso-dev.caltech.edu/gsa/fly/entity_link_tables/123646.html.
In “RNA species from DGRC” please replace “DGRC” with its definition.
Please replace “HSDB” with its definition.
In “detection was carried out with NBT/BCIP” please replace “NBT/BCIP” with its definition.
Please add the affiliation for Manfried Frasch.
“cDNA synthesis was performed” as meant? (The original had “synthesized”.)
“neuroblast (NB)4-2 → ganglion mother cell (GMC)” as meant, as the definitions at first mention of “NB” and “GMC”? Please confirm or amend.
Please add the definition here at first mention of “RP”.
The arrowheads in Figures 6, 8, and 10 have some remaining stems and are not readily differentiated from the arrows. In addition, the stems on the arrows have differing lengths. If possible, please revise figure artwork and resupply so that the differences between arrows and arrowheads are readily apparent and so that the lengths of stems on arrows are more consistent.
“in the levels of orb2 mRNA” as meant? (Original did not have “of”.)
“transcripts in 4965 showed no adverse effects” as meant? (Original had no “showed”.)
Please verify that the subheadings “Alignment of the mitotic spindle is disrupted in orb2 mutants” and “Behavorial deficiencies in orb2 adults” are meant to be subheadings that are subordinate to “orb2 may have a general role in asymmetric cell division”.
Regarding “(Figure 10A, cell with arrowhead”: Figure 10A appears to have two arrows and two arrowheads. Please clarify references to Figure 10A arrowhead (singular) throughout.
Regarding “arrow in Figure 9B)”: there is no arrow in Figure 9B. Please revise text or change and resupply Figure 9 artwork.
“Finally, we also found that 6090, but not 1925, recovers more slowly from heat shock than wild type (Figure 9D).” as meant? (Original had “we found that…heat shock as well than”.)
“while there is no Orb in the follicle cells” as meant (that is, “Orb” instead of “Orb2”).
“33% should be homozygous” as meant? (Original had “33% of should be homozygous”.)
In the sentence beginning “With the exception,” is “1925” as meant, to match all other examples? (Original had “925”.)
“nondividing (arrowheads) and deviding (arrows) neuroblasts” as meant? [Original had “(arrowhead)” and “(arrow)”.]
- Received July 14, 2011.
- Accepted August 23, 2011.
- Copyright © 2011 by the Genetics Society of America