- THIS ARTICLE
-
Abstract
- Full Text (PDF)
- Alert me when this article is cited
- Alert me if a correction is posted
- SERVICES
- Similar articles in this journal
- Similar articles in PubMed
- Alert me to new issues of the journal
- Download to citation manager
- Reprints & Permissions
- CITING ARTICLES
- Citing Articles via HighWire
- Citing Articles via Google Scholar
- GOOGLE SCHOLAR
- Articles by Goldstein, A. L.
- Articles by McCusker, J. H.
- Search for Related Content
- PUBMED
- PubMed Citation
- Articles by Goldstein, A. L.
- Articles by McCusker, J. H.
Development of Saccharomyces cerevisiae as a Model Pathogen: A System for the Genetic Identification of Gene Products Required for Survival in the Mammalian Host Environment
Alan L. Goldsteina and John H. McCuskera,ba Department of Microbiology, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, North Carolina 27710
b Department of Genetics, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, North Carolina 27710
Corresponding author: John H. McCusker, Department of Microbiology, 3020, Duke University Medical Ctr., Durham, NC 27710., mccus001{at}mc.duke.edu (E-mail)
Communicating editor: A. P. MITCHELL
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
Saccharomyces cerevisiae, a close relative of the pathogenic Candida species, is an emerging opportunistic pathogen. An isogenic series of S. cerevisiae strains, derived from a human clinical isolate, were used to examine the role of evolutionarily conserved pathways in fungal survival in a mouse host. As is the case for the corresponding Candida albicans and Cryptococcus neoformans mutants, S. cerevisiae purine and pyrimidine auxotrophs were severely deficient in survival, consistent with there being evolutionary conservation of survival traits. Resistance to the antifungal drug 5-fluorocytosine was not deleterious and appeared to be slightly advantageous in vivo. Of mutants in three amino acid biosynthetic pathways, only leu2 mutants were severely deficient in vivo. Unlike the glyoxylate cycle, respiration was very important for survival; however, the mitochondrial genome made a respiration-independent contribution to survival. Mutants deficient in pseudohyphal formation were tested in vivo; flo11
mutants were phenotypically neutral while flo8
, tec1
, and flo8
tec1
mutants were slightly deficient. Because of its ease of genetic manipulation and the immense S. cerevisiae database, which includes the best annotated eukaryotic genome sequence, S. cerevisiae is a superb model system for the identification of gene products important for fungal survival in the mammalian host environment.
SACCHAROMYCES cerevisiae is closely related to the pathogenic Candida species (![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
The work described here further develops S. cerevisiae as a model system to identify highly conserved signal transduction and metabolic pathways critical for fungal survival in the host environment. Since the importance of many gene products depends upon the environment, one of the fundamental steps in genetic analysis is the identification of gene products that are important for survival in specific environments. This is particularly true for the difficult issue of survival of pathogens in the host environment. Genetic analysis can identify which of these pathways are necessary for in vivo survival and thereby greatly improve our understanding of fungal pathogenesis.
To test specific hypotheses regarding survival in the host environment, dominant drug-resistance markers (DDRM; ![]()
![]()
![]()
::DDRM) and mutant strains. Accurate determinations of survival phenotypes were possible because wild-type and mutant strains, which could be readily distinguished, were in competition and therefore simultaneously exposed to the same environment.
As an initial test of the system and the generality of fungal gene products required for survival in the host environment, S. cerevisiae ade2
and ura3
mutants were found to be deficient in survival, as is the case for the equivalent Candida albicans and Cryptococcus neoformans mutants (![]()
![]()
![]()
) mutants were only slightly deficient in survival. In contrast, respiratory-deficient mutants (cox15
,
0) were severely deficient. Finally, the contribution of dimorphism to survival was assessed; flocculin-deficient flo11
mutants were phenotypically neutral while the transcription factor-deficient flo8
, tec1
, and flo8
tec1
mutants, which are required for expression of FLO11, were slightly deficient in survival in vivo.
The ease of genetically manipulating S. cerevisiae, relative to the more commonly observed pathogenic fungi, along with the immense database and highly annotated genome sequence of this species, makes S. cerevisiae a powerful, genetically tractable model system to identify pathways required for fungal survival in the mammalian host environment.
