- THIS ARTICLE
-
Abstract
- Full Text (PDF)
- Alert me when this article is cited
- Alert me if a correction is posted
- SERVICES
- Similar articles in this journal
- Similar articles in PubMed
- Alert me to new issues of the journal
- Download to citation manager
- Reprints & Permissions
- CITING ARTICLES
- Citing Articles via HighWire
- Citing Articles via Google Scholar
- GOOGLE SCHOLAR
- Articles by Simmons, M. J.
- Articles by Merriman, P. J.
- Search for Related Content
- PUBMED
- PubMed Citation
- Articles by Simmons, M. J.
- Articles by Merriman, P. J.
The P Cytotype in Drosophila melanogaster: A Maternally Transmitted Regulatory State of the Germ Line Associated With Telomeric P Elements
Michael J. Simmonsa, John D. Raymonda, Jarad B. Niemia, Jeremy R. Stuarta, and Peter J. Merrimanaa Department of Genetics, Cell Biology and Development, University of Minnesota, Saint Paul, Minnesota 55108-1095
Corresponding author: Michael J. Simmons, Cell Biology and Development, 250 BioScience Center, 1445 Gortner Ave., University of Minnesota, St. Paul, MN 55108-1095., simmo004{at}umn.edu (E-mail)
Communicating editor: R. S. HAWLEY
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
The incomplete P elements TP5 and TP6 are inserted in the TAS repeats near the left telomere of the Drosophila melanogaster X chromosome. These telomeric P elements repress P-induced gonadal dysgenesis and germ-line hypermutability in both sexes. However, their capacity to repress hypermutability is lost when they are transmitted patroclinously in a cross. TP5 and TP6 do not repress P-element activity in somatic cells, nor do they alter the somatic or germ-line phenotypes of P-insertion alleles. In the germ line, these elements suppress the phenotype of a P-insertion allele of the singed gene that is evoked by other P elements, presumably because these other elements encode repressor polypeptides. This suppression is more effective when the telomeric P elements are inherited maternally. Regulation by telomeric P elements parallels that of the P cytotype, a state that represses P-element activity in some strains of Drosophila. This state exists only in the germ line and is maternally transmitted along with the P elements themselves. Regulation by known repressor P polypeptides is not restricted to the germ line and does not require maternal transmission of the relevant P elements. Regulation by telomeric P elements appears to be epistatic to regulation by repressor P polypeptides.
THE transposable P elements of Drosophila melanogaster were discovered through their involvement in hybrid dysgenesis, a syndrome of abnormalities that occurs in the offspring of crosses between recently established wild-type strains and longstanding laboratory strains (![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Flies derived recently from natural populations possess P elements in their genomes; they usually also possess the P cytotype, which keeps their P elements in check (![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
In dysgenic crosses, P-element activity is restricted to the germ line. The molecular basis of this restriction involves alternate splicing of P-element transcripts (![]()
![]()
![]()
For many years researchers have hypothesized that the 66-kD polypeptide is responsible for the P cytotype. Transgenes designed to produce this polypeptide repress P activity, albeit partially, and models have been constructed to explain its preferential production in the germ lines of P strains (![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Genetic analyses have offered another explanation for the P cytotype. Complete P elements inserted at the left end of the X chromosome, very near the telomere, repress hybrid dysgenesis almost completely, and repression by these elements has a maternally inherited component (![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Different assays have been used to study P-element regulation. The most direct approaches have tested for repression of hybrid dysgenesis. For example, one can monitor the frequency of gonadal dysgenesis, a form of sterility due to a developmental failure in the germ line, in flies that do and do not carry putative repressor P elements, or one can monitor the frequency of transposase-catalzyed P-element excisions in the germ lines of such flies. P excisions can also be monitored in somatic cells using a test system in which the flies carry a modified P element that lacks the last intron; with such an element, production of the P transposase is not restricted to the germ line (![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
In this article we consider questions about telomeric P elements and the P cytotype. We focus on two incomplete elements, TP5 and TP6, inserted in the TAS repeats near the left telomere of the X chromosome (![]()
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
Drosophila stocks and husbandry:
Genetic symbols for the Drosophila stocks are explained in ![]()
![]()
Synthesis of stocks with "cytotype-dependent" alleles:
Stocks carrying an X-linked telomeric P element (TP, either TP5 or TP6) and the P-insertion mutation vg21-3 of the autosomal vestigial gene were created in a scheme that began by crossing TP males with C(1)DX, y f; vg21-3 females (y, yellow body; f, forked bristles). The TP; vg21-3/+ sons were then backcrossed to C(1)DX, y f; vg21-3 females to create a stock homozygous for vg21-3 and hemizygous for TP in the males. TP; vg21-3 males were then crossed to homozygous TP females to obtain TP/TP; vg21-3/+ daughters, which were backcrossed to TP; vg21-3 males. Among the progeny, flies showing the vestigial phenotype were crossed to establish a stock fixed for both the TP and the vg21-3 allele.
