Telomere Structure Regulates the Heritability of Repressed Subtelomeric Chromatin in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Corresponding author: Arthur J. Lustig, Department of Biochemistry SL43, Tulane University Medical Ctr., 1430 Tulane Ave., New Orleans, LA 70112., alustig{at}mailhost.tcs.tulane.edu (E-mail)

Communicating editor: F. WINSTON

	ABSTRACT

TOP ABSTRACT MATERIALS AND METHODS RESULTS DISCUSSION LITERATURE CITED

Telomeres, the protein-DNA structures present at the termini of linear chromosomes, are capable of conferring a reversible repression of Pol II- and Pol III-transcribed genes positioned in adjacent subtelomeric regions. This phenomenon, termed telomeric silencing, is likely to be the consequence of a more global telomere position effect at the level of chromatin structure. To understand the role of telomere structure in this position effect, we have developed an assay to distinguish between the heritability of transcriptionally repressed and derepressed states in yeast. We have previously demonstrated that an elongated telomeric tract leads to hyperrepression of telomere-adjacent genes. We show here that the predominant effect of elongated telomeres is to increase the inheritance of the repressed state in cis. Interestingly, the presence of elongated telomeres overcomes the partial requirement of yCAF-1 in silencing. We propose that the formation of a specific telomeric structure is necessary for the heritability of repressed subtelomeric chromatin.

THE mechanism by which cells "remember" their transcriptional state from one generation to the next involves epigenetic effects in development, variegation, and heterochromatin formation. Telomeric silencing specifically refers to the epigenetic and metastable transcriptionally repressed state that is conferred onto genes inserted adjacent to telomeric chromatin in both yeast and other organisms (GOTTSCHLING et al. 1990 ; LUSTIG 1998 ). This effect is similar to position-effect variegation (PEV) and heterochromatin formation observed in Drosophila and in higher eukaryotes (HENIKOFF 1996 ).

The budding yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae has served as an excellent model for investigating both the effect of telomeres on the structure of subtelomeric sequences and the formation of heterochromatic domains. Telomeric silencing is clearly associated with specific changes in subtelomeric chromatin structure (GOTTSCHLING 1992 ; WRIGHT et al. 1992 ; RENAULD et al. 1993 ; HECHT et al. 1995 , HECHT et al. 1996 ; STRAHL-BOLSINGER et al. 1997 ). First, specific subclasses of acetylated subtelomeric histones (BRAUNSTEIN et al. 1993 ) are present in subtelomeric regions. Second, subtelomeric chromatin is compacted into nuclease-resistant domains (GOTTSCHLING 1992 ; WRIGHT et al. 1992 ; RENAULD et al. 1993 ). Finally, novel "fold-back" structures appear to form between the telomeric and subtelomeric domains (HECHT et al. 1996 ; GRUNSTEIN 1997 ; STRAHL-BOLSINGER et al. 1997 ). These heterochromatin-like regions are found at both natural and modified termini, although the regulation of natural telomeric silencing has a higher level of complexity (VEGA-PALAS et al. 1997 ; FOUREL et al. 1999 ; PRYDE and LOUIS 1999 ).

Five fundamental processes have been proposed to operate both in silencing of the cryptic HM mating-type loci and in telomeric silencing (PILLUS and RINE 1989 ; LOO and RINE 1995 ; LUSTIG 1998 ). Within the context of a telomere, these include (1) recruitment of silencing factors to specific DNA binding sites (termed silencers; COCKELL et al. 1998 ), (2) a molecular "communication" between the telomeric and subtelomeric sequences that initiates subtelomeric silencing (PARK et al. 1998 ), (3) the maintenance of the repressed state during the cell cycle, and (4) the heritability of the repressed state. A fifth parameter is the distance that repressed states are promulgated unidirectionally from the telomeric initiation sites into distal subtelomeric regions (termed propagation in this study; RENAULD et al. 1993 ).

Telomeric silencing is related to silencing of HML and HMR, which share proteins essential for silencing. The yeast duplex telomere-binding protein repressor/activator protein 1 (Rap1p) recruits the silent information regulators Sir3p and Sir4p to the telomere via the Rap1p C-terminal domain (MORETTI et al. 1994 ; COCKELL et al. 1995 ; LIU and LUSTIG 1996 ). Indeed, the protein encoded by the rap1-17 mutation, Rap1-17p, lacks the C-terminal 165 amino acids that are obligatory for silencing and has defects in telomere size control (KYRION et al. 1992 , KYRION et al. 1993 ). In wild-type cells, the repressed state spreads unidirectionally through nucleosomal chromatin. Silencing is likely to be maintained in part through associations among the Sir2, Sir3, and Sir4 proteins, and between the N termini of histones H3 and H4 and both Sir3p and Sir4p (reviewed in COCKELL et al. 1998 ; LUSTIG 1998 ).

Yeast chromatin assembly factor-1 (yCAF-1) has also been implicated in silencing (ENOMOTO et al. 1997 ; KAUFMAN et al. 1997 ; MONSON et al. 1997 ). yCAF-1 is composed of three subunits, Cac1p, Cac2p, and Cac3p (KAUFMAN et al. 1997 ), each of which is necessary for full telomeric silencing and for heritability of the repressed state. yCAF-1 also plays a role in a multiplicity of additional processes, including ribosomal DNA silencing (SMITH et al. 1999 ), repair of DNA damage (GAME and KAUFMAN 1999 ), and transposition (QIAN et al. 1998 ; HUANG et al. 1999 ). Both hCAF-1 and yCAF-1 have been characterized biochemically. Human CAF-1 acts specifically during DNA replication (KAUFMAN et al. 1995 ), possibly depositing a subset of acetylated histones H3 and H4 or forming a structure that is more accessible to specific acetylation. yCAF-1 has a similar subunit structure and shares homology with hCAF-1 (KAUFMAN et al. 1997 ). Biochemically, yCAF-1 enzyme activity is also capable of histone deposition activity and is likely to be involved in chromatin formation. Interestingly, recent data indicate that proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA), the ß-clamp component of the DNA polymerase complex, associates with CAF-1 in vitro (KRUDE 1999 ; SHIBAHARA and STILLMAN 1999 ). Conceivably, PCNA targets yCAF-1 to specific chromosomal sites that require a unique function of yCAF-1.

Far less is known about heritability. Heritability refers to the ability of either repressed or derepressed transcriptional states to give rise to an identical transcriptional state in subsequent progeny. Several studies have begun to investigate this phenomenon. At the silent HM loci, several topological and single-cell pedigree analyses have demonstrated that silencers act in both the formation and heritability, but not maintenance, of the repressed state (HOLMES and BROACH 1996 ; BI and BROACH 1997 ; ANSARI and GARTENBERG 1999 ). These studies also strongly suggest that repressed chromatin is erased after DNA replication in the absence of silencers.