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
Strains:
All S. cerevisiae strains used in these experiments are listed in Table 1 and were isogenic with YJM145, a homothallic, clinically derived strain. YJM145, and strains isogenic with YJM145, have been extensively characterized genetically (![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
diploid strains were used in all experimental infection experiments because, unlike diploid YJM145 background strains, haploid YJM145 background strains exhibited severe clumping, which precluded the accurate determination of colony-forming units (A. L. GOLDSTEIN and J. H. MCCUSKER, unpublished data); in addition, S. cerevisiae diploids, but not haploids, were observed clinically (![]()
![]()
![]()
|
Media:
Yeast extract-peptone-dextrose (YEPD) medium (![]()
![]()
![]()
mutants was tested on YEPD medium containing 10-2 M 5-fluorocytosine, which was added to autoclaved medium. The ability to respire was determined by the ability to grow on yeast extract-peptone-ethanol-glycerol medium, which contains the nonfermentable carbon sources ethanol and glycerol, each at 2% final concentrations; ethanol was added after autoclaving. Auxotrophic requirements were determined by growth on synthetic defined media (![]()
![]()
Gene disruptions and strain construction:
All gene replacements were performed by PCR-mediated gene replacement (![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
|
Between 500 ng and 2 µg of PCR product was used to transform S. cerevisiae strains using either the lithium acetate/dithiothreitol electroporation (![]()
![]()
2 mm in diameter. Homologous integration of dominant drug-resistance cassettes was verified by colony PCR (![]()
Deletion mutations marked by dominant drug-resistance markers were made by transforming a diploid YJM145 background strain to generate deletion heterozygotes. To generate deletion homozygotes for testing in experimental infections, deletion heterozygotes were sporulated at 30°, tetrads were dissected, and the phenotypes of both the dominant drug-resistance marker and the gene deletion mutation were determined. Every deletion homozygote used in this study was isolated from deletion heterozygotes, the tetrads of which showed absolute 2:2 cosegregation of the dominant drug-resistance marker and the deletion mutation.
Experimental infections:
Systemic infections were established in 4- to 5-week-old male CD-1 mice (outbred, immune competent; Charles River Laboratory, Wilmington, MA) as described previously (![]()
2 x 107 yeast cells suspended in phosphate buffered saline (PBS; pH 7.4); mice were provided food and water ad libitum throughout the course of the experiments. In most instances, the inoculum was composed of a pool of three isogenic YJM145 background strains, each differentially marked with dominant drug-resistance cassettes. Pools of three strains were established by first growing each strain separately in YEPD at 30° to mid-log phase and determining the concentration of cells by hemocytometer count. Approximately equal numbers of cells of each strain were then combined in PBS to produce a total cell concentration of
2 x 108 cells/ml. Viable cell counts were also determined for the inocula by plating serial dilutions onto antibiotic-containing plates.
To recover yeast cells from infected mice, the mice were euthanized in CO2 and brain tissue was dissected from each animal; each brain was homogenized in 5 ml PBS containing 100 µg/ml ampicillin and streptomycin, for 20 sec with a Tekmar T25 homogenizer with an 8-mm probe at 19,000 rpm. Each brain homogenate was centrifuged for 10 min at 700 x g, the supernatant was discarded, and the pellet was resuspended in 12 ml PBS containing 100 µg/ml ampicillin and streptomycin. For each strain with which a mouse was infected, 100 µl of supernatant, or appropriate dilutions of the supernatant, was plated onto three of the appropriate antibiotic-containing plates, and the colonies on the plates were counted. Because at least the wild-type control in every competition was present on average at >105 colony-forming units/brain at 14 days postinfection, dilutions were made such that each of the three plates usually contained 200 or more colonies. The number of colonies of the three plates was added and this number was used to determine the ratio of each mutant to the wild-type control within the homogenate from each animal.