Stocks carrying an X-linked telomeric P element and the P-insertion mutation sn50e of the X-linked singed gene were obtained by recombining a TP w m f (w, white eyes; m, miniature wings) X chromosome with a y w sn50e X chromosome in heterozygous females. TP y+ w sn50e m+ f+ recombinant males were individually crossed to FM6, l(1)69a/Df(1)wrJ1 females and to C(1)DX, y f females (both from M strains) to obtain, respectively, TP w sn50e/FM6, l(1)69a daughters and TP w sn50e sons. These flies were then intercrossed to obtain TP w sn50e homozygous females and TP w sn50e males, which were used to establish the stocks.
The presence of the telomeric P element and the P-insertion mutation in all of the stocks was verified by PCR using primers complementary to P-element sequences. Synthesis of stocks with the telomeric P elements and the snw (weak singed) allele of the singed gene has been described in ![]()
Synthesis of stocks with chromosomes from an M' strain:
M' strains possess P elements but do not have the P cytotype. Chromosomes of the M' strain Sexi.4 (![]()
![]()
Gonadal dysgenesis assay for P-element activity:
Gonadal dysgenesis (GD) was induced by crossing females from a particular strain to males from the Harwich-w P strain. Thirty replicate cultures of each cross were incubated at 25°, and as many as 20 daughters and 10 sons from each culture were examined for GD. The daughters were examined by squashing them between two glass slides to determine if they carried eggs. Females that did not were judged to have GD. The sons were examined by placing them individually in 13 x 100-mm culture tubes with two C(1)DX, y f virgin females at 25° and checking for larvae 6 days later. Males that did not produce any progeny were judged to have GD. The initial cross to induce GD was incubated at 25° instead of the usual 29° to prevent the generalized male sterility that is seen when flies are reared at 29°.
Assay for female fertility:
Females (not necessarily virgins) to be tested for the sterility associated with certain alleles of the singed gene were collected from cultures and incubated en masse with males for at least 2 days in vials. Each female was then placed in a separate 13 x 100-mm culture tube, which was incubated at 25° for 9 days. The fertility of each female was assessed by counting the number of pupae on the walls of the tube at the end of this incubation period.
Mutability assay for P-element activity:
Instability of the double P-insertion mutation weak singed (snw) of the X-linked singed gene was used to assay for transposase activity. In the presence of the P transposase, one or the other of the P elements inserted in the singed gene is excised, creating singed alleles with different phenotypes: extreme singed (sne) or pseudo-wild-type (sn+; ![]()
2-3)99B transgene, which produces the P transposase in the soma as well as in the germ line, the C(1)DX, y f females used in the testcrosses came from a P strain; the chromosomes from this strain suppress the bristle mosaicism that would otherwise occur in the offspring (![]()
Molecular analyses:
Initially the P element inserted in the sn50e allele was amplified by PCR using a primer complementary to a segment in the inverted terminal repeats. The product of this amplification was sequenced by a campus facility. Southern blotting experiments with DNA from a homozygous sn50e stock had indicated that the P element in sn50e was inserted in the 5' region of the singed gene. Primers in this region were used in combination with primers complementary to segments within the P element to amplify the DNA around the P element's insertion site and these products were sequenced.
| RESULTS |
|---|
Telomeric P elements repress gonadal dysgenesis in both male and female germ lines:
Previous work has shown that the telomeric P elements TP5 and TP6 are strong repressors of transposase-catalyzed P-element excision in both the male and the female germ lines (![]()
Homozygous TP5 or TP6 females were crossed at 25° to males from the Harwich-w P strain to induce gonadal dysgenesis in the offspring. Daughters from these crosses were examined for the absence of eggs, and sons were crossed individually to C(1)DX, y f virgin females to ascertain if they were fertile or sterile. As controls, females from an M (y w) or a P (Harwich-w) strain were crossed to Harwich-w males, and the offspring were analyzed for dysgenic sterility. The results of these experiments are summarized in Table 1.
|
The progeny from the control crosses with the M strain showed high frequencies of gonadal dysgenesis in both females (85.9%) and males (98.6%). The frequency of GD among the females was slightly less than that seen in previous experiments [99.9%, ![]()
In these experiments, the telomeric P elements were inherited maternally and both the target P elements and the sources of the P transposase were inherited paternally. The results demonstrate that maternally inherited telomeric P elements are effective repressors of the GD induced by these paternally inherited factors in both the male and the female germ lines.