The HM silencer and putative internal silencers compete with the telomere for limiting components (LUSTIG et al. 1996 ; MAILLET et al. 1996 ; GOTTA et al. 1997 ; SMITH et al. 1999 ). Earlier studies in our laboratory indicated that longer telomeres introduced into wild-type cells display higher levels of silencing (KYRION et al. 1993 ). Interestingly, such longer telomeres impair silencing at HMR, most likely through sequestration of Sir4p at the telomere (BUCK and SHORE 1995 ).

Indeed, this competition is probably a manifestation of a larger role for an exchange of Sir factors to other sites in the genome. In particular, aging cells exhibit relocalization of Sir2p, Sir3p, and Sir4p to the nucleolus (AUSTRIACO and GUARENTE 1997 ; KENNEDY et al. 1997 ; SINCLAIR et al. 1997 ), possibly as a prelude to apoptotic-like fragmentation of the nucleolus (SINCLAIR et al. 1997 ). In addition, the production of yeast double-strand breaks relocalizes both the yKu heterodimer and Sir3p to strand breaks (MARTIN et al. 1999 ; MILLS et al. 1999 ). It is unclear at present whether Sir3p acts at double-strand breaks in heterochromatin formation or in a protective role.

We have previously demonstrated that when elongated telomeres are introduced into wild-type strains, repression levels exceed wild-type values (KYRION et al. 1993 ; LI and LUSTIG 1996 ). In this investigation, we examine the effect of telomere length on "cellular memory" of repressed and derepressed states. To this end, we developed a novel assay to discriminate between the stability of these transcriptional states. We find that the increased length of a telomeric tract confers higher levels of heritability of repressed subtelomeric chromatin in a process unaffected by loss of yCAF-1. In addition, increased heritability of the repressed state acts in cis and hence is likely to be mediated by an intramolecular process. Our data also suggest the presence of redundant pathways, governed by both telomere structure and yCAF-1, that may be necessary for molecular memory.

	MATERIALS AND METHODS

TOP ABSTRACT MATERIALS AND METHODS RESULTS DISCUSSION LITERATURE CITED

Plasmids:
Tethering plasmids pBTM and pBTM-SIR3 were constructed as described (LUSTIG et al. 1996 ). Bacterial transformations were carried out by standard techniques.

Yeast strains and methods:
The genotypes of the strains used in this study, the percentage of total telomeres that are elongated, and the presence (or absence) of wild-type or elongated VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomeres are shown in Table 1. CZY1/RAP1 and CZY4/RAP1 were each transformed with pBTM (encoding LexA) or pBTM-SIR3 (encoding LexA-Sir3) as described (LUSTIG et al. 1996 ). MBH9 was derived from CLY1/rap1-17 (LIU and LUSTIG 1996 ) and contained a 3.6-kb telomeric tract with an artificially introduced HaeIII site 750 bp from the subtelomeric/telomeric junction (M. BUCHOLC and A. J. LUSTIG, unpublished data). Transformations were carried out by the LiOAc method. Standard fluctuation assays were carried out as previously described, using 7–10 colonies per assay (LIU et al. 1994 ). Medians of propagation assays were determined by measuring the red FOA^r colonies/total red colonies in each member of the distribution.

Assessment of marked and global telomere length:
All strains containing elongated telomeres were derived from an initial cross of wild-type and rap1-17 strains. After sporulation, wild-type spore colonies containing the elongated telomeres were used for subsequent studies. The size of the VIIL-marked telomeres was determined by Southern analysis. The global elongated telomere size ranges from ~400 bp to 4 kb in length (KYRION et al. 1992 ). The approximate percentage of elongated telomeres was based on statistical probability and random assortment (i.e., first cross, 50% elongated; second cross, 25% telomeres, etc.).

Determination of interactions among homologous telomeres:
To distinguish individually among the silencing of two homologs, diploids were generated containing one homolog with either a wild-type or elongated marked VIIL:: ura3/ADE2-marked telomere. The other homolog contained an elongated VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomere. Cells were first grown on FOA-limiting adenine media and screened for FOA^r white colonies. Given the unidirectionality of silencing, FOA^r cells would be indicative of repression at the telomeric ADE2 gene. On the other homolog, the ADE2 gene must be derepressed to give rise to FOA^r white colonies. These telomeres, therefore, must define the derepressed/repressed state. We then conducted fluctuation analysis on FOA-containing media for 20 generations to determine the degree of switching from derepressed/repressed to repressed/repressed states. The degree of switching is defined in this study as the number of repressed cells/total cells and is a semiquantitative indication of the rate of switching. This is required because the number of switched cells can be influenced by an increase in both the rate of switching and the stability of the switched state. This assay measures switching only at the VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomere.

To determine the degree of switching from derepressed to repressed states in diploids containing one elongated VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomere, fluctuation analysis was performed after the identification of white colonies. Cells were grown for 20 generations on limiting adenine media. The low level of switching from the derepressed state to the repressed state (Figure 2) precludes multiple switches. Therefore, in this case, the degree of switching is equal to the frequency of red-centered colonies within the population. In the case of AJL 419 and AJL 421, the percentage of FOA^r cells was determined by a standard fluctuation analysis (Figure 4).

View larger version (31K): In this window In a new window Download PPT slide   Figure 1. Determining the heritability of the repressed and derepressed state at telomeres. (Top) A diagram of the VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomere used in these studies. The black boxes (from left to right) are the URA3 and ADE2 genes, respectively. The telomeric tract is depicted as a thick black line on the right. (Bottom) A pictorial representation of the assay (described in the text) to determine the heritability of repressed (A) and derepressed (B) states. Black and white indicate repressed (black) and derepressed (white) sectors or colonies, respectively.

View larger version (432K): In this window In a new window Download PPT slide   Figure 2. The relationship of telomere length to the heritability of repressed and derepressed states. (Top left) Red sectors from the periphery of white colonies were picked from AJL 275-2a:: UA, carrying wild-type length telomeres. Cells were treated as described in Figure 1A, and the sectoring pattern (shown here) was analyzed. (Top right) Red sectors from the periphery of white colonies were picked from BL22-2b, carrying an elongated telomere. Cells were treated as in Figure 1A, and the plates were analyzed. (Bottom left) White sectors from the periphery of red colonies were picked from AJL275-2a:: UA, carrying wild-type length telomeres. Cells were treated as in Figure 1B and the plates were subsequently analyzed. (Bottom right) White sectors from the periphery of red colonies were picked from BL22-2b, carrying an elongated VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomere. Cells were treated as in Figure 1B and the plates were analyzed. In all experiments, elongated telomere size was confirmed by Southern analysis. The approximate switch rates from repressed to derepressed states are listed on the top, while the switch rates between derepressed and repressed states are shown on the bottom.