Competitive indices:
The ability of mutant strains to compete with wild type was quantified by competitive indices, a well-established method in bacterial (e.g., ![]()
![]()
![]()
|
|
To determine in vitro competitive indices, YAG40 (HO/ho
::hphMX4) and two mutant strains (orf
::natMX4/orf
::natMX4 and orf
::kanMX4/orf
::kanMX4) were grown separately to 1.0 OD600 and then pooled in equal amounts before adding
104 cells of the pool to 1 liter of YEPD. The pooled cells were then cultured at 37° with shaking until the OD600 of the culture was
1 x 108 cells/ml at which point 0.5 ml of each culture was passaged to 1 liter of fresh YEPD. In total, each pool was passaged through 3 liters of YEPD. After each culture reached
1 x 108 cells/ml, a sample was diluted and plated to YEPD plates containing either hygromycin B, G418, or nourseothricin to determine the composition of the population. After the colonies were counted, competitive indices were calculated as described above. Population doublings were calculated using the formula (final cell concentration)/(initial cell concentration)
2n, where n is approximately equal to the number of population doublings.
| RESULTS |
|---|
Experimental design:
Survival competition experiments were performed by pooling wild-type and mutant strains into a single inoculum. In most instances, the inoculum contained three diploid strains, each containing a unique DDRM integrated into the yeast genome. Because each mouse was infected with a population, each mouse constituted a separate, self-contained experiment where two mutants were assayed for survival relative to a wild-type control.
In every case, one of the three diploid strains was heterozygous at the HO locus where one of the HO ORFs was replaced with a DDRMHO/ho
::DDRM. The decision to use HO/ho
::DDRM strains as wild-type controls was based on three factors. First, HO is expressed only in haploids (![]()
![]()
![]()
Since the DDRMs had no effect on the survival of S. cerevisiae in mice, when compared to each other or to an unmarked isogenic strain (see below), the HO/ho
::DDRM strains served as the wild-type control in the inocula. The inocula also contained two mutants, each mutant being homozygous for a deletion of the same gene but each mutant strain containing a different DDRM; this redundancy served as an internal control for consistency. For each experiment, systemic infections were initiated by lateral tail-vein injection of 15 4- to 5-week-old male CD-1 mice with a total of
2 x 107 cells, which was previously determined to be the optimum inoculum dose for S. cerevisiae infections in CD-1 mice (![]()
![]()
Neutrality of dominant drug-resistance markers in vivo:
The first experiments established that the hygromycin B, G418, and nourseothricin antibiotic resistance cassettes were neutral for survival in mice, as they were in in vitro competition experiments in liquid media (![]()
![]()
::natMX4), YJH7 (HO/ho
::kanMX4), and YJH10 (HO/ho
::hphMX4). Between 4 hr and 14 days postinfection, the percentage of each strain within the population remained constant (for YJH3, from 33.0 ± 1.8% to 31.8 ± 3.5%; for YJH7, from 32.1 ± 1.3% to 32.1 ± 2.9%; for YJH10, from 35.0 ± 1.3% to 36.1 ± 3.9%), showing that none of the DDRMs conferred a survival advantage or disadvantage to S. cerevisiae in mice. In two additional repetitions of this experiment, the largest change seen between 4 hr and 14 days postinfection was an increase from 35.0 ± 2.0% to 39.7 ± 4.0% for YJH7.
To get an idea for the noise in the system, the data from the in vivo competitions between YJH3, YJH7, and YJH10 were used to calculate competitive indices where, in successive calculations, one of the three strains was viewed as wild type and the other two strains as mutant. The lowest competitive index calculated from these wildtype strain competitions was 0.75 and the highest was 1.38. Therefore, competitive indices of 0.75 and 1.38 were used as thresholds. Mutants with average competitive indices >0.75 but <1.38 were characterized as phenotypically equivalent to wild type. Mutants with average competitive indices greater than 1.38 were characterized as being advantageous in vivo. Mutants with average competitive indices at 14 days postinfection of <0.75 but >0.2 were characterized as being slightly deficient while those with competitive indices of <0.2 were characterized as being severely deficient.