Telomeric P elements lose their ability to repress transposase activity when they are inherited paternally:
Maternal inheritance is a key requirement for repression of P-element activity by the P cytotype (![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
2-3)99B, a stable P transgene that produces the P transposase in the soma as well as the germ line (![]()
![]()
2-3)99B. Furthermore, reciprocal crosses between TP snw (where TP is TP5 or TP6) and H(hsp/CP)2 strains indicate that repression of germ-line snw mutability occurs only when the telomeric P elements are maternally inherited. However, the analysis of these crosses is complicated by maternal transmission of the transposase activity encoded by the H(hsp/CP)2 transgene (![]()
To obtain unequivocal evidence that repression of transposase-induced snw mutability requires maternal inheritance of the telomeric P elements, we carried out a reciprocal-cross analysis using the P(ry+,
2-3)99B transgene, which does not transmit transposase activity maternally (![]()
2-3)99B males (cross I) and C(1)DX, y f; P(ry+,
2-3)99B females carrying attached-X chromosomes were crossed to TP snw males (cross II). The TP snw; P(ry+,
2-3)99B/+ sons from both types of crosses were then mated individually to C(1)DX, y f females from a P strain with the
2 genetic background to obtain progeny, which were classified and counted for their singed bristle phenotypes. These progeny could be classified unambiguously because their maternally derived P chromosomes repressed the somatic transposase activity encoded by P(ry+,
2-3)99B, which should be present in half of them. Three distinct phenotypes appeared among the progeny: weak singed (snw), wild type (sn+), and extreme singed (sne), the latter two types being due to the excision of one of the P elements in the snw allele while it was in the paternal germ line. As controls, we also measured snw mutability in flies that did not carry a telomeric P element.
The results of these experiments are summarized in Table 2. The control flies from the two reciprocal crosses had snw mutation rates of
0.80, indicating a high level of transposase activity in the germ line. The near identity of these rates demonstrates that there is no reciprocal-cross effect associated with transposase activity itself. The absence of this effect is expected from previous studies, which showed that the transposase activity encoded by the P(ry+,
2-3)99B transgene is not transmitted through the egg cytoplasm (![]()
|
It should be noted that all the flies that were tested for snw mutability in these experiments were somatic mosaics for the singed bristle phenotypes. Thus, as previously demonstrated (![]()
Chromosomes from a P strain partially repress transposase activity when they are inherited paternally:
P strains possess many different P elements scattered throughout the genome. The preceding analyses have indicated that P elements inserted at the left telomere of the X chromosome are associated with a reciprocal-cross effect that is characteristic of germ-line regulation by the P cytotype. Although cytotype is the paramount system of regulating the P-element family, other types of regulation that do not exhibit a reciprocal-cross effect are known (![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
The P strain used in these experiments had the C(1)DX, y f compound-X chromosomes in females and the snw mutation in males. It was produced by introgressing chromosomes from
2, a standard P strain derived from wild-caught flies, into an M strain that carried the C(1)DX, y f compound-X chromosomes (![]()
2) females with snw (
2) males each generation.
Few, if any, non-snw males are ever observed in this P strain, even in mass cultures. However, if snw males from this stock are crossed to C(1)DX, y f females from an M strain, and the sons are then crossed to C(1)DX, y f females to assess germ-line snw mutability, non-snw sons are frequently observed (i.e., >20% of all sons). These findings indicate that the synthetic P strain carries transposase-producing P elements capable of destabilizing snw; however, within the strain, the transposase activity encoded by these P elements is repressed.
