Quantitative Trait Locus (QTL) Mapping Using Different Testers and Independent Population Samples in Maize Reveals Low Power of QTL Detection and Large Bias in Estimates of QTL Effects

Corresponding author: Albrecht E. Melchinger, Institute of Plant Breeding, Seed Science and Population Genetics, University of Hohenheim, 70593 Stuttgart, Germany, melchinger{at}uni-hohenheim.de (E-mail).

Communicating editor: Z-B. ZENG

The efficiency of marker-assisted selection (MAS) depends on the power of quantitative trait locus (QTL) detection and unbiased estimation of QTL effects. Two independent samples (N = 344 and 107) of F₂ plants were genotyped for 89 RFLP markers. For each sample, testcross (TC) progenies of the corresponding F₃ lines with two testers were evaluated in four environments. QTL for grain yield and other agronomically important traits were mapped in both samples. QTL effects were estimated from the same data as used for detection and mapping of QTL (calibration) and, based on QTL positions from calibration, from the second, independent sample (validation). For all traits and both testers we detected a total of 107 QTL with N = 344, and 39 QTL with N = 107, of which only 20 were in common. Consistency of QTL effects across testers was in agreement with corresponding genotypic correlations between the two TC series. Most QTL displayed no significant QTL x environment nor epistatic interactions. Estimates of the proportion of the phenotypic and genetic variance explained by QTL were considerably reduced when derived from the independent validation sample as opposed to estimates from the calibration sample. We conclude that, unless QTL effects are estimated from an independent sample, they can be inflated, resulting in an overly optimistic assessment of the efficiency of MAS.

This article has been cited by other articles:

				D. Manicacci, L. Camus-Kulandaivelu, M. Fourmann, C. Arar, S. Barrault, A. Rousselet, N. Feminias, L. Consoli, L. Frances, V. Mechin, et al. Epistatic Interactions between Opaque2 Transcriptional Activator and Its Target Gene CyPPDK1 Control Kernel Trait Variation in Maize Plant Physiology, May 1, 2009; 150(1): 506 - 520. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				S. Garcia-Lara, M. M. Khairallah, M. Vargas, and D. J. Bergvinson Mapping of QTL Associated with Maize Weevil Resistance in Tropical Maize Crop Sci., January 28, 2009; 49(1): 139 - 149. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				H. C. Rowe and D. J. Kliebenstein Complex Genetics Control Natural Variation in Arabidopsis thaliana Resistance to Botrytis cinerea Genetics, December 1, 2008; 180(4): 2237 - 2250. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				B. C.Y Collard and D. J Mackill Marker-assisted selection: an approach for precision plant breeding in the twenty-first century Phil Trans R Soc B, February 12, 2008; 363(1491): 557 - 572. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				R. Tuberosa, S. Salvi, S. Giuliani, M. C. Sanguineti, M. Bellotti, S. Conti, and P. Landi Genome-wide Approaches to Investigate and Improve Maize Response to Drought Crop Sci., December 18, 2007; 47(Supplement_3): S-120 - S-141. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				L. A. Robertson-Hoyt, C. E. Kleinschmidt, D. G. White, G. A. Payne, C. M. Maragos, and J. B. Holland Relationships of Resistance to Fusarium Ear Rot and Fumonisin Contamination with Agronomic Performance of Maize Crop Sci., September 1, 2007; 47(5): 1770 - 1778. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				B. Stich, J. Yu, A. E. Melchinger, H.-P. Piepho, H. F. Utz, H. P. Maurer, and E. S. Buckler Power to Detect Higher-Order Epistatic Interactions in a Metabolic Pathway Using a New Mapping Strategy Genetics, May 1, 2007; 176(1): 563 - 570. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				E. Frascaroli, M. A. Cane, P. Landi, G. Pea, L. Gianfranceschi, M. Villa, M. Morgante, and M. E. Pe Classical Genetic and Quantitative Trait Loci Analyses of Heterosis in a Maize Hybrid Between Two Elite Inbred Lines Genetics, May 1, 2007; 176(1): 625 - 644. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				S. Xu and Z. Jia Genomewide Analysis of Epistatic Effects for Quantitative Traits in Barley Genetics, April 1, 2007; 175(4): 1955 - 1963. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				K. Harris, P. Subudhi, A. Borrell, D. Jordan, D. Rosenow, H. Nguyen, P. Klein, R. Klein, and J. Mullet Sorghum stay-green QTL individually reduce post-flowering drought-induced leaf senescence J. Exp. Bot., January 1, 2007; 58(2): 327 - 338. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				B. Bennett, P. Carosone-Link, N. R. Zahniser, and T. E. Johnson Confirmation and Fine Mapping of Ethanol Sensitivity Quantitative Trait Loci, and Candidate Gene Testing in the LXS Recombinant Inbred Mice J. Pharmacol. Exp. Ther., October 1, 2006; 319(1): 299 - 307. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				D. Zhong, D. M. Menge, E. A. Temu, H. Chen, and G. Yan Amplified Fragment Length Polymorphism Mapping of Quantitative Trait Loci for Malaria Parasite Susceptibility in the Yellow Fever Mosquito Aedes aegypti Genetics, July 1, 2006; 173(3): 1337 - 1345. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				L. A. Robertson-Hoyt, M. P. Jines, P. J. Balint-Kurti, C. E. Kleinschmidt, D. G. White, G. A. Payne, C. M. Maragos, T. L. Molnar, and J. B. Holland QTL Mapping for Fusarium Ear Rot and Fumonisin Contamination Resistance in Two Maize Populations Crop Sci., June 20, 2006; 46(4): 1734 - 1743. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				F. Breseghello and M. E. Sorrells Association Analysis as a Strategy for Improvement of Quantitative Traits in Plants Crop Sci., April 25, 2006; 46(3): 1323 - 1330. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				J. Cuartero, M. C. Bolarin, M. J. Asins, and V. Moreno Increasing salt tolerance in the tomato J. Exp. Bot., March 1, 2006; 57(5): 1045 - 1058. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				S. J. Yun, L. Gyenis, P. M. Hayes, I. Matus, K. P. Smith, B. J. Steffenson, and G. J. Muehlbauer Quantitative Trait Loci for Multiple Disease Resistance in Wild Barley Crop Sci., October 27, 2005; 45(6): 2563 - 2572. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				R. Mihaljevic, H. F. Utz, and A. E. Melchinger No Evidence for Epistasis in Hybrid and Per Se Performance of Elite European Flint Maize Inbreds from Generation Means and QTL Analyses Crop Sci., October 27, 2005; 45(6): 2605 - 2613. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				F. Hospital Selection in backcross programmes Phil Trans R Soc B, July 29, 2005; 360(1459): 1503 - 1511. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				D. Zhong, A. Pai, and G. Yan Costly Resistance to Parasitism: Evidence From Simultaneous Quantitative Trait Loci Mapping for Resistance and Fitness in Tribolium castaneum Genetics, April 1, 2005; 169(4): 2127 - 2135. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				R. Mihaljevic, C. C. Schon, H. F. Utz, and A. E. Melchinger Correlations and QTL Correspondence between Line Per Se and Testcross Performance for Agronomic Traits in Four Populations of European Maize Crop Sci., January 1, 2005; 45(1): 114 - 122. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				J.-M. Lacape, T.-B. Nguyen, B. Courtois, J.-L. Belot, M. Giband, J.-P. Gourlot, G. Gawryziak, S. Roques, and B. Hau QTL Analysis of Cotton Fiber Quality Using Multiple Gossypium hirsutum x Gossypium barbadense Backcross Generations Crop Sci., January 1, 2005; 45(1): 123 - 140. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				D. W. Podlich, C. R. Winkler, and M. Cooper Mapping As You Go: An Effective Approach for Marker-Assisted Selection of Complex Traits Crop Sci., September 1, 2004; 44(5): 1560 - 1571. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				V. A. Fasoula, D. K. Harris, and H. R. Boerma Validation and Designation of Quantitative Trait Loci for Seed Protein, Seed Oil, and Seed Weight from Two Soybean Populations Crop Sci., July 1, 2004; 44(4): 1218 - 1225. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				K. D. Glover, D. Wang, P. R. Arelli, S. R. Carlson, S. R. Cianzio, and B. W. Diers Near Isogenic Lines Confirm a Soybean Cyst Nematode Resistance Gene from PI 88788 on Linkage Group J Crop Sci., May 1, 2004; 44(3): 936 - 941. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				R. Mihaljevic, H. F. Utz, and A. E. Melchinger Congruency of Quantitative Trait Loci Detected for Agronomic Traits in Testcrosses of Five Populations of European Maize Crop Sci., January 1, 2004; 44(1): 114 - 124. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				G. R. Brown, D. L. Bassoni, G. P. Gill, J. R. Fontana, N. C. Wheeler, R. A. Megraw, M. F. Davis, M. M. Sewell, G. A. Tuskan, and D. B. Neale Identification of Quantitative Trait Loci Influencing Wood Property Traits in Loblolly Pine (Pinus taeda L.). III. QTL Verification and Candidate Gene Mapping Genetics, August 1, 2003; 164(4): 1537 - 1546. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				A. J. Castro, X. Chen, P. M. Hayes, and M. Johnston Pyramiding Quantitative Trait Locus (QTL) Alleles Determining Resistance to Barley Stripe Rust: Effects on Resistance at the Seedling Stage Crop Sci., March 1, 2003; 43(2): 651 - 659. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				G. M. Timmerman-Vaughan, T. J. Frew, A. C. Russell, T. Khan, R. Butler, M. Gilpin, S. Murray, and K. Falloon QTL Mapping of Partial Resistance to Field Epidemics of Ascochyta Blight of Pea Crop Sci., November 1, 2002; 42(6): 2100 - 2111. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				R. TUBEROSA, S. SALVI, M. C. SANGUINETI, P. LANDI, M. MACCAFERRI, and S. CONTI Mapping QTLs Regulating Morpho-physiological Traits and Yield: Case Studies, Shortcomings and Perspectives in Drought-stressed Maize Ann. Bot., June 15, 2002; 89(7): 941 - 963. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				S. A. Goff, D. Ricke, T.-H. Lan, G. Presting, R. Wang, M. Dunn, J. Glazebrook, A. Sessions, P. Oeller, H. Varma, et al. A Draft Sequence of the Rice Genome (Oryza sativa L. ssp. japonica) Science, April 5, 2002; 296(5565): 92 - 100. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				G. G. Yousef and J. A. Juvik Enhancement of Seedling Emergence in Sweet Corn by Marker-Assisted Backcrossing of Beneficial QTL Crop Sci., January 1, 2002; 42(1): 96 - 104. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				R. D. Ball Bayesian Methods for Quantitative Trait Loci Mapping Based on Model Selection: Approximate Analysis Using the Bayesian Information Criterion Genetics, November 1, 2001; 159(3): 1351 - 1364. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				A. L. Fall, P. F. Byrne, G. Jung, D. P. Coyne, M. A. Brick, and H. F. Schwartz Detection and Mapping of a Major Locus for Fusarium Wilt Resistance in Common Bean Crop Sci., September 1, 2001; 41(5): 1494 - 1498. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				M. G. Turri, N. D. Henderson, J. C. DeFries, and J. Flint Quantitative Trait Locus Mapping in Laboratory Mice Derived From a Replicated Selection Experiment for Open-Field Activity Genetics, July 1, 2001; 158(3): 1217 - 1226. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				V. Mechin, O. Argillier, Y. Hebert, E. Guingo, L. Moreau, A. Charcosset, and Y. Barriere Genetic Analysis and QTL Mapping of Cell Wall Digestibility and Lignification in Silage Maize Crop Sci., May 1, 2001; 41(3): 690 - 697. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				A. J. Cardinal, M. Lee, N. Sharopova, W. L. Woodman-Clikeman, and M. J. Long Genetic Mapping and Analysis of Quantitative Trait Loci for Resistance to Stalk Tunneling by the European Corn Borer in Maize Crop Sci., May 1, 2001; 41(3): 835 - 845. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				P. N. Miklas, W. C. Johnson, R. Delorme, and P. Gepts QTL Conditioning Physiological Resistance and Avoidance to White Mold in Dry Bean Crop Sci., March 1, 2001; 41(2): 309 - 315. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