Pool complexity:
Given that the DDRMs were phenotypically neutral in vivo and that pools of at least three strains could be tested, the next step was to determine whether larger pools could be tested. As the size or complexity of an inoculum pool increases, so does the chance that, due to stochastic effects, insufficient numbers of any one strain can be recovered from infected tissue, resulting in the misidentification of gene products required for survival. To determine how many S. cerevisiae mutants could be combined in an inoculum pool, a competition experiment was performed where three strains were combined in different ratios to mimic different pool sizes; the bulk of the initial inoculum population consisted of an unmarked wild-type strain (YAG129) and the remainder of the population consisted of YAG40 (HO/ho
::hphMX4) in an
1:6 ratio or 17.1% of the population and YAG38 (HO/ho
::kanMX4) in an
1:13 ratio or 7.5% of the population. Between 4 hr and 14 days postinfection, there was little change in the percentages of YAG129 (75.4 ± 5.1% to 75.6 ± 2.9%) and YAG40 (17.1 ± 3.6% to 20.0 ± 2.8%) within the population. Therefore, a pool of at least six strains can be tested for survival in CD-1 mice over a 14-day time course. The decrease of YAG38 from 7.5 ± 1.5% at 4 hr postinfection to 4.5 ± 0.7% of the population at 14 days postinfection suggested that 13 strains may be approaching the pool size limit, at least for this mouse model system at a 14-day timepoint. However, even in a pool of 13 mutants, minor fluctuations such as these would not prohibit the identification of mutants with severe in vivo survival defects.
Mating does not occur in vivo:
The ability to pool strains within a single inoculum required that mating must not occur in vivo, because mating would result in the complementation of mutations in different strains. All the strains used in these experimental infections were MATa/MAT
diploids and therefore unable to mate. However, these strains might, at least in principle, sporulate in vivo to produce mating-competent haploid spores. Since the pool included HO/ho
::kanMX4 and HO/ho
::natMX4 strains, ho
::kanMX4/ho
::natMX4 diploids would be generated if mating occurred in vivo. To determine if any mating occurred in vivo, the homogenates of the neutrality experiments, which contained 3001000 colony-forming units when plated onto YEPD + G418 or YEPD + nourseothricin, were also plated onto YEPD + G418 + nourseothricin. No colonies grew on the YEPD + G418 + nourseothricin plates, which strongly argues that mating did not occur in vivo.
The role of nucleotide biosynthesis in survival in vivo:
Both the purine and pyrimidine biosynthetic pathways are required for pathogenesis in the phylogenetically diverse species of C. albicans (![]()
![]()
![]()
, ade4
, and ura3
S. cerevisiae mutants were constructed and evaluated for survival in the CD-1 mouse model system.
The ura3
strains YAG216c and YAG218a were compared to the prototrophic strain YAG40 for survival. As shown in Table 3, there was a significant loss of the ura3
strains as rapidly as 4 hr postinoculation. After 14 days, the ura3
mutants were severely depleted in the population. To prove that the reduced survival of the ura3
mutants was due to loss of the URA3 gene, the URA3 gene was transformed into ura3
strain YAG216c to generate the Ura+ strain YAG228 (URA3/ura3
::natMX4). As shown in Table 4, the reintroduction of the URA3 gene restored survival, confirming the requirement of Ura3p for survival.
Since de novo biosynthesis of pyrimidines was important for survival, the pyrimidine salvage pathway might be important for fungal survival as well. To test this hypothesis, fcy1
strains deficient in cytosine deaminase, a part of the pyrimidine salvage pathway that converts cytosine to uracil, were constructed and tested for survival. As shown in Table 3, the fcy1
mutation was not deleterious and appeared to confer a slight selective advantage in vivo.
Table 3 shows a similar assay for the requirement of purine biosynthesis in vivo using the ade2
strains YAG210a and YAG208a vs. YAG40 and the ade4
strains YAG269a and YAG271a vs. YAG40. In contrast to the ura3
mutants, the ade2
and ade4
mutants were not dramatically reduced from the in vivo population 4 hr postinoculation. However, after 7 days the ade2
and ade4
mutants were both severely depleted. To establish that the survival defect of the ade2
mutants was due to the ade2 mutation, the ADE2 gene was transformed into the ade2
strain YAG208a to generate YAG226 (ADE2/ade2
::kanMX4). As shown in Table 4, the wild-type ADE2 gene restored survival to wild-type levels.