To see if this repression could be due to a noncytotype mechanism, we tested paternally inherited chromosomes from this P strain for repression of snw mutability induced by a maternally inherited P(ry+,
2-3)99B transgene. The strategy was to measure
2-3-induced snw mutability in the presence (group I) and absence (group II) of the paternally inherited P chromosomes. Lower snw mutability in the presence of the P chromosomes would indicate a noncytotype mechanism of regulation. The flies for these tests were obtained from crosses between C(1)DX, y f; P(ry+,
2-3)99B females and snw (
2) males (group I) or snw (M) males (group II). Sons were tested for snw mutability by crossing them individually to C(1)DX, y f females from the P strain. As controls, we also measured snw mutability induced by the P chromosomes in the absence of the P(ry+,
2-3)99B transgene (group I'). The flies for these tests were obtained by crossing C(1)DX, y f females from an M strain to snw (
2) males. The results of all of the snw mutability experiments are summarized in Table 3.
|
The paternally inherited P chromosomes repressed somatic transposase activity induced by the P(ry+,
2-3)99B transgene. Among the three types of tested males, nearly all of those in group II showed somatic transposase, whereas almost none of those in groups I and I' showed this activity. The presence of transposase activity in group II is due to somatic production of the P transposase by the P(ry+,
2-3)99B transgene, and the absence of this activity in group I' is due to the lack of this transgene. The absence of somatic transposase activity in group I indicates repression of the P(ry+,
2-3)99B transgene by paternally derived P chromosomes.
The paternally inherited P chromosomes also repressed transposase activity in the germ line. Test groups I and I' had about the same germ-line snw mutability even though the flies in group I carried the
2-3 transposase source. The ability of this transposase source to induce germ-line snw mutability is evident in group II, where the mutation rate is more than twice that of group I. Thus, the paternally inherited P chromosomes present in the flies of group I must repress the germ-line snw mutability induced by the P(ry+,
2-3)99B transgene.
These findings indicate that the P strain used in these experiments possesses a noncytotype regulatory mechanism. Chromosomes inherited paternally from it repress transposase activity in both the soma and the germ line.
Telomeric P elements do not affect the phenotypes of cytotype-dependent alleles in the soma:
![]()
![]()
To determine if telomeric P elements affect so-called cytotype-dependent alleles in the soma, we created stocks homozygous for these elements and the P-insertion mutations vg21-3 and sn50e.
The vg21-3 mutation is due to the insertion of a 2.6-kb P element in the 5' region of the autosomal vestigial gene (![]()
![]()
The sn50e allele is due to the insertion of a 0.6-kb P element in the 5' region of the X-linked singed gene. The inserted P element contains a segment of non-P DNA 125 bp long in place of base pairs 1622540 in the canonical P sequence (![]()
![]()
![]()
In a genetic background devoid of other P elements, sn50e is associated with an extreme mutant phenotype. The bristles are very short and twisted. In the genetic background of a P strain, flies with the sn50e allele have moderately mutant bristleslonger and less twisted than those seen in the extreme mutant phenotype (![]()
|
To follow up these experiments, we tested a complete P element for its ability to suppress the extreme phenotype of sn50e in the presence or absence of telomeric P elements. This complete P element is contained within a hobo transgene, H(hsp/CP)2, inserted on chromosome 2. Previous analyses have shown that this transgene encodes the P transposase as well as a repressor of transposase activity, presumably the 66-kD polypeptide, in the germ line (![]()
Telomeric P elements affect a cytotype-dependent allele in the germ line:
The snw allele is due to the insertion of two incomplete P elements in the first noncoding exon of one of the transcription units of the singed gene. In males this mutation is associated with a weak malformation of the bristles. In females, the bristles are close to wild type, but in some cases, slight malformations can be seen. In males, the bristle phenotype of snw is the same in M and P genetic backgrounds, as well as in the presence of the telomeric P elements TP5 and TP6.
The snw allele also causes homozygous females to be sterile. This "singed sterility" occurs because of faulty vitellogenesis in the nurse cells, which are part of the female germ line (![]()
![]()
We discovered that P elements in the genome of Sexi.4, an M' strain devoid of complete P elements (![]()
![]()
Quantitative data on the fertility of individual homozygous snw females from the original stocks and their Sexi.4 derivatives were obtained by counting progeny at the pupal stage in fertility assay cultures (Table 5). Most of the females from the original stocks produced many progeny; very few were completely sterile. By contrast, none of the homozygous snw females from the Sexi.4 stocks produced any progeny unless a telomeric P element was present. With either TP5 or TP6, most of the tested females produced some progeny, although not as many as the females from the corresponding original stocks. Thus, the sterility caused by the Sexi.4 background is partially suppressed by the telomeric P elements.
|
To determine if this suppression follows the pattern of the P cytotype, we performed reciprocal crosses between the snw; Sexi.4 and TP snw; Sexi.4 strains and tested their daughters for fertility. In series A, snw/FM6; Sexi.4 females were crossed to TP snw; Sexi.4 males and in series B, TP snw; Sexi.4 females were crossed to snw; Sexi.4 males. We analyzed the TP snw/snw; Sexi.4 daughters from both series. These daughters are expected to be genetically identical. As controls, we also analyzed the TP snw/FM6; Sexi.4 daughters from series A. To distribute the effort in these experiments, the tested females were divided into two groups, one assayed within a few days of eclosion (the young group) and the other about a week later (the old group).