View larger version (140K): In this window In a new window Download PPT slide   Figure 3. Hyperrepression does not ensure enhanced heritability. (Top) Depiction of tethered silencing system. Tethering of the LexA protein does not affect silencing, while tethering by LexA-Sir3p leads to hyperrepression of silencing in cis. The degree of ADE2 silencing is indicated by the thickness of the arrow. The extent of propagation is shown by the hatched bar. Other symbols are shown on the figure. Some of the proteins normally involved in wild-type telomeric silencing are also shown. (Bottom) White sectors from red or pink colonies of the RAP1 strain CZY4/RAP1, containing wild-type length telomeres, were transformed with pBTM-SIR3 (encoding LexA-Sir3) and treated as described in Figure 1B. The sectoring patterns were analyzed as described in the text.

View larger version (17K): In this window In a new window Download PPT slide   Figure 4. Telomere elongation-mediated hyperrepression acts in cis. (A) Relationship between hyperrepression and overall length of the telomeric tract. Diploid strains containing a single wild-type length VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomere and either 0 (AJL 425; line 1) or 25% (AJL 427 and AJL 428; line 2) elongated telomeres were constructed as indicated (Table 1). BL4-3 (line 3) contained 25% elongated telomeres with an elongated VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomere. The strain BL4-2 (line 4) is isogenic to BL4-3 except for the deletion of VIIL:: URA3/ADE2 to wild-type tract size. The average median is presented together with the sample sizes and the total range of values in the distribution, in parentheses. The thin line represents a potential nonhomologous chromosome that might pair and influence the silencing of the wild-type length VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomere. With the exception of BL4-3, which contained a marked telomere of 650–1100 bp, the remaining VIIL:: URA3/ADE2 telomeres were wild type in length (300 bp). %ET refers to the expected percentage of elongated telomeres. (B) Interactions among telomeres of homologous chromosomes. The degree of switching from the derepressed state to the repressed state was assayed. BL4-3 (line 1), which was used as a hyperrepression control, contains telomeres of 1.1 kb. The second strain, AJL 459 (line 2), contains two elongated VIIL telomeres, one of which contains a VIIL:: ura3/ADE2-marked telomere (homolog 2) and the other a VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomere (homolog 1). AJL 459 telomeres consisted of two elongated forms: 1.3 and 1.6 kb. In the experiments assayed, each of the seven AJL 459 colonies from the fluctuation assay contained two telomeres between 1.1 and 1.4 kb. The third strain, YP8 (line 3), is identical to AJL459 except that the VIIL:: ura3/ADE2 (homolog 2) telomere is wild type in length, while the lengths of the marked elongated telomeres in two experiments were 1.1 and 1.5 kb, respectively. In the fluctuation assays, each of the samples contained telomeres from 0.9 to 0.95 and 1.25 to 1.5 kb, respectively. In both A and B, the 5-FOAr values are presented as percentages. The asterisks refer to mutations within the URA3 gene. White boxes represent mutant ura3 genes, while black boxes refer to the wild-type gene. The fourth strain, AJL 421 (line 4), contains two VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomeres, one of wild-type length and a second elongated telomere of >700 bp. The fifth strain, AJL419 (line 5), contains two elongated marked telomeres with telomere sizes of >700 bp. In both cases, silencing was measured by standard fluctuation analysis and the frequency of FOAr cells was determined (i.e., FOAr/total cells). The data were converted into a percentage value.

	RESULTS

TOP ABSTRACT MATERIALS AND METHODS RESULTS DISCUSSION LITERATURE CITED

An assay for the heritability of transcriptional states at telomeres:
In this study we examine three parameters to investigate the process of "cellular memory." At a theoretical level, heritability refers to the ability of a given transcriptional state to be continuously transmitted to subsequent progeny. Operationally, we define the heritability of the repressed state as the degree of sectoring of cells initially repressed for transcription at the telomeric ADE2 gene to cells derepressed for ADE2 expression. An analogous operational definition holds for the heritability of derepressed cells. The degree of switching can be estimated by semiquantitative methods based on the frequency of conversion from one transcriptional state to the other. Finally, propagation refers to the extent to which silencing can spread from the telomere to distal chromatin regions. This is defined here as the percentage of ADE2-repressed cells that are repressed at the distal URA3 gene (Figure 1). We have developed a model system to distinguish between the heritability of repressed and derepressed transcriptional states after selection for each state for a specified number of generations (Figure 1). The heritability assays use a yeast strain with a marked VIIL:: URA3/ADE2 telomere, with URA3 in the centromere-distal position (Figure 1, top). In the strain background used in these studies, the ADE2 gene is repressed only poorly (LI and LUSTIG 1996 ), providing the greatest sensitivity for conditions that measure repression (Figure 1).

To measure the stability of the repressed state, newly arisen red (repressed) sectors, derived from the periphery of white colonies, were grown on limiting adenine media containing 5-fluoro-orotic acid (5-FOA) for a specified number of generations (Figure 1A). 5-FOA allows the growth of Ura3^-, but not Ura3⁺, cells. Because the URA3 gene is telomere-distal to the ADE2 gene and silencing spreads unidirectionally, all Ura^- cells must be Ade^- (RENAULD et al. 1993 ; HECHT et al. 1996 ). As a consequence, all 5-FOA^r cells produce red colonies (data not shown). After 20 generations, cells are dispersed onto nonselective plates and the sectoring patterns are evaluated.

In the converse experiment, we picked newly arisen derepressed Ade⁺ (white) sectors from the extreme periphery of repressed Ade^- (red) colonies and cultured the cells on adenine omission media [conditions that induce the ADE2 gene (GEDVILAITE and SANAUSKAS 1994)] for 20 generations (Figure 1B). We dispersed cells onto nonselective plates and evaluated the colony sectoring patterns. Southern analysis was used to confirm the lengths of telomeres in each experiment.

Elongated telomeres increase the heritability of the repressed state:
We have previously demonstrated that elongated telomeres (produced in rap1-17 mutant cells) confer a hyperrepressed state onto adjacent Pol II-transcribed genes (e.g., VIIL:: URA3/ADE2) after reintroduction into a wild-type RAP1 background (KYRION et al. 1992 ; LI and LUSTIG 1996 ; Figure 1). We wished to explore whether tract-length-dependent hyperrepression, in otherwise wild-type cells, is associated with changes in the heritability of the repressed or derepressed states. We therefore conducted the stability assays using the RAP1 cells containing a VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomere with either 300 bp wild type or elongated telomeric tract sizes of >700 bp (Figure 2).