To compare in vivo with in vitro competition results, the ade2
strains YAG210a and YAG208a and the ade4
strains YAG269a and YAG271a were competed in vitro against the wild-type strain YAG40. After 23 population doublings in YEPD at 37°, the competitive indices for the ade2
strains were 0.004 for YAG210a and 0.001 for YAG208a; after 34 population doublings, both ade2
strains were undetectable with competitive indices of <0.0008. In contrast, after 23, 34, and 45 population doublings, the in vitro competitive indices for the ade4
strains were 0.54, 0.53, and 0.25 for YAG269a and 0.35, 0.28, and 0.15 for YAG271a, respectively.
The role of amino acid biosynthesis in survival in vivo:
Virtually all of the amino acids are present at substantial concentrations in serum (see ![]()
The leu2
strains YAG185b and YAG183b were compared to prototrophic YAG40 for their ability to survive in mice. As shown in Table 3, the leu2
strains were severely depleted by 14 days postinfection. In contrast, as shown in Table 3, his3
mutants were only slightly deficient in vivo and trp1
mutants were approximately equivalent to the prototrophic control. One possible explanation for this result is that the prototrophic strain in each pool was able to cross-feed the auxotrophs. To determine if the prototrophic YAG40 strain in the mixed infection somehow supplied exogenous histidine or tryptophan to the auxotrophic mutants, three groups of 10 mice were infected, separately, with
2 x 107 cells of each auxotrophic strain and a prototrophic control. Five mice from each group were sacrificed 4 hr postinfection and the remaining 5 were sacrificed 14 days later. Brain homogenate (100 µl) from each animal was plated in triplicate onto antibiotic plates and the colonies counted after incubation at 30°. When infected in the absence of wild-type cells, the survival of his3
and trp1
mutants was almost equivalent to wild type (data not shown). Therefore, cross-feeding between prototrophic and mutant strains in vivo was not responsible for the survival of the his3
and trp1
strains. In contrast to leu2
strains, the phenotype of his3
and trp1
strains suggested that the concentrations of histidine and tryptophan, coupled with the histidine and tryptophan transport capacity, were sufficient for survival in vivo.
The role of the glyoxylate cycle in survival in vivo:
Carbon source utilization to generate energy will be important for survival of pathogens in vivo. One aspect of carbon source utilization and energy metabolism is the glyoxylate cycle. The glyoxylate cycle is not required for utilizing sugars or C3 compounds, such as glycerol, as carbon sources. However, the glyoxylate cycle is required for utilizing C2 compounds, such as ethanol and acetate (![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
strains YAG323a and YAG331c were competed against YAG40. As shown in Table 3, the icl1
mutants were slightly deficient in survival compared to wild type at 14 days postinfection; a 21-day postinfection timepoint showed a similar phenotype (data not shown).
In CD-1 mice, S. cerevisiae proliferated and showed extended survival only in the brain (![]()
![]()
![]()
mutants had an attenuated ability to survive in other mouse organs, and to assess survival at longer timepoints, survival of the icl1
mutants YAG323a and YAG331c was compared to YAG40 in complement factor 5-deficient DBA/2N mice. Relative to wild type, the icl1
mutants showed equivalent survival in liver, lung, and kidney at 14 days, in spleen at 21 days, and in brain at 28 days (data not shown).
The role of respiration and the mitochondrial genome in survival in vivo:
Respiration is another key aspect of energy metabolism. Unlike most of the pathogenic fungi, S. cerevisiae is petite positive; that is, S. cerevisiae can lose its mitochondrial genome and remain viable (reviewed in ![]()
COX15 is a nuclearly encoded gene, the gene product of which is required for cytochrome c oxidase assembly (![]()
strains YAG152a and YAG154a were compared to YAG38 for their ability to survive. As shown in Table 3, the cox15
mutants were significantly depleted in vivo. To determine that the reduced survival of the cox15
strains was due to loss of the COX15 gene, the COX15 gene was transformed into YAG152a to generate YAG230 (COX15/cox15
::natMX4). As shown in Table 4, the wildtype COX15 gene restored the ability to survive to the cox15
strain.