Table 6 summarizes the data from these experiments. The control females, which were snw/sn+ heterozygotes, produced many progeny; very few of these females were completely sterile and among those that were fertile, the median number of progeny ranged from 38 to 43. The females that were homozygous for snw produced significantly fewer progeny. Among those from cross A, many were completely sterile: 77 and 96% of the TP5 females and 36 and 81% of the TP6 females, from the young and old groups, respectively. Among the females from cross B, the corresponding sterility frequencies were lower: 14 and 60% of the TP5 females and 7 and 7% of the TP6 females. By z-tests based on binomial variances, these frequencies are significantly lower than those for the females from cross A (P < 0.05 in all four comparisons). Thus, this form of sterility exhibits a reciprocal-cross effect: less sterility in the daughters of cross B, where a telomeric P element had been transmitted maternally, than in the daughters of cross A. The number of progeny produced by the fertile females from these two crosses also showed a reciprocal-cross effect. Among the snw homozygotes from cross A, the median numbers of progeny were 2 and 1.5 for the TP5 females and 4 and 1 for the TP6 females, from the young and old groups, respectively. Among the snw homozygotes from cross B, the corresponding numbers were 4 and 2 and 12 and 13. By the Mann-Whitney rank-sum test, the cross B females had significantly more progeny than did the cross A females in the three comparisons that were made (TP5 young, TP6 young, and TP6 old females; P < 0.05 in each case). Thus, maternal transmission of a telomeric P element appears to be associated with suppression of sterility and reduced fertility in snw homozygotesa phenomenon that parallels the maternally transmitted repression of germ-line transposase activity by the telomeric P elements. Furthermore, the data suggest that the suppression of snw sterility is more obvious among young females than among old ones and that it is more pronounced with TP6 than with TP5.
|
To show that the sterility caused by the Sexi.4 genetic background specifically involves a malfunction of the singed gene, we analyzed females heterozygous for snw and snx2. The latter mutation is an X-ray-induced null allele that has an extreme singed bristle phenotype and that causes female sterility. If snw/snx2 females with the Sexi.4 background are sterile but snw/+ females with the same background are not, then the observed sterility must involve a malfunction of snw evoked by the Sexi.4 background. Males from the original snw stocks and their Sexi.4 derivatives were crossed to FM7, y31d snx2 B/+ females (cross A) and the two types of daughters, snw/snx2 and snw/+, were assayed for fertility. We also assayed snw/snx2 daughters from the reciprocal cross, FM7, y31d snx2 B males x snw (or snw/FM6) females (cross B). The results of these experiments are summarized in Table 7.
|
As expected, the snw/+ heterozygotes produced many progeny, even when they carried Sexi.4 chromosomes. A vast majority of these females were fertile and, among those that were, the median number of progeny ranged from 38 to 48. These results are similar to those from the controls in Table 6. Different results were obtained from the snw/snx2 females, which were phenotypically weak singed. From cross A, most of the females with the Sexi.4 background were sterile, even when a telomeric P element was present (100% sterile without a TP, 95% sterile with TP5, and 87% sterile with TP6). By contrast, very few (<6%) of the snw/snx2 females without the Sexi.4 background were completely sterile. Although these females did produce fewer progeny (median numbers 24, 28, and 30) than the snw/+ controls, they produced many more progeny than the few fertile snw/snx2 females that had the Sexi.4 background (median numbers 1 and 2 for the TP5 and TP6 females, respectively). Thus, the sterility and reduced fertility of the snw/snx2 females appears to be caused by an adverse effect of the Sexi.4 background on the function of the snw allele.
The snw/snx2 females from cross B provided an opportunity to observe suppression of singed sterility by maternally inherited telomeric P elements. Of course, without the Sexi.4 background, little sterility was seen. With the Sexi.4 background, the majority of the snw/snx2 females from cross B were sterile, even when a telomeric P element was present. However, for both TP5 and TP6 the sterility frequencies were slightly less than those seen with the corresponding females from cross A (by z-tests, P < 0.05 for TP6, but not for TP5). There were not enough fertile females to test for differences in the numbers of progeny produced by the A and B females. Thus, in these experiments, there is some evidence that maternal transmission of a telomeric P element suppresses singed sterility.