Strikingly, the presence of an elongated VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomere in wild-type cells has a dramatic effect on the stability of the repressed state. After growth on 5-FOA-containing media, cells with the marked elongated telomere remain in the repressed state after an additional round of solid subculturing (i.e., 20 generations; Figure 2, top right). Indeed, the majority of cells (63%) at the periphery of repressed colonies remained in that state after an additional 20 generations of growth. In contrast, isogenic cells containing a marked telomere of wild-type size gave rise to a high level of sectoring, indicating increased reversion to the derepressed state (Figure 2, top left).

To assay the heritability of the derepressed transcription state at the telomeric ADE2 gene, cells were selected for ADE2 by growth on adenine omission media and plated onto low adenine media. Cells containing the elongated VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomeres maintain the derepressed state after selection through 20 generations of colony growth. However, a slightly greater number of derepressed sectors appeared to be present at the periphery than in cells with wild-type telomeres (Figure 2, bottom).

The qualitative differences can be estimated semiquantitatively if two assumptions are fulfilled. First, the telomere length must be present at elongated sizes throughout colony growth. Rapid deletion events can shorten telomeres to wild-type length in <20 generations (LI and LUSTIG 1996 ). Such a process would distort any estimates that we may derive. Second, switches in state must form primarily at the periphery of colonies so that the semiquantitative methods reflect the observed switching. Both parameters are fulfilled based on Southern analysis and visual inspection of the colonies.

We first estimated the degree of switching from repressed to derepressed state. After growth on 5-FOA media (Figure 1), cells from 10 independent colonies were grown on nonselective media and assayed for the percentage of derepressed colonies in strains containing short (AJL275-2a::UA) or elongated (BL22-2b) telomeres. We found that strains carrying the elongated telomere contained an approximately fourfold decrease in repressed cells over cells containing wild-type telomeres, with switching values of 22 vs. 82%, respectively [ Figure 2, top left (AJL275-2a::UA) and top right (BL22-2b)].

To assay the degree of switching from derepressed to repressed states, we followed an analogous approach with cells grown on adenine omission media (Figure 2, bottom). We found that strains carrying the elongated telomere contained a threefold increase in repressed cells over cells containing wild-type telomeres, with switching values of 16 vs. 5%, respectively (Figure 2, bottom left and bottom right). Hence, the degree of switching from derepressed to repressed states is also increased in strains by the elongated telomeres. However, the apparent increase in switching to the derepressed state (Figure 2) may also be a reflection of increased heritability of the repressed state once formed.

Elongated telomeres increase the propagation of the repressed state:
We were interested in examining the relationship between heritability and propagation. The distance that the repressed state is spread from telomeric sequences through subtelomeric chromatin (i.e., propagation) is also clearly increased by telomere length. In cells containing wild-type-length telomeres, 2.5% of red (Ade^-) colonies were Ura^-. In contrast, 39% of red colonies that contain elongated telomeres formed 5-FOA^r colonies (see Figure 5). Hence, telomere elongation appears to enhance the heritability and propagation of the repressed state, and consequently to decrease switching to the derepressed state relative to wild-type-length telomeres. These data suggest a mechanistic relationship between heritability and propagation.

View larger version (22K): In this window In a new window Download PPT slide   Figure 5. Telomere elongation overcomes the requirement for yCAF-1 in the propagation of silencing. Wild-type, cac1, and cac2 strains containing a VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomere with or without elongated telomeres were derived from sporulation of the diploids YP1, YP2, YP3, and YP4. The appropriate spore colonies were assayed for the fraction of red and FOAr colonies in wild-type, cac1, and cac2 backgrounds. The number of fluctuation analyses carried out is shown in parentheses. We note that all elongated telomeres in this experiment ranged from 1.9 to 2.6 kb. In each case, the average of the medians of different experiments is shown. In the diagram of the elongated and wild-type-length marked telomere, black boxes indicate the URA3 and ADE2 genes, gray ovals represent Rap1p, and Sir3p is denoted by a rectangular gray box.

The relationship between heritability and telomere length:
Two models can explain the results described above. First, a specific relationship may exist between telomere length and heritability. Alternatively, any state that results in hyperrepression may lead to an increase in heritability of the telomeric ADE2 and URA3 genes. To test the latter possibility, we performed the heritability assays under a second distinct hyperrepressed state formed by tethering of LexA-Sir3p at the telomeric/subtelomeric junction in wild-type RAP1 strains (Figure 3, top). Under these conditions, despite the wild-type telomere length, extremely high levels of Sir-dependent repression are attained at the telomeric ADE2 gene (LUSTIG et al. 1996 ).

Assays for the heritability of the derepressed state were performed using CZY4/RAP1, which includes three LexA sites just distal to the telomeric tract (Figure 3, top), transformed by pBTM-SIR3 (encoding LexA-Sir3). Fluctuation analysis following expression of LexA-Sir3p yielded values of 98% repressed colonies, while expression of LexA displayed values of 11%. Remarkably, sectoring patterns of this strain display an unusual red (pink)/white ring-like colony phenotype (Figure 3, bottom). No effects on wild-type levels were observed in the absence of a LexA binding site or after transformation with LexA alone (data not shown). This result contrasts with the profound increase in the stability of the repressed state found in elongated telomere-mediated hyperrepression. These data from tethered strains containing wild-type-length telomeres in wild-type RAP1 strains suggest the presence of rapid switches between repressed (red), partially repressed (pink), and derepressed (white) states during growth of the colony. These data also suggest that there may be multiple pathways to the hyperrepressed state.

We note that tethered LexA-Sir3p also displayed a marked decrease in propagation (1 x 10^-4 FOA^r) compared to propagation induced by elongated telomeres (0.39 FOA^r, Figure 5). These data suggest a 3800-fold drop in propagation between tethering-induced and telomere-elongation-induced hyperrepression. These data once again link heritability to propagation.

Elongation-mediated hyperrepression is telomere-autonomous:
The enhancement of silencing due to elongated telomeres might act solely intramolecularly (in cis) or through increased interactions with other telomeres or telomeric factors (in trans). To test this, we compared the effect of differing amounts of elongated telomeres on repression of a wild-type-length VIIL:: URA3/ADE2 telomere in diploid cells (see Figure 4). Silencing was measured in this case by the expression of the URA3 gene distal to the ADE2 gene. Wild-type cells containing 25% elongated telomeres were compared to strains carrying only wild-type-length VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomeres (Figure 4A, lines 1 and 2). Repression was assayed by the frequency of 5-FOA^r (Ura^-) colonies.