				H.-P. Piepho and H. G. Gauch , Jr. Marker Pair Selection for Mapping Quantitative Trait Loci Genetics, January 1, 2001; 157(1): 433 - 444. [Abstract] [Full Text]

				H.-P. Piepho A Mixed-Model Approach to Mapping Quantitative Trait Loci in Barley on the Basis of Multiple Environment Data Genetics, December 1, 2000; 156(4): 2043 - 2050. [Abstract] [Full Text]

				P. Hurme, M. J. Sillanpää, E. Arjas, T. Repo, and O. Savolainen Genetic Basis of Climatic Adaptation in Scots Pine by Bayesian Quantitative Trait Locus Analysis Genetics, November 1, 2000; 156(3): 1309 - 1322. [Abstract] [Full Text]

				E. Igartua, M. Edney, B.G. Rossnagel, D. Spaner, W.G. Legge, G J. Scoles, P.E. Eckstein, G.A. Penner, N.A. Tinker, K.G. Briggs, et al. Marker-Based Selection of QTL Affecting Grain and Malt Quality in Two-Row Barley Crop Sci., September 1, 2000; 40(5): 1426 - 1433. [Abstract] [Full Text]

				H. F. Utz, A. E. Melchinger, and C. C. Schön Bias and Sampling Error of the Estimated Proportion of Genotypic Variance Explained by Quantitative Trait Loci Determined From Experimental Data in Maize Using Cross Validation and Validation With Independent Samples Genetics, April 1, 2000; 154(4): 1839 - 1849. [Abstract] [Full Text]

				L. Moreau, S. Lemarié, A. Charcosset, and A. Gallais Economic Efficiency of One Cycle of Marker-Assisted Selection Crop Sci., March 1, 2000; 40(2): 329 - 337. [Abstract] [Full Text]

				T.G. Berke and T.R. Rocheford Quantitative Trait Loci for Tassel Traits in Maize Crop Sci., September 1, 1999; 39(5): 1439 - 1443. [Abstract] [Full Text]