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
The telomeric P elements TP5 and TP6 are strong repressors of P-element activity in the germ line. Both elements repress P-induced gonadal dysgenesis and transposase-catalyzed P-element excision. However, the repression abilities of these telomeric P elements are manifested only when they are transmitted maternally to the offspring of a dysgenic cross. Paternal transmission abolishes repression ability completely. This reciprocal-cross effect is not seen in tests with KP elements or transgenes containing KP elements or with transgenes that produce other repressor polypeptides. Such elements and transgenes repress germ-line P activity when they are transmitted from either parent (![]()
![]()
![]()
Passage through the female germ line is a sine qua non for repression by telomeric P elements. However, the repression itself is not limited to the female germ line. Males that have inherited a telomeric P element from their mothers effectively repress gonadal dysgenesis and snw mutability in their germ lines. The regulatory state associated with telomeric P elements is therefore transmitted maternally to offspring of both sexes. However, a telomeric P element that has passed from a female to a male will lose its repression ability if that element is transmitted to a male in the next generation. The regulatory state associated with telomeric P elements is therefore established and maintained in the female germ line.
Although maternally transmitted telomeric P elements are strong repressors of P activity in the germ line, they appear to be without effect in the soma. Some P polypeptides repress the somatic transposase activity encoded by the P(ry+,
2-3)99B transgene (![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
In the course of this study, we found that the H(hsp/CP)2 transgene, which is capable of producing the 66-kD repressor polypeptide in the soma, partially suppresses the phenotype of sn50e, a P-insertion allele of the singed gene. Chromosomes from a P strain also had this effect, presumably because they carry P elements that encode the 66-kD or other repressor polypeptides. The mechanism of this suppression is unknown. However, it might involve the formation of a secondary structure in the DNA of the inserted P element. ![]()
Repressor P polypeptides also alter the expression of some P-insertion mutations in the germ linefor example, snw. This double P insertion of the singed gene is associated with reduced female fertility, but only when repressor P polypeptides are present (![]()
![]()
![]()
Our most significant finding, however, is that the singed sterility evoked by the Sexi.4 P elements is partially suppressed by telomeric P elementsmore so in snw homozygotes than in snw/snx2 heterozygotes. Furthermore, this suppression is more effective when the telomeric P elements are transmitted from females in a cross. This reciprocal-cross effect, reminiscent of cytotype regulation, indicates that maternally transmitted telomeric P elements can control the synthesis or behavior of repressor P polypeptides either by silencing the expression of the P elements that encode these polypeptides or by altering the chromatin around the P elements with which these polypeptides interact. However, this control of repressor P polypeptides is not absolute. Heterozygous snw/snx2 females show high levels of singed sterility even though they have inherited a telomeric P element maternally (Table 7). ![]()
Singed sterility is also partially suppressed in homozygous snw females that have inherited a telomeric P element paternally (Table 6). This result may seem at odds with the loss of repression ability when telomeric P elements are paternally transmitted. However, this loss is observed in father-to-son, i.e., patroclinous, transmission. When transmission is from father to daughter, the telomeric P element is returned to a female germ line, where it might be able to reestablish some of its repression ability. The partial suppression of singed sterility seen in Table 6 may therefore be evidence for a revival of the regulatory ability of a telomeric P element that has passed through the male germ line.
Given what we have learned about P-insertion mutations such as vg21-3, sn50e, and snw, it seems appropriate to revise the terminology that has been used to describe them. Heretofore, these kinds of P-insertion mutations have been called "cytotype-dependent" alleles because their expression seemed to be conditioned on the cytotype of the fly. We believe there are several reasons for replacing this term with "repressor sensitive." First, cytotype regulation is limited to the germ line; P-insertion alleles with somatic phenotypes therefore cannot be cytotype dependent. Second, telomeric P elements, which are associated with the P cytotype, do not alter the germ-line phenotype of snw; thus, cytotype itself does not regulate the expression of this allele. Third, the expression of vg21-3, sn50e, and snw is altered by P elements that encode repressor polypeptides; moreover, these alterations occur no matter which parent contributes the repressor P element in a crossthat is, they are cytotype independent. Fourth, the germ-line phenotype of snw is altered by chromosomes from a strain with the M cytotype, presumably because these chromosomes carry P elements that encode some type of repressor polypeptide; thus, it is the repressor-encoding P elements, not the cytotype, that alter the snw phenotype. Fifth, this alteration of phenotype is suppressed by maternally inherited telomeric P elements that are associated with the P cytotype; the P cytotype therefore actually reverses the phenotype of the repressor-sensitive allele.