MIP1 is the nuclearly encoded structural gene for the catalytic subunit of the mitochondrial-specific DNA polymerase. In the absence of Mip1p, yeast cells are unable to respire because they have lost their mitochondrial genome and become
0 (![]()
![]()
0 strains YAG180b and YAG182a were compared to YAG40 for the ability to survive in mice. As shown in Table 3, the mip1
0 strains were rapidly and severely depleted in mice. Unlike all of the other mutations in this study, mip1
causes loss of the mitochondrial genome, a defect that cannot be complemented by reintroduction of MIP1. Therefore, YAG158, an isogenic MIP1 strain that was made
0 with ethidium bromide (![]()
0 strains, this MIP1
0 strain was rapidly and severely depleted in mice (Table 3). Because MIP1
0 and mip1
0 strains had the same phenotype in mice, the effect on survival in vivo was independent of Mip1p and was due to the absence of the mitochondrial genome.
The cox15
and mip1
results were consistent with the hypothesis that respiration was required for survival. However, although both the cox15
and mip1
mutants were depleted in vivo, the two mutants behaved differently. While the cox15
mutants at 7 days postinfection had a competitive disadvantage relative to wild type of
12-fold, the mip1
mutants had a competitive disadvantage of
130-fold. These results suggest that the mitochondrial genome contributes more to fitness and to survival in vivo than the ability to respire.
The role of dimorphism in survival in vivo:
Although there are exceptions, such as C. glabrata, which does not undergo dimorphism in vivo (![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
, flo8
, tec1
, and flo8
tec1
mutations were introduced into the YJM145 background; these mutants were streaked onto SLAD plates and scored for pseudohyphal formation after 1 week. While the tec1
mutants were able to form pseudohyphae almost as abundantly as wild type, the flo11
, flo8
, and flo8
tec1
mutants formed few, if any, pseudohyphae (data not shown).To determine the contribution of dimorphism to the survival of S. cerevisiae in vivo, flo11
, flo8
, tec1
, and flo8
tec1
mutants were competed against wild-type strains in vivo. As shown in Table 3, the flo11
mutant strains were phenotypically equivalent to wild type while the flo8
and tec1
mutant strains were slightly deficient in survival. The flo8
and tec1
mutant strains were somewhat more fit in vivo than the flo8
tec1
mutant strain, suggesting a possible additive phenotypic effect of loss of both Flo8p and Tec1p.
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
Many conserved signal transduction and metabolic pathways are critical for fungal pathogenicity (![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Auxotrophy and survival in vivo:
As a first test of the S. cerevisiae model system, auxotrophs were examined for their ability to survive in the mouse model system. In addition to testing the generality of fungal survival factors, auxotrophic mutants allow several key aspects of fungal biology to be assessed in vivo. For example, the phenotype of an auxotroph is a function of (i) the concentration of the required nutrient combined with the uptake capacity for that nutrient in vivo, (ii) the phenotypic effect of limitation for the required nutrient in the in vivo environment, and, possibly, (iii) the specific block in the pathway.
The survival defect of C. albicans and C. neoformans purine and pyrimidine auxotrophs (![]()
![]()
![]()
and ade4
mutants suggested that, at least for purine auxotrophy, the specific block in the pathway was not relevant to survival and that purine limitation, whether due to a low concentration of purines or low purine transport capacity in vivo, must severely affect survival in a mammalian host.
The ade2
and ade4
mutants allowed an interesting test of the hypothesis that in vitro phenotypes can predict in vivo phenotypes. S. cerevisiae ade4
mutants are deficient in the first step in purine biosynthesis. ade2 mutants, which are blocked in a late step in the purine biosynthetic pathway (![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
In vitro competitions (this work), performed at 37° to mimic body temperature but under otherwise highly favorable environmental conditions (YEPD has a high concentration of glucose and acidic pH and is nutrient replete), showed that while ade4
mutants were slightly deficient in vitro, ade2
mutants were severely deficient in vitro. Given this in vitro differential between ade2
and ade4
mutants, one might have predicted that ade4
mutants would have a considerably less severe defect in vivo than ade2
mutants. In fact, at least at the timepoints tested, ade2
and ade4
mutants were phenotypically indistinguishable in vivo. These results demonstrate that phenotypes are environment specific and that extrapolation from the in vitro environment to the in vivo environment can be misleading and problematic.