Our results indicated that the presence of the subpopulation of elongated telomeres did not increase the level of telomeric silencing at VIIL:: URA3/ADE2. Another interpretation of these data is that 25% of elongated telomeres may not be sufficient to confer hyperrepression. To test this, we conducted the converse experiment in which 25% elongated telomeres including an elongated VIIL:: URA3/ADE2 (BL4-3; Figure 4A, line 3) were present. Under these conditions, hyperrepression in diploid strains was as high as observed in the haploid strains containing 50% elongated telomeres (34%; Figure 5), suggesting that the percentage of elongated telomeres between 25 and 50% does not alter silencing.

Furthermore, cells that differed from BL4-3 in only a deletion of the elongated VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomere to wild-type size, eliminated hyperrepression (BL 4-2; Figure 4A, line 4). Because the only difference between the two strains is the presence of the elongated VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomere, these data suggest that the degree of telomeric silencing is not the consequence of general telomere elongation nor the interaction among the telomeres of nonhomologous chromosomes. These data support the notion that an elongated telomere affects hyperrepression in cis.

Consistent with this hypothesis, a haploid strain containing an elongated VIIL:: ura3/ADE2 telomere cannot confer hyperrepression on the short URA3-marked telomere on the right side of chromosome V (VR:: URA3; LI 1998 ).

Can the two telomeres of homologs interact to facilitate silencing? To test this, we analyzed the degree of switching of a derepressed homolog containing a marked elongated telomere as a function of the structure of the homologous telomere in diploid cells (see MATERIALS AND METHODS).

For YP8 (containing one elongated VIIL:: URA3/ADE2 telomere and a second wild-type-length VIIL:: ura3/ADE2-marked telomere; Figure 4B, line 3) and AJL 459 (containing two elongated telomeres, one with a VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomere and the second with a VIIL:: ura3/ADE2-marked telomere; Figure 4B, line 2), FOA^r white colonies were initially identified. For both strains, given the unidirectionality of silencing, white FOA^r cells would be indicative of repression at the ADE2 gene at VIIL in homolog 1 and derepression in homolog 2 (Figure 4B, lines 2 and 3). The degree of switching between the derepressed/repressed and repressed/repressed states was determined by measuring the percentage of white FOA^r cells that switch to FOA^r red cells after 20 generations of growth on nonselective media. This assay therefore measures switching only at the VIIL:: ura3/ADE2-marked telomere.

BL4-3 contains one VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomere, with a 25% chance that a second unmarked telomere is elongated. Recently derived white colonies were picked and standard fluctuation analysis was performed after 20 generations of growth. The degree of switching between the derepressed and repressed states was determined by measuring the percentage of derepressed (white) cells that switch to the repressed (red) state after 20 generations of growth on nonselective media (see Figure 4B, line 1; MATERIALS AND METHODS).

Our results indicate that BL4-3 and AJL459 have similar high levels of switching (Figure 4B, lines 1 and 2). However, when a short homolog is paired with an elongated telomere (YP8), red FOA^r cells are produced at wild-type values 50-fold lower than AJL459 (Figure 4B, line 3). Hence, the degree of switching is not substantially influenced by the size of its homolog, which further suggests an in cis effect.

Fluctuation analysis of a diploid strain containing elongated and wild-type-length VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomeres (AJL421; Figure 4B, line 4) demonstrated near-wild-type levels of silencing. Hence, the elongated telomere did not improve the low efficiency of silencing conferred by the wild-type-length telomere. Strains containing two elongated VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomeres (AJL419; Figure 4B, line 5), while yielding values 500-fold higher than AJL 421, did not display a positive effect on silencing relative to the efficiency of a single elongated telomere (Figure 4B, lines 4 and 5). Taken together, these data indicate the absence of interaction among the telomeres of homologs that could promote the repressed state and provide an additional compelling argument that the heritability of the repressed state functions intramolecularly (in cis) to promote hyperrepression.

Telomere elongation overcomes the requirement for yCAF-1:
Recent experiments have demonstrated that mutations in any one of the three subunits (CAC1, CAC2, and CAC3) of the yeast chromatin assembly factor I (yCAF-1) cause a significant reduction in telomeric silencing (ENOMOTO et al. 1997 ; KAUFMAN et al. 1997 ; MONSON et al. 1997 ). At a VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomere, each of the cac mutants abrogate the formation of wild-type-size 5-FOA^r colonies, but produce 5-FOA^r microcolonies at a frequency of 0.25% (KAUFMAN et al. 1997 ; data not shown). A previous study using single-cell analysis indicated that cac1 mutants have a decreased probability of inheritance of the repressed state from preexisting repressed cells (MONSON et al. 1997 ). The cac mutants can also produce an unstable repressed state at HML that is poorly maintained. This is a probable reflection of a CAF-1 requirement in maintaining the continual deposition of histones during heterochromatin formation (ENOMOTO et al. 1997 ; KAUFMAN et al. 1997 ).

Is elongation-mediated heritability of the repressed state dependent on yCAF-1? To test this, we first examined the effect of the cac1 and cac2 null mutations on telomeric silencing at the VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomere. Interestingly, unlike the effect of this mutation at other sites, silencing at the ADE2 gene adjacent to both wild-type-length and elongated telomeres is CAC1- and CAC2-independent (Figure 5). Rather, the extent of propagation of silencing from the ADE2 gene into the URA3 gene (2.5%) in wild-type cells carrying wild-type-length telomeres was reduced 150-fold in cac1 and cac2 cells. In contrast, CAC1 cells containing elongated telomeres displayed 39% propagation, which decreased only 2-fold in cac1 and cac2 mutant cells (Figure 5). Hence, propagation of the hyperrepressed state due to telomere elongation is CAC1- and CAC2-independent. In addition, microcolonies observed in cac1 and cac2 cells are abrogated in the presence of the elongated VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomere.

	DISCUSSION

TOP ABSTRACT MATERIALS AND METHODS RESULTS DISCUSSION LITERATURE CITED

In these studies, we have provided the first evidence for a role of telomere structure in cellular memory, specifically in the heritability of the "closed chromatin" adjacent to telomeres. This hypothesis is consistent with previous reports indicating that the HML silencer is required for heritability and repressed chromatin states in yeast (HOLMES and BROACH 1996 ; BI and BROACH 1997 ; ANSARI and GARTENBERG 1999 ). We have also found that the degree of propagation is associated with the increased heritability of the repressed state, suggesting that heritability and spreading may be functionally interrelated rather than distinct steps in silencing.