At its inception, the analysis of hybrid dysgenesis defined two broad classes of strains, M and P, on the basis of their ability to induce and repress gonadal dysgenesis in pairwise crosses (![]()
![]()
The regulation of germ-line P-element activity in P, Q, and M' strains involves a complex blend of mechanisms. In some strains, P elements may be quiescent due to the absence of complete P elements that can produce the transposase. In other strains, repressor P polypeptides may regulate transposase activity. Studies suggest that this form of regulation does not depend on the parental origin of the repressor P elements and that it has rather modest effects. In P and Q strains, P activity is repressed by the maternally inherited P cytotype. Although the mechanistic basis of this condition is still unclear, it appears to be associated with P elements inserted near the left telomere of the X chromosome. It seems unlikely that the strong regulatory abilities of these elements are mediated by repressor polypeptides (![]()
![]()
![]()
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
Mark Liszewski provided technical help. Funding was provided by National Institutes of Health grant GM-40263, the University of Minnesota Graduate School, and the Minnesota Medical Foundation.
Manuscript received June 24, 2003; Accepted for publication September 28, 2003.
| LITERATURE CITED |
|---|
ADAMS, M. D., S. E. CELNIKER, R. A. HOLT, C. A. EVANS, and J. D. GOCAYNE et al., 2000 The genome sequence of Drosophila melanogaster. Science 287:2185-2195.
BINGHAM, P. M., M. G. KIDWELL, and G. M. RUBIN, 1982 The molecular basis of P-M hybrid dysgenesis: the role of the P element, a P strain-specific transposon family. Cell 29:995-1004.[CrossRef][Medline]
BLACK, D. M., M. S. JACKSON, M. G. KIDWELL, and G. A. DOVER, 1987 KP elements repress P-induced hybrid dysgenesis in Drosophila melanogaster.. EMBO J. 6:4125-4135.[Medline]
ENGELS, W. R., 1979a Hybrid dysgenesis in Drosophila melanogaster: rules of inheritance of female sterility. Genet. Res. 33:219-236.
ENGELS, W. R., 1979b Extrachromosomal control of mutability in Drosophila melanogaster.. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 76:4011-4015.
ENGELS, W. R., 1984 A trans-acting product needed for P factor transposition in Drosophila.. Science 226:1194-1196.
GLOOR, G. B., C. R. PRESTON, D. M. JOHNSON-SCHLITZ, N. A. NASSIF, and R. W. PHILLIS et al., 1993 Type I repressors of P-element mobility. Genetics 135:81-95.[Abstract]
HODGETTS, R. B. and S. L. O'KEEFE, 2001 The mutant phenotype associated with P-element alleles of the vestigial locus in Drosophila melanogaster may be caused by a readthrough transcript initiated at the P-element promoter. Genetics 157:1665-1672.
JACKSON, M. S., D. M. BLACK, and G. A. DOVER, 1988 Amplification of KP elements associated with the repression of hybrid dysgenesis in Drosophila melanogaster.. Genetics 120:1003-1013.
KARESS, R. and G. M. RUBIN, 1984 Analysis of P transposable element functions in Drosophila. Cell 38:135-146.[CrossRef][Medline]
KIDWELL, M. G., J. F. KIDWELL, and J. A. SVED, 1977 Hybrid dysgenesis in Drosophila melanogaster: a syndrome of aberrant traits including mutation, sterility and male recombination. Genetics 86:813-833.
LASKI, F. A., D. C. RIO, and G. M. RUBIN, 1986 Tissue specificity of Drosophila P element transposition is regulated at the level of mRNA splicing. Cell 44:7-19.[CrossRef][Medline]
LEE, C. C., Y. M. MUL, and D. C. RIO, 1996 The Drosophila P-element KP repressor protein dimerizes and interacts with multiple sites on P-element DNA. Mol. Cell. Biol. 16:5616-5622.[Abstract]
LEE, C. C., E. L. BEALL, and D. C. RIO, 1998 DNA binding by the KP repressor protein inhibits P-element transposase activity in vivo.. EMBO J. 17:4166-4174.[CrossRef][Medline]
LEMAITRE, B., S. RONSSERAY, and D. COEN, 1993 Maternal repression of the P element promoter in the germline of Drosophila melanogaster: a model for the P cytotype. Genetics 135:149-160.[Abstract]
LINDSLEY, D. L., and G. ZIMM, 1992 The Genome of Drosophila melanogaster. Academic Press, New York.