Three different amino acid auxotrophs were examined for their ability to survive in vivo: his3
, leu2
, and trp1
. Histidine, leucine, and tryptophan are all present at concentrations in mouse serum (![]()
![]()
and trp1
mutants were only slightly deficient in their ability to survive. Similarly, a C. albicans his1 mutant has been shown to be unaffected in its virulence (![]()
and ura3
mutants, speaks to the generality of fungal survival factors. In contrast, in spite of a substantial concentration of leucine in mouse serum (22 µg/ml; ![]()
mutants were severely depleted in vivo. These results suggested that (i) specific amino acids may exist at lower concentrations in tissue(s) compared with serum and/or (ii) significant differences may exist in the transport capacity for different amino acids in vivo. These in vivo competition results were exactly the opposite of what would be predicted on the basis of in vitro competition experiments, where leu2 mutants have no discernible growth defect (![]()
![]()
![]()
The survival defect of S. cerevisiae leu2 mutants may be different from that of a C. albicans leu2 mutant, which was approximately as virulent as the prototrophic parent (![]()
The characterization of auxotrophs for their ability to survive in the in vivo environment addresses an important issue, namely, the ecology of infection. In addition, the in vivo phenotypes of mutants can identify and evaluate potential antifungal drug targets; from this work and other analysis, the histidine and tryptophan pathways would not be good antifungal targets while the purine, pyrimidine, and, possibly, leucine pathways would be good antifungal drug targets. Finally, the identification of auxotrophs with survival defects allows these genes to be used as reporters for in vivo promoter activity for future in vivo expression technology analysis (![]()
![]()
Drug resistance and fitness in vivo:
Antimicrobial drug resistance is a serious clinical problem for both bacteria (![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Determining the effects on fitness of drug-resistance mutations requires isogenic strains and knowing the exact nature of the resistance mutations. These requirements are difficult to achieve in most pathogenic fungi but are relatively straightforward in S. cerevisiae. Therefore, as a test of the system, fcy1
mutants were tested for their ability to survive. Cytosine deaminase, which is encoded by FCY1, is part of the pyrimidine salvage pathway that converts cytosine to uracil. Cytosine deaminase is also required for the activity of the antifungal drug 5-fluorocytosine which, in order to be toxic, must be converted to 5-fluorouracil. Given the importance of de novo biosynthesis of pyrimidines for survival, the pyrimidine salvage pathway might also be important for fungal survival, which would be consistent with the frequent deleterious effects of drug-resistance mutations. However, the fcy1
mutants were not deleterious and, indeed, appeared to be slightly advantageous in vivo; this result is consistent with the frequent clinical occurrence of 5-fluorocytosine resistance in pathogenic yeasts (![]()
![]()
![]()
The glyoxylate cycle and survival in vivo:
The role of the glyoxylate cycle in vivo was of particular interest because of its requirement for utilization of fatty acids, such as oleate (![]()
![]()
/icl1
mutant showed a substantial reduction in virulence (![]()
mutants were slightly deficient in vivo suggests that the glyoxylate cycle and, presumably, fatty acid utilization make a minor contribution to S. cerevisiae fitness in vivo.
Respiration, the mitochondrial genome, and survival in vivo:
There are three possible explanations for the critical importance of respiration for survival in the host. First, and most obvious, there is the role of respiration in energy metabolism. Given a concentration of glucose in mouse serum of
0.07% (![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
The severe survival defect of
0 strains, relative to cox15 strains, suggested that the mitochondrial genome makes respiration-independent contributions to survival. It is clear that, in addition to respiration, a variety of functions take place within the mitochondrion, such as steps in amino acid, fatty acid, and heme biosynthesis (![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
0 strains (![]()
The severe survival defect of
0 strains was particularly interesting because many S. cerevisiae strains grown at high temperatures (
37°) show an elevated loss of the mitochondrial genome and become
0 (![]()
![]()
0 strains, mitochondrial genome stability at the high temperatures experienced in vivo must be an important survival factor that may, in turn, be intrinsically related to the ability of clinically derived S. cerevisiae strains to grow at supra-optimal temperatures, as determined in vitro (![]()
![]()
In the context of mitochondrial genome stability, 5-fluorocytosine damages the S. cerevisiae mitochondrial genome and is a potent petite-inducing (
0/
-) agent (![]()
![]()
Dimorphism and survival in vivo:
Dimorphism is thought to be an important virulence factor for most of the pathogenic fungi infecting humans; it is clear that C. albicans mutants with defects in dimorphism are either avirulent or have attenuated virulence (![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
The reversible dimorphic switch between yeast and pseudohyphal forms has been extensively characterized in S. cerevisiae (reviewed in ![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
, flo8
, tec1
, and flo8
tec1
mutants were constructed. Compared to wild type, the tec1
mutants were only slightly deficient in their ability to form pseudohyphae. However, the flo11
, flo8
, and flo8
tec1
mutants formed few, if any, pseudohyphae in vitro.