The system that we used to assay heritability and propagation was a comparison of these parameters in cells containing wild-type-length or elongated VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomeres. Using this assay, we found that telomere elongation leads to an increase in both heritability and propagation. This process acts on the elongated telomere in cis and, unlike wild-type-length telomeres, is independent of CAF-1.

The possibility that elongated telomere-mediated hyperrepression operates in a distinct pathway of telomeric silencing is highly unlikely, as silencing remains dependent on the Rap1 C terminus, Sir2p, Sir3p, and Sir4p (LI 1998 ). High levels of silencing are not sufficient to promote heritability and propagation, because tethering of LexA-Sir3p at the subtelomeric/telomeric junction did not display either phenotype. Thus, telomere length is likely to regulate the factors and/or structures that are necessary for both heritability and propagation of the repressed state.

This increased inheritance and propagation appears to require the continued presence of the elongated telomere. This conclusion is based on the finding that rapid deletion of a VIIL:: URA3/ADE2-marked telomere to wild-type length also abrogates hyperrepression (see Figure 4B; LI and LUSTIG 1996 ). Rapid deletion is an intrachromatid recombination process that can delete elongated telomere tract sequences to near wild-type length in <20 generations (LI and LUSTIG 1996 ).

An alternative, albeit less likely possibility, is that the experimental procedure for measuring the stability of the repressed state may produce a bias for a subset of cells. Because propagation is measured as the percentage of repressed telomere-proximal genes (i.e., ADE2 genes) that are also repressed in distal genes (i.e., URA3 genes), growth on 5-FOA media in the heritability assays may select for those cells that are propagated to greater distances. In this scenario, the high levels of 5-FOA resistance in the absence of subsequent selection would suggest the presence of a molecular memory of the propagated state.

Our data suggest that telomere length affects the stability of the repressed state in cis rather than in trans. This study therefore argues against any strong negative transvection effect at the telomere that may occur through the communication between homologs or nonhomologs. It also argues against titration of a limiting factor at the telomere.

These in cis effects are particularly intriguing given the numerous instances in which telomeric processes (acting in trans) are dependent upon associations with either other telomeres or telomere-associating factors (COCKELL et al. 1998 ; LUSTIG 1998 ). For example, recombinational telomeric rapid deletion displays a strong dependence on the length of other telomeres in the cell (LI and LUSTIG 1996 ). In addition, silencing appears to require sequestration of telomeres and silencing factors to a specific nuclear location mediated through in trans effects among telomeres and telomeric factors (GOTTA et al. 1996 ; MAILLET et al. 1996 ; MARCAND et al. 1996 ). In addition, the creation of double-strand DNA breaks induces the exchange of silencing factors from the telomeres to double-strand breaks (MARTIN et al. 1999 ; MILLS et al. 1999 ). The in cis effect that we observe contrasts with the HMR locus in diploid cells. At HMR, the level of repression appears to be controlled by cell type rather than by a mechanism acting independently on the two homologs (SUSSEL et al. 1993 ).

In our experiments, cac1 and cac2 mutants had no effect on the repression of the telomere-proximal ADE2 gene on the left arm of chromosome VII. The major effects of mutations in cac1 and cac2 cells are on the propagation of silencing from the ADE2 gene into the URA3 gene at a wild-type-length VIIL:: URA3/ADE2 as well as the formation of microcolonies. The reason for the diminished effects of cac mutations on telomeric silencing mutants, observed in other studies (e.g., KAUFMAN et al. 1997 ), is as yet unclear. However, it has been previously noted that telomeric silencing is context- and gene-specific, and possibly dependent on the chromatin structure of each terminus (GOTTSCHLING et al. 1990 ; MONSON et al. 1997 ).

How can telomere length influence transcriptional heritability? Our data at present appear to best fit a structural model for the heritability of the repressed state. In this model, a telomeric structural switch, formed in cis late in DNA replication, triggers the formation of highly stable and specialized subtelomeric chromatin that may confer the greater heritability of the repressed state. We propose that structures produced by elongated telomeres in yeast may form such a structural switch efficiently. Hence, the relative stability of telomeric length through DNA replication may provide the cellular memory in silencing. The extent of the telomere-induced stability on subtelomeric chromatin may then promote the propagation of silencing. The structural switch model is also consistent with the lack of a linear correlation between silencing and telomere length that would be expected from a purely length-mediated process (KYRION et al. 1993 ).

One of the subtelomeric structures that may be formed is a fold-back structure, mediated through interactions between telomeric and subtelomeric factors (GRUNSTEIN 1997 ). Clearly, other more complex telomeric/subtelomeric associations are also conceivable. Regardless, the formation of this stable structure could act as an intramolecular "lock," preventing association and dissociation of silencing factors, as well as preventing further competition with activators in the G2/M phase of the cell cycle (APARICIO and GOTTSCHLING 1994 ). A similar scenario may occur at wild-type telomeres, except that the rate and/or stability of the structure may be significantly reduced. In this model, elongated telomeres and yCAF-1, possibly targeted by PCNA (KRUDE 1999 ; SHIBAHARA and STILLMAN 1999 ), might act redundantly late in DNA replication in the formation or stabilization of the optimum structure for silencing (FERGUSON et al. 1991 ; FERGUSON and FANGMAN 1992 ).

In summary, the structure of telomeres plays a major role in modulating the heritability of adjacent closed chromatin states. This may well reflect a more general role for the structure of repetitive regions in the formation of heterochromatin. This stands in contrast to some alternative forms of cellular memory in higher eukaryotes that involve the covalent modification of DNA (MARTIENSSEN and RICHARDS 1995 ). The behavior of telomeres in higher eukaryotic cellular memory will be an important area for future investigation.

	ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

We thank E. B. Hoffman, P. Kaufman, D. Levens, T. de Lange, H. Wyatt, and other members of my laboratory for critical comments on the manuscript. We also thank P. Kaufman for sharing his unpublished strains. These studies were supported by National Science Foundation grant MCB-9604194.

Manuscript received July 30, 1999; Accepted for publication October 20, 1999.

	LITERATURE CITED

TOP ABSTRACT MATERIALS AND METHODS RESULTS DISCUSSION LITERATURE CITED

ANSARI, A. and M. R. GARTENBERG, 1999  Persistence of an alternate chromatin structure at silenced loci in vitro. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 96:343-348[Abstract/Free Full Text].

APARICIO, O. and D. GOTTSCHLING, 1994  Modifiers of position effect are shared between telomeric and silent mating-type loci in S. cerevisiae. Genes Dev. 8:1133-1146[Abstract/Free Full Text].

AUSTRIACO, N. R. and L. P. GUARENTE, 1997  Changes of telomere length cause reciprocal changes in the lifespan of mother cells in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci USA 94:9768-9772[Abstract/Free Full Text].

BI, X. and J. R. BROACH, 1997  DNA in transcriptionally silent chromatin assumes a distinct topology that is sensitive to cell cycle progression. Mol. Cell. Biol. 17:7077-7087[Abstract].

BRAUNSTEIN, M., A. ROSE, S. HOLMES, C. ALLIS, and J. BROACH, 1993  Transcriptional silencing in yeast is associated with reduced nucleosome acetylation. Genes Dev. 7:592-604[Abstract/Free Full Text].

BUCK, S. and D. SHORE, 1995  Action of a RAP1 carboxy-terminal silencing domain reveals an underlying competition between HMR and telomeres in yeast. Genes Dev. 9:370-384[Abstract/Free Full Text].

COCKELL, M., F. PALLADINO, T. LAROCHE, G. KYRION, and C. LIU et al., 1995  The carboxy termini of Sir4 and Rap1 affect Sir3 localization: evidence for a multi-component complex required for yeast telomeric silencing. J. Cell Biol. 129:909-924[Abstract/Free Full Text].

COCKELL, M., M. GOTTA, F. PALLADINO, S. G. MARTIN, and S. M. GASSER, 1998  Targeting Sir proteins to sites of action: a general mechanism for regulated repression. Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quant. Biol. 63:401-412[Medline].

ENOMOTO, S., P. D. MCCUNE-ZIERATH, M. GERAMI-NEJAD, M. A. SANDERS, and J. BERMAN, 1997  Chromatin assembly factor I contributes to the maintenance, but not the re-establishment, of silencing at the yeast silent mating loci. Genes Dev. 11:358-370[Abstract/Free Full Text].

FERGUSON, B. and W. FANGMAN, 1992  A position effect on the time of replication origin activation in yeast. Cell 68:333-339[Medline].

FERGUSON, B., B. BREWER, A. REYNOLDS, and W. FANGMAN, 1991  A yeast origin of replication is activated late in S phase. Cell 65:507-515[Medline].

FOUREL, G., E. REVARDEL, C. E. KOERING, and E. GILSON, 1999  Cohabitation of insulators and silencing elements in yeast subtelomeric regions. EMBO J. 18:2522-2537[Medline].

GAME, J. C. and P. D. KAUFMAN, 1999  Role of Saccharomyces cerevisiae chromatin assembly factor-I in repair of ultraviolet radiation damage in vivo. Genetics 151:485-497[Abstract/Free Full Text].

GEDVILAITE, A. and K. SASNAUSKAS, 1994  Control of the expression of the ADE2 gene of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae.. Curr. Genet. 25:475-479[Medline].

GOTTA, M., T. LAROCHE, A. FORMENTON, L. MAILLET, and H. SCHERTHAN et al., 1996  The clustering of telomeres and colocalization with Rap1, Sir3, and Sir4 proteins in wild-type Saccharomyces cerevisiae.. J. Cell Biol. 134:1349-1363[Abstract/Free Full Text].

GOTTA, M., S. STRAHL-BOLSINGER, H. RENAULD, T. LAROCHE, and B. KENNEDY et al., 1997  Localization of Sir2p: the nucleolus as a compartment for silent information regulators. EMBO J. 16:3243-3255[Medline].

GOTTSCHLING, D., 1992  Telomere-proximal DNA in Saccharomyces cerevisiae is refractory to methyltransferase activity in vivo. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 89:4062-4065[Abstract/Free Full Text].

GOTTSCHLING, D., O. APARICIO, B. BILLINGTON, and V. A. ZAKIAN, 1990  Position effect at S. cerevisiae telomeres: reversible repression of Pol II transcription. Cell 63:751-762[Medline].

GRUNSTEIN, M., 1997  Molecular model for telomeric heterochromatin in yeast. Nature 389:349-352[Medline].

HECHT, A., T. LAROCHE, S. STRAHL-BOLSINGER, S. M. GASSER, and M. GRUNSTEIN, 1995  Histone H3 and H4 N-termini interact with the silent information regulators Sir3 and Sir4: a molecular model for the formation of heterochromatin in yeast. Cell 80:583-592[Medline].

HECHT, A., S. STRAHL-BOLSINGER, and M. GRUNSTEIN, 1996  Spreading of transcriptional repressor SIR3 from telomeric heterochromatin. Nature 383:92-96[Medline].

HENIKOFF, S., 1996  Dosage-dependent modification of positioneffect variegation in Drosophila. Bioessays 18:401-409[Medline].

HOLMES, S. G. and J. R. BROACH, 1996  Silencers are required for inheritance of the repressed state in yeast. Genes Dev. 10:1021-1032[Abstract/Free Full Text].

HUANG, H., J. Y. HONG, C. L. BURCK, and S. W. LIEBMAN, 1999  Host genes that affect the target-site distribution of the yeast retrotransposon Ty1. Genetics 151:1393-1407[Abstract/Free Full Text].

KAUFMAN, P. D., R. KOBAYASHI, N. KESSLER, and B. STILLMAN, 1995  The p150 and p60 subunits of chromatin assembly factor I: a molecular link between newly synthesized histones and DNA replication. Cell 81:1105-1114[Medline].

KAUFMAN, P. D., R. KOBAYASHI, and B. STILLMAN, 1997  Ultraviolet radiation sensitivity and reduction of telomeric silencing in Saccharomyces cerevisiae cells lacking chromatin assembly factor-I. Genes Dev. 11:345-357[Abstract/Free Full Text].

KENNEDY, B. K., M. GOTTA, D. A. SINCLAIR, K. MILLS, and D. S. MCNABB et al., 1997  Redistribution of silencing proteins from telomeres to the nucleolus is associated with extension of life span in S. cerevisiae. Cell 89:381-391[Medline].

KRUDE, T., 1999  Chromatin replication: finding the right connection. Curr. Biol. 9:R394-R396[Medline].

KURTZ, S. and D. SHORE, 1991  RAP1 protein activates and silences transcription of mating-type genes in yeast. Genes Dev. 5:616-628[Abstract/Free Full Text].

KYRION, G., K. BOAKYE, and A. J. LUSTIG, 1992  C-terminal truncation of RAP1 results in the deregulation of telomere size, stability, and function in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.. Mol. Cell. Biol. 12:5159-5173[Abstract/Free Full Text].

KYRION, G., K. LIU, C. LIU, and A. J. LUSTIG, 1993  RAP1 and telomere structure regulate telomere position effects in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.. Genes Dev. 7:1146-1159[Abstract/Free Full Text].

LI, B., 1998 The regulation of telomere size in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Ph.D. Dissertation, Cornell University School of Medicine, New York.

LI, B. and A. J. LUSTIG, 1996  A novel mechanism for telomere size control in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.. Genes Dev. 10:1310-1326[Abstract/Free Full Text].

LIU, C., X. MAO, and A. J. LUSTIG, 1994  Mutational analysis defines a C-terminal tail domain of Rap1 essential for telomeric silencing in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.. Genetics 138:1025-1040[Abstract].

LIU, C. and A. J. LUSTIG, 1996  Genetic analysis of Rap1p/Sir3p interactions in telomeric and HML silencing in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.. Genetics 143:81-93[Abstract].

LOO, S. and J. RINE, 1995  Silencing and heritable domains of gene expression. Annu. Rev. Cell Biol. 11:519-548[Medline].

LUSTIG, A. J., 1998  Mechanisms of silencing in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.. Curr. Opin. Genet. Dev. 8:233-239[Medline].

LUSTIG, A. J., C. LIU, C. ZHANG, and J. HANISH, 1996  Tethered Sir3p nucleates silencing at telomeres and internal loci in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.. Mol. Cell. Biol. 16:2483-2495[Abstract].

MAILLET, L., C. BOSCHERON, M. GOTTA, S. MARCAND, and E. GILSON et al., 1996  The distribution of Sir proteins and proximity to telomeres modulate silencer-mediated repression in yeast. Genes Dev. 10:1796-1811[Abstract/Free Full Text].

MARCAND, S., S. W. BUCK, P. MORETTI, E. GILSON, and D. SHORE, 1996  Silencing of genes at nontelomeric sites in yeast is controlled by sequestration of silencing factors at telomeres by Rap1 protein. Genes Dev. 10:1297-1303[Abstract/Free Full Text].

MARTIENSSEN, R. A. and E. J. RICHARDS, 1995  DNA methylation in eukaryotes. Curr. Opin. Genet. Dev. 5:234-242[Medline].

MARTIN, S. G., T. LAROCHE, N. SUKA, M. GRUNSTEIN, and S. M. GASSER, 1999  Relocalization of telomeric Ku and SIR proteins in response to DNA strand breaks in yeast. Cell 97:621-633[Medline].

MILLS, K. D., D. A. SINCLAIR, and L. GUARENTE, 1999  MEC1-dependent redistribution of the Sir3 silencing protein from telomeres to DNA double-strand breaks. Cell 97:609-620[Medline].

MONSON, E. K., D. DE BRUIN, and V. A. ZAKIAN, 1997  The yeast Cac1 protein is required for the stable inheritance of transcriptionally repressed chromatin at telomeres. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 94:13081-13086[Abstract/Free Full Text].

MORETTI, P., K. FREEMAN, L. COODLEY, and D. SHORE, 1994  Evidence that a complex of SIR proteins interacts with the silencer and telomere binding protein RAP1. Genes Dev. 8:2257-2269[Abstract/Free Full Text].

PARK, Y., J. HANISH, and A. J. LUSTIG, 1998  Sir3p domains involved in the initiation of telomeric silencing in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.. Genetics 150:977-986[Abstract/Free Full Text].

PILLUS, L. and J. RINE, 1989  Epigenetic inheritance of transcriptional states in S. cerevisiae. Cell 59:637-647[Medline].

PRYDE, F. E. and E. J. LOUIS, 1999  Limitations of silencing at native yeast telomeres. EMBO J. 18:2538-2550[Medline].

QIAN, Z., H. HUANG, J. Y. HONG, C. L. BURCK, and S. D. JOHNSTON et al., 1998  Yeast Ty1 retrotransposition is stimulated by a synergistic interaction between mutations in chromatin assembly factor I and histone regulatory proteins. Mol. Cell. Biol. 18:4783-4792[Abstract/Free Full Text].

RENAULD, H., O. APARICIO, P. ZIERATH, B. BILLINGTON, and S. CHHABLANI et al., 1993  Silent domains are assembled continuously from the telomere and are defined by promoter distance and strength, and SIR3 dosage. Genes Dev. 7:1133-1145[Abstract/Free Full Text].

SHIBAHARA, K. and B. STILLMAN, 1999  Replication-dependent marking of DNA by PCNA facilitates CAF-1 coupled inheritance of chromatin. Cell 96:575-585[Medline].

SINCLAIR, D. A., K. MILLS, and L. GUARENTE, 1997  Accelerated aging and nucleolar fragmentation in yeast sgs1 mutants. Science 277:1313-1316[Abstract/Free Full Text].

SMITH, J. S., E. CAPUTO, and J. D. BOEKE, 1999  A genetic screen for ribosomal DNA silencing defects identifies multiple DNA replication and chromatin-modulating factors. Mol. Cell. Biol. 19:3184-3197[Abstract/Free Full Text].

STRAHL-BOLSINGER, S., A. HECHT, K. LUO, and M. GRUNSTEIN, 1997  SIR2 and SIR4 interactions differ in core and extended telomeric heterochromatin in yeast. Genes Dev. 11:83-93[Abstract/Free Full Text].

SUSSEL, L., D. VANNIER, and D. SHORE, 1993  Epigenetic switching of transcriptional states: cis- and trans-acting factors affecting establishment of silencing at the HMR locus in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.. Mol. Cell. Biol. 13:3919-3928[Abstract/Free Full Text].

VEGA-PALAS, M. A., S. VENDITTI, and E. DIMAURO, 1997  Telomeric transcriptional silencing in a natural context. Nat. Genet. 15:231-233[Medline].

WRIGHT, J., D. GOTTSCHLING, and V. A. ZAKIAN, 1992  Saccharomyces telomeres assume a non-nucleosomal chromatin structure. Genes Dev. 6:197-210[Abstract/Free Full Text].

This article has been cited by other articles:

				H. Liaw and A. J. Lustig Sir3 C-Terminal Domain Involvement in the Initiation and Spreading of Heterochromatin Mol. Cell. Biol., October 15, 2006; 26(20): 7616 - 7631. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

M. Livingstone-Zatchej, R. Marcionelli, K. Moller, R. de Pril, and F. Thoma Repair of UV Lesions in Silenced Chromatin Provides in Vivo Evidence for a Compact Chromatin Structure J. Biol. Chem., September 26, 2003; 278(39): 37471 - 37479. [Abstract]