MARIN, L., M. LEHMANN, D. NOUAUD, H. IZAABEL, and D. ANXOLABÉ
ERE et al., 2000 P-element repression in Drosophila melanogaster by a naturally occurring defective telomeric P copy. Genetics 155:1841-1854.
MISRA, S. and D. C. RIO, 1990 Cytotype control of Drosophila P element transposition: the 66 kD protein is a repressor of transposase activity. Cell 62:269-284.[CrossRef][Medline]
O'HARE, K. and G. M. RUBIN, 1983 Structure of P transposable elements and their sites of insertion and excision in the Drosophila melanogaster genome. Cell 34:25-35.[CrossRef][Medline]
O'HARE, K., A. DRIVER, S. MCGRATH, and D. M. JOHNSON-SCHLITZ, 1992 Distribution and structure of cloned P elements from the Drosophila melanogaster P strain
2. Genet. Res. 60:33-41.[Medline]
RASMUSSON, K. E., M. J. SIMMONS, J. D. RAYMOND, and C. F. MCLARNON, 1990 Quantitative effects of P elements on hybrid dysgenesis in Drosophila melanogaster.. Genetics 124:647-662.[Abstract]
ROBERTSON, H. M. and W. R. ENGELS, 1989 Modified P elements that mimic the P cytotype in Drosophila melanogaster.. Genetics 123:815-824.
ROBERTSON, H. M., C. R. PRESTON, R. W. PHILLIS, D. JOHNSON-SCHLITZ, and W. K. BENZ et al., 1988 A stable genomic source of P element transposase in Drosophila melanogaster.. Genetics 118:461-470.
ROCHE, S., M. SCHIFF, and D. C. RIO, 1995 P-element repressor autoregulation involves germ-line transcriptional repression and reduction of third intron splicing. Genes Dev. 9:1278-1288.
ROIHA, H., G. M. RUBIN, and K. O'HARE, 1988 P element insertions and rearrangements at the singed locus of Drosophila melanogaster.. Genetics 119:75-83.
RONSSERAY, S., M. LEHMANN, and D. ANXOLABÉHÈRE, 1991 The maternally inherited regulation of P elements in Drosophila melanogaster can be elicited by two P copies at cytological site 1A on the X chromosome. Genetics 129:501-512.[Abstract]
RONSSERAY, S., M. LEHMANN, D. NOUAND, and D. ANXOLABÉHÈRE, 1996 The regulatory properties of autonomous subtelomeric P elements are sensitive to a Suppressor of variegation in Drosophila melanogaster. Genetics 143:1663-1674.[Abstract]
RONSSERAY, S., L. MARIN, M. LEHMANN, and D. ANXOLABÉHÈRE, 1998 Repression of hybrid dysgenesis in Drosophila melanogaster by combinations of telomeric P-element reporters and naturally occurring P elements. Genetics 149:1857-1866.
RONSSERAY, S., A. BOIVIN, and D. ANXOLABÉHÈRE, 2001 P-element repression in Drosophila melanogaster by variegating clusters of P-lacZ-white transgenes. Genetics 159:1631-1642.
SIMMONS, M. J., N. A. JOHNSON, T. M. FAHEY, S. M. NELLET, and J. D. RAYMOND, 1980 High mutability in male hybrids of Drosophila melanogaster.. Genetics 96:479-490.
SIMMONS, M. J., J. D. RAYMOND, K. E. RASMUSSON, L. M. MILLER, and C. F. MCLARNON et al., 1990 Repression of P-element-mediated hybrid dysgenesis in Drosophila melanogaster.. Genetics 124:663-676.[Abstract]
SIMMONS, M. J., K. J. HALEY, C. D. GRIMES, J. D. RAYMOND, and J. B. NIEMI, 2002a A hobo transgene that encodes the P-element transposase in Drosophila melanogaster: autoregulation and cytotype control of transposase activity. Genetics 161:195-204.
SIMMONS, M. J., K. J. HALEY, C. D. GRIMES, J. D. RAYMOND, and J. C. L. FONG, 2002b Regulation of P-element transposase activity in Drosophila melanogaster by hobo transgenes that contain KP elements. Geneti