The flo8
and tec1
mutant strains were slightly deficient relative to wild type in vivo. Since the flo8
tec1
mutant strain was less fit than either of the single mutant strains, this result would suggest that the absence of both Flo8p and Tec1p has an additive effect on phenotype. Interestingly, the flo11
mutant strains were phenotypically indistinguishable from wild type in in vivo competitions. Therefore, the slight phenotypes of the flo8
, tec1
, and flo8
tec1
mutants cannot be due to lack of transcription of FLO11 and must instead be due to effects on other genes. In addition, given the complete absence of Flo11p in the flo11
strains, the in vivo phenotype of flo11
strains would argue that either production of Flo11p confers no selective advantage in vivo or that FLO11 is not expressed in vivo.
Of 30 S. cerevisiae clinical isolates, nonclinical strains, and laboratory strains tested for survival in vivo, the S288c genetic background, which is deficient in pseudohyphal formation due to a naturally occurring flo8 mutation (![]()
![]()
mutants in the YJM145 background (this work) suggests that the flo8 mutation in the S288c background makes only a minor, quantitative contribution to the inability of the S288c background to survive in vivo. We will have to look beyond FLO8, and possibly beyond dimorphism altogether, to find the genetic basis for the large in vivo phenotypic differences between the YJM145 and S288c genetic backgrounds.
Given the importance of dimorphism for C. albicans pathogenicity, why do the S. cerevisiae flo11
, flo8
, tec1
, and flo8
tec1
dimorphism-deficient mutants have little or no phenotype in vivo? One answer to this question is that some virulence or survival factors may be species specific. As an example of a species-specific virulence trait, capsule formation, which is critical for the virulence of C. neoformans, is not observed in other pathogenic fungi infecting humans (![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Of all the pathogenic fungi, S. cerevisiae is most closely related to C. glabrata (![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
| CONCLUSION |
|---|
Given the evolutionary conservation of basic signal transduction and metabolic pathways in fungi and the results described here, in most cases, what is true for S. cerevisiae will also be true for the more commonly observed pathogenic fungi. However, even when examining conserved functions and pathways, there will be some cases where S. cerevisiae mutants and mutants in another species have different in vivo phenotypes. Such cases may be directly relevant to the differences in pathogenesis between S. cerevisiae, an emerging opportunistic pathogen, and closely related and more virulent species, such as C. albicans. Interspecific differences in mutant phenotypes may also be relevant to the evolution of fungal pathogenesis. It is now possible to use S. cerevisiae, the most extensively studied eukaryotic microorganism, to directly examine conserved pathways for their role in survival in vivo, which will improve our understanding of fungal pathogenesis.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
The authors thank J. Harrell for some strain construction and P. Hartzog and B. Nicholson for some PCR primer design. The authors also thank G. Cox, J. Heitman, T. Mitchell, and J. Perfect for reading the manuscript and J. Perfect for communication of unpublished results concerning the in vivo expression of the C. neoformans ICL1 gene. A. Goldstein was supported by National Institutes of Health (NIH) training grants T32-CA09111 and T32-AI07392. This work was also supported by NIH grants PO1-AI44975 and RO1-GM58476 and funds from Duke University Medical Center.
Manuscript received May 21, 2001; Accepted for publication July 19, 2001.
| LITERATURE CITED |
